UNSOLVED

me12

updated

26 years ago

M

me12

3 Posts

0

8983

January 25th, 2001 20:00

Power Supply Upgrade?

Does anyone know if any of the other Dell-manufactured power supplies can be used with a Dell Dimension system? For example, can a power supply from a Workstation 330 be used with a Dimension?
  • Jim Hardin

    2 Intern

    •

    2053 Posts

    323

    0

    Posted January 25th, 2001 21:00

    Unless you are planning to do some arc welding with it, you have more than enough power supply to keep you going.

    I don’t know who is putting out this ‘power supply envy’ nonsense…
  • me12

    3 Posts

    323

    0

    Posted January 25th, 2001 23:00

    Actually, this has nothing to do with 'power supply envy.' It is a known and tested fact that systems with a stronger power base tend to be much more stable. As you add new devices, i.e. disk drives and multimedia cards (as I have done), the power requirments across the motherboard rise. A power-hungry device (my Visiontek geForce 256 for example) can cause power-related crashes in applications such as gaming that require higher power usage by the CPU and other system devices. Upgrading the power supply would be the next logical step.
  • Ron55

    185 Posts

    323

    0

    Posted January 26th, 2001 01:00

    Go over to the Upgrade Hardware conference and browse around at some answers to posts and you will see a lot of guys with MEGA stuff hooked up to their systems. Most, if not all of them, are using the standard Dell 200 watt power supply.

    Also you can post this question there and I am sure the Power System gurus will tell you to save your money.

    Have a Good One...

    Ron

    Dimension L600r
    Pentium III 600EB MHz/133FSB (soon to be 1 GIG)
    Intel 810E Chipset
    256megs SDRAM
    Viewsonic GS771 17" Monitor
    Maxtor Ultra ATA (7200RPM) HD
    Sony CRX140E CD-RW
    Kensington Optical Pro 5 Button Mouse
    Microsoft Internet Keyboard
    OS: Win98se
  • 323

    0

    Posted January 26th, 2001 20:00

    Unless you are salvaging parts you may want to consider either an ANTEC or a Sparkle power supply (Antec-inc.com or sparklepower.com) A 300w antec with 160w on the +5v and 3.3v will set you back roughly $50 and the sparkle about the same if you shop around. If you do want to arc-weld you should really consider the Enermax Wavesonic made in Germany and endorsed by the Texas penal system --the 650 goes for $200 with 300w on the 5v and 3.3v, aside from welding and frying it is also good with raid set-ups, dual-processors and displacing ps-envy to others. Of course any of these choices will void your warranty and if your system is performing and you have a real good ups system, then so long as the fuse relay works your Dell ps won't damage your system, just occassionally brown-out if it is really really pressed. (When it does decide to die watch out -- "brain-attack" comes to mind).

    Coincidentally when looking to buy several new systems a Dell salesman also suggested the 330 as a very stable few-complaints product, however they do not recommend or support interchanging parts. But consider the source, this is the same salesman who believes the I3800 has got to be one of Dell's most reliable products--something about a basicly sound lattitude chassis which has survived independently run "torture" tests. Oviously he has to go back for regrooving if he is going to push new improved high margin hype with plastic multi-colored inserts (oops this isn't a laptop site).

    Depending upon which system and case you have, if you have a PIII all you would typically need is a supply certified to meet the ATX and Intel standard that fits your case (w/o arc welding), double check but I thought the salesman said that the 330 was an ATX system but you would need to go to the spec sheets to be sure (including the dimensions of the box) . The plugs are nearly (only nearly) fool proof and Dell's most excellent spec sheets for connections can be found on their web site assuming you avoid the Mr. Dud function. Some Dell cases are not knuckle friendly, there are several sites that sell these supplies on-line (see sharkyextreme.com for info) with cross-references to particular systems.

    No doubt Dell's ps should be sufficient for the system as shipped, for other examples of aftermarket power supplys.

    http://www.pcpowercooling.com/

    http://www.power-on.com/power-on/atxnlxmatx.html


    But the other respondents have a point. Put this matter to rest. Let your system run full out and if it crashes or bogs down please post how long you were on hold while you solved the problem on your own and then compare to what Dell proposes as a solution. Maybe their video card suppliers are all wrong and Dell's 200w supply is more than capable of supporting all the doodads being hung on it. I hope so, California needs and deserves your electricity!!!

    And, for a bit of flame:
    Power-supply envy? More like headache avoidance and getting a good value on a new buy vs. fixing an old machine.

    The power-supply is really just an easy indicator of whether or not over all product quality is being nickeled and dimed. But, for the heck of it, check out sharkyextreme.com or manufacturer support sites such as Hewlett Packard where they discuss ps issues in general. (HP has had big time issues in its 8600 mid-tower series) The video card manufacturers are also good for citing this issue in explaining why oem no name cards that they supply unexplainably bog down. Too many goodies not enough stability (--kinda like a certain overpriced SUV).

  • Lunkrhuntr

    34 Posts

    323

    0

    Posted January 26th, 2001 22:00

    The Dell 200W PS is as good if not better than most 250-300W PS's out there.