
UNSOLVED
No Surround Sound with Integrated Audio (SoundMax) on 8300
It seems that there are a number of messages regarding the absence of surround sound when using the SoundMax Integrated Audio. Nonetheless, I am experiencing the same problem. I can add a little more information, but I cannot resolve the issue and Dell Tech Support offered little help - In fact they said that I needed to contact the manufacturer of SoundMax and it wasn't their problem. Funny - The Motherboard I have is manufactured for Dell and they advertise 5.1 sound - Why am I supposed to contact the manufacturer. Anyway I am hoping that one of the Dell tech guru's who read these message boards can offer some help:
First problem: The drivers on DELL.COM for SoundMax are NOT the same as the one that was shipped with my computer and is not the same one that is on the Driver CD that came with my system. The driver on DELL.COM has a version number 5.12.1.3555 (4/29/2003) but the one on my system (and CD) Is 5.12.1.3650 (6/18/2003).
When I install 5.12.1.3555, I get audio out of all 5.1 speakers. However the audio does not appear to be surround - it sounds like the rear channels are producing the same audio as the front speaker. In fact if you use the Audio Control Panel and 'MUTE' the Center and/or Rear Channel, NOTHING happens. But if you 'MUTE' the front channel, All ofd the speakers get muted.
When I install 5.12.1.3650, I only get audio out of the Front Left and Right Speakers. I cannot get surround sound (no REAR or Front Center) with any games. HOWEVER, when I put in a DVD with a THX optimizer, I did get audio out of all 5.1 speakers and I think it is correct.
First question- Why is the driver on DELL.COM older then the driver that was shipped with my system?
Second: Why can't I get Surround out of anything other than DVD's?
Third: Why is the Advanced option in the Volume control Grey'd out (others have mentioned this as well)?
It looks like DELL may have put the old driver (3555) on the Download page so that people would hear sound out of all their speakers and be happy. I hope I am mistaken.
I think Cody was on to something when he suggested "Uncheck the boxes next to 1 6ch ->2ch (Down Mix) and 2 2ch -> 6ch (Spread).", but there appears to be something wrong with the driver and we cannot get to this option.
Please Help.
Thanks.
Message Edited by GFerrell on 01-06-2004 10:35 PM
Responses (36)
Solutions (0)
- - First question- Why is the driver on DELL.COM older then the driver that was shipped with my system?
The more recent drivers on your system may have been validated for shipment with new systems, but not verified for placement on the File Library for various reasons. I am requesting clarification on this from Dell Engineering.
- Second: Why can't I get Surround out of anything other than DVD's?
DVDs that contain a Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack will be played via the 5.1 surround outputs on your system. Most other normal audio is 2-channel, such as system sounds, games (that do not have realtime 5.1 audio), audio CDs, and MP3s; sound via these sources will only be output via the two front speakers.
- Third: Why is the Advanced option in the Volume control Grey'd out (others have mentioned this as well)?
This is another difference between drivers that I am currently requesting additional information about. Thank you for your patience.
- Dell chose this achitecture for their MB and sold it as 5.1 capable.
You are correct, and the onboard chipset is working as designed, as a DVD with a Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack plays back 5.1-channel sound.Message Edited by DELL-Cody on 01-07-2004 12:11 PM
I apprecieate your response and have a feeling that I am going to be an avid Creative Labs fan myself REAL soon!
Nonethelss, I beg to differ regarding you comment that Dell is not at fault; Dell chose this achitecture for their MB and sold it as 5.1 capable. It is their responsibility to get it to function as advertised. If I buy a car and the radio doesn't work, is it my job to contact the radio manufacturer to figure out why the thing isn't working? I bought a computer system, not individual parts from a bunch of manufacturers. If I wanted to do this, I would have built my own system from scratch.
Is anyone from Dell listening???????
Message Edited by GFerrell on 01-07-2004 11:25 AM
Cody - Awesome. I appreciate the response.
Let me make sure I completely understand:
- I cannot get Surround Sound out of any game using SoundMax and I can only get 5.1 sound from DVDs with a DD 5.1 Soundtrack, correct?
- If I want Surround Sound from games, I must purchase a Sound Card, such as one from SB?
- Is this how SoundMax is designed or is there a problem with the driver, that if fixed, may allow me to get 5.1 from Games?
Thanks again for responding.
Cody - Sorry - I wrote the last sentence of my response before I saw your explaination. But I guess I am still a little troubled. I not an avid gamer either (no time anymore) but I believe the games I am running do have Dobly Surround Sound. In fact, for Need For Speed III, it shows a "Surround Sound' Screen at the beginning, but still no surround sound.
Am I missing something simple?? I don't think the games I have tried have EAX or A3D, so I am still a bit confused.
The first thing to check is that you have the correct SoundMax driver. I was only able to get 5.12.1.3650 (6/18/2003) to work "correctly". Other than that - there isn't any magic involved. But this is how I verified the audio:
I found a DVD that had THX certified sound; "Finding Nemo" was handy at the time. Anyway, on this DVD there is a THX optimizer that helps you set up your Audio and Video for THX Optimization
. If you select the Audio test, White noise will be produced from each of the 5.1 speakers independently so that you can adjust the volume to optimal levels. Note that for Dolby Digital, the rear left and right speakers are not independent; the same sound is produced in both rear speakers. (For 7.1 however, the side right and side left ARE independent.) Someone correct me if I am wrong.
Also make sure in your Volume Control that the Center, Lfe and Rear speakers are "UNMUTED". If these options are not present, go into "options> properties" of the Volume Control and put checks next to Center, Lfe and Rear so that they show up. Also make sure that in the "Sound and Audio Control Devices" (In the Control Panel) under "Speaker Setting > Advanced" you have "5.1 Surround Sound Speakers" Selected.
Other than that, I didn't do anything special. I believe the 5.12.1.3650 driver works for DVD Dolby Digital 5.1 Decoding, but for games, that appears to be another issue.
Hope this helps. ...and if someone can give me a good explaination of why 5.1 doesn't work in games but does on DVDs, I would be quite appreciative!
- - I cannot get Surround Sound out of any game using SoundMax and I can only get 5.1 sound from DVDs with a DD 5.1 Soundtrack, correct?
If the game is capable of outputting true realtime 5.1 surround sound via a 5.1-capable audio device, you should be able to achieve 5.1-surround within that game. I am not an avid gamer, and do not currently have a list of games capable of true 5.1 surround sound. From what I have seen, most games achieve surround sound through some sort of effects processing technique, such as EAX or A3D.
- If I want Surround Sound from games, I must purchase a Sound Card, such as one from SB?
If the game in question is only capable of creating a 3D soundfield using a process such as EAX or A3D, you would need a sound solution with that functionality included. Creative Labs is the owner of the trademarked EAX process, and uses it with many of their boards and drivers.
- Is this how SoundMax is designed or is there a problem with the driver, that if fixed, may allow me to get 5.1 from Games?
The way in which the SoundMax onboard audio solution within your system is designed is to provide the same number of channels, up to 5.1, as the software in use provides. The onboard audio solution does not contain effects processors (such as EAX) that allow a surround output to be derived from a stereo source. - Thank you for the correction. I guess we have an additional problem then; I am quite sure that the audio out of the rear is NOT independent on the left and right channels. In fact, there was still a significant amount of audio out of the front speakers when only the rear speakers were supposed to have audio. I will recheck when I get home tonight to verify, but if this is the case, then Dolby 5.1 from DVDs isn't working as advertised either from Integrated Audio.......
Message Edited by GFerrell on 01-07-2004 01:55 PM
I do have the 3650 driver but don't have a DVD with the THX optimizer you suggested. I'll have to wait for Cody to respond on why the Adv Properties option is greyed out for all of us.
BTW on Dolby Digital 5.1, the rear surround channels are supposed to be independent, so you should get separate rear left and rear right audio. Dolby Pro-logic the precursor to Dolby Digital had the mono rear channel. The 5.1 represents 5 independent audio channels and .1 is the low frequency effect channel ie subwoofer.

lukejd87
118 Posts
742
0
Posted January 7th, 2004 05:00