
UNSOLVED
KO
Kevin Osiowy
13 Posts
0
7383
February 3rd, 2005 17:00
Lotsa BIOS questions Dimension 4500 upgraded w/Northwood 3.06Ghz CPU
Hello,
Hope there's a resident 4500 expert around to help me out. I went to Powerleap.com which has a nice little interactive utility which examines your system and recommends upgrade options for your machine. As a result of using their recommendations, I upgraded from the old 1,6Ghz Williamette processor I had to the Northwood 3.06Ghz which was the top end processor my 4500 apparently supports. At the same time, I upped my RAM from 512 megs to 1024 megs, which, again, is the limit the motherboard (D845EPT2 Rev AAA83422-105) will accept. I already had the latest BIOS (A04) on the machine so I didn't have to reflash it. When I fired up the machine after performing the upgrades, I began to sweat bullets because, while the POST information and RAID initialization flashed by at lightning speed, it took a looooong time for Windows to even begin to boot and from the time the initial Windows logo appeared to the appearance of the welcome screen there was a full 80 seconds of black screen! I was really disheartened, but once Windows finally did fully boot up, everything worked beautifully and the speed increase was breathtaking compared to what it was with the old processor. Maybe I should leave well enough alone and bear with the 2+ minute bootup, but common sense tells me that something must be wrong somewhere to cause an upgraded system to boot slower. I've fiddled with the BIOS boot settings, but no variations in the settings improve the bootup speed. My suspicion is that although the BIOS sees the new CPU just fine and also recognized the change from 400 to 533 in the FSB speed, it's struggling with the fact that the CPU has hyperthreading ability while the BIOS and board don't support HT. Now here's where my questions get real hairy...
Dell offers a BIOS (A06) for a model 4500C which, from what I have been able to gather from what I've read, is a variation of the 4500 marketed in Japan only. The info on the A06 BIOS states that one of its "fixes" specifically deals with the sporadic recognition of the 2nd processor for the 3.06 CPU in hyperthreading mode. I am well aware that you can toast your motherboard (or at least the BIOS chip) if you flash the wrong BIOS onto it, but I'm *real* tempted to try the A06 bios on my machine to see if it makes the slow boot go away and *maybe* even give me HT. How risky would that be? Does anyone know what the differences are between the 4500 and its Japanese cousin the 4500C?
As if I haven't already taxed your patience, here's some even hairier questions. On Intel's site, they offer 8 incremented BIOS versions for the D845EPT2 motherboard. The latest version (P08) disable hyperthreading for some reason, but an earlier version (P05) enabled HT and the next revision (P06) offered the option to enable or disable HT. I'm running XP Pro w/SP2, which I've read works well with HT while other versions of XP with or without SP1 often choke with HT. Intel warns that flashing their BIOS onto proprietary systems (like Dell) that use Intel boards might cause improper operation but I don't see any warnings about permanent damage as a possibility. So, again, I'm also real tempted to try one of the Intel BIOS flashes to see if, at the very least, the slow boot goes away, and at most, I wind up with an hyperthreading machine.Would I be playing with fire by doing so?
Last, but not least, I upgraded the graphics on my machine last month with a Radeon 9600 All-In-Wonder w/128megs. By default, the BIOS sets something called the video or graphics "aperture" to 64 megs. After wading through other graphics-related messages on the web, I'm confused because some people say that the "aperture" setting needs to be set to the amount of RAM actually on your video card while others recommend setting the aperture to 256 megs even if you only have 128 megs on your card. Can anyone clear up my confusion?
Thanks in advance for being patient enough to read all this and for any help anyone can offer.
Regards,
Kevin Osiowy
Responses (8)
Solutions (0)
Kevin Osiowy
13 Posts
499
0
Posted February 4th, 2005 00:00
Thanks for the quick reply Steve, but legacy USB support was already disabled and yanking the Sidewinder steering wheel and joystick out of my USB ports didn't improve the bootup speed. Guess I'll have to live with the slow boot until I can find a newer motherboard that I can swap my new CPU and memory into. Should be able to pick one up relatively cheap but I really hate to lose my Dell's diagnostic lights. They saved me a lot of time, aggravation and money once when my memory module suddenly developed a dirty/loose connection.
Kevin
- I'll see if I can help with a couple of more of your original questions.....An Intel BIOS flash.... although it may not damage your motherboard it will more than likely not fully support your proprietary Dell motherboard as owners of other Dell models have found out. The other problems you will encounter is that trying to flash back to the Dell BIOS version will be very difficult if not impossible and you will find that your Dell supplied CDs will no longer install on your system as they check for a Dell BIOS during the install.AGP Aperture... this setting sets aside an amount of system RAM to be used by the video when the video card's RAM needs the extra memory for processing. Although opinions vary on which setting is best, the most common recommendation is to set the AGP Aperture to one-half of the amount of system RAM you have installed. In otherwords if you have 512 megs or more of system RAM installed then the AGP Aperature would be set to 256.If I'm reading your posting correct, I am getting the impression that your system bogs down when the Windows logo first appears. If this is correct then I suspect your lag has nothing to do with the BIOS, but it is related to the operating system since the display of the Windows logo indicates that the BIOS has finished loading. You might want to post your problem in the Software - Windows XP forum to see what addtional suggestions your receive. There are utilities like your anti-virus program that will do a quick scan of the system while the logo is being displayed and it could be the cause of the added delay.
Kevin Osiowy
13 Posts
499
0
Posted February 5th, 2005 13:00
Thanks for replying Majestic!
About flashing with Intel BIOS, after reading just about every 4500-related posting on this site, it appears that if you flash a Dell system with an Intel BIOS, Dell makes it impossible to reflash with any Dell BIOS by somehow checking for an already installed Dell BIOS, and if it doesn't find one, it will not proceed with the flashing process. I can't help but wonder whether this "copy-protection" scheme is to protect users from screwing up their machines or if it's just a method Dell uses to force people to unnecessarily buy hardware upgrades when the systems they already have really can do more than the Dell BIOS allows them to do... I mean, how different can Dell's Intel-built boards really be if diagnostic software like Sisandra, Belarc and Inspec all report the Dell boards as specific Intel boards? I realize that those diags simply read the parameters of the chipset, but aside from Dell's asinine practice of removing/disabling environmental sensors, how really different can their board circuitry be from the Intel equivalent?
Based upon what you said as well as what I've gathered from reading about the subject elsewhere, I have changed the AGP aperture in BIOS to 256 since I now have a gig of system RAM installed.
The horrible bootup time I'm experiencing begins well before I see even the initial Windows XP logo (the logo with the black background and the sliding capsule thingy animation. However, since the POST and RAID initialization go by at warp speed (virtually impossible to read), like you, I now suspect that the slooooow bootup is likely due to some Windows initialization problem(s) rather than with the BIOS. I have no idea why a processor and memory upgrade would throw a monkey wrench into the Windows initialization process, but at this point, I'll probably wind up doing a clean reinstall of XP Pro to see what that does.
Ultimately, what I think I'll wind up doing sometime soon is to sniff around on Ebay for a used 4550 to replace my 4500. From what I understand, the 4550 along with the BIOS currently available for it, supports the 3.06 processor in hyperthreading mode and will also allow me to use my existing PC2100 RAM, so my expense will be limited to whatever a bare bones 4550 will cost me. I'd buy a new board from Dell, but I doubt if they still sell them.
If a reinstall of XP makes my bootup problems go away, I'll post an updated message here.
Kevin
- Regards to flashing the BIOS... when the Dell BIOS upgrade program runs it checks for two things. The first, it checks to see that a Dell BIOS is already in place on the system. The second, it checks to see that model number of the machine matches the new BIOS information. If either of those two things are missing then the upgrade program will abort. I don't think this is as much of a copy protection scheme as it is a way of keeping things goof proof for the newbie to average computer user. Not too mention it also helps reduce problem calls to their tech support. A Dell BIOS upgrade is like the Dell BIOS itself.... simple and to the point.Regards to an Intel BIOS..... the effect a Intel BIOS can have on a Dell proprietary motherboard can vary from model to model. There is no way of telling how the switch in BIOSes will perform. Through the years I have been visiting here I have seen quite a few people who took the challenge and lost. Their problems ranged from unbootable machines to systems where the installed hardware was no longer supported 100%. This resulted in processors running well below their specified rating to IDE drives that could no longer be accessed. With the exception of one or two older Dimension models I have yet to see anyone report an Intel BIOS working on any machine newer than the XPS D series.Regarding to flashing back.... as I mentioned earlier the trip back from an Intel BIOS can be a very difficult if not impossible task. At one time it was thought it could never be done, but once in a while someone reports back that they were successful. This success though requires the ability to hack the Dell BIOS program and change the coding so that the program no longer checks to see a Dell BIOS is in place on the system.Regarding the boot up time..... after the hardware upgrades have you ever tried clearing the NVRAM? It isn't so out of the ordinary for the hardware information stored in the NVRAM to become corrupted or not updated correctly after a hardware change. This can lead to delays in the BIOS portion of the boot time. By clearing the NVRAM the stored information will be erased and then the system will take a fresh inventory of all the installed hardware. Since Dell hasn't updated their documentation, I'm not quite sure which procedure is the correct one for your model. If you would like to try then use the procedure listed for the 4500s model found at this link here.
<ADMIN NOTE: Broken link has been removed from this post by Dell>
If that procedure fails to produce the required beep upon reset then try this procedure....- Reboot system and enter the BIOS Setup by pressing F2.
- Turn on Caps Lock, Scroll Lock and Num Lock.
- Press ALT+ E then ALT+ F then ALT+ B
Message Edited by Majestic on 02-05-2005 05:25 PM
Kevin Osiowy
13 Posts
499
0
Posted February 6th, 2005 00:00
Thanks again Majestic for going through all the time and effort to help me. Believe me, it's most appreciated!
I had been wondering about hacked BIOS flashes ever since I first read about Dell's "ours or nothing" approach to BIOS. And while I appreciate Dell taking measures to "goof proof" their systems, it would seem to me that preventing people from reverting back to their original Dell BIOS would cause their tech support people even more headaches because if someone has taken the time to learn about BIOS flashing and how to do it, there's no downside to allowing them to reflash with the Dell BIOS after they've discovered that the Intel flash doesn't work for them. In fact, an excellent argument could be made that a lot more people likely have permanently fudged up their machines experimenting with an Intel BIOS and have cried to Dell's tech support because Dell has denied them the ability to fix it themselves once they discover Dell's "ours or nothing" BIOS scheme. Call me a cynic, but it would take a gun held to my head to get me to say that Dell truly had the end user's best interests in mind when they developed their BIOS policy. As it is, some fledgling geek (a.k.a. millions of uninitiated computer enthusiasts) who know just enough to make him or her dangerous and lacks the patience and/or maturity to research before leaping are ideal candidates for falling into Dell's BIOS trap and I'm sure the tech rep who takes their frantic and forlorn calls at Dell is only happy to console them with the fact that for a mere several hundred dollars, Dell will repair their systems for them...
As far as clearing the NVRAM, I tried both the 4500S method and the one you suggested without any results. I thought I had read in some thread that selecting the "load optimal defaults" option in the BIOS "flushes the CMOS" and loads the factory defaults. Am I mixing apples and oranges here?
In any case, this may all soon become moot because I believe I may soon just swap out my 4500 mobo for an 8300 mobo and be done with it. I was thinking about a 4550 mobo, but someone here quickly (and thankfully) pointed me in the direction of the 8300 that will permit me to further upgrade processors and memory if I want to down the road but will still permit me to use my existing RAM and processor for the time being.
Again, thank you very much for your time and patience!
Kevin
" I thought I had read in some thread that selecting the "load optimal defaults" option in the BIOS "flushes the CMOS" and loads the factory defaults. Am I mixing apples and oranges here?"
This can vary from model to model. On some models it merely resets all the BIOS Setup options to their recommended factory settings while on other models it will clear the NVRAM and default the settings. There are times though that clearing the NVRAM through the BIOS doesn't totally resolve the problem and requires what I call a "hard" reset of the NVRAM by removing the battery from the motherboard. This will then totally clear the NVRAM guaranteed. It may or may not help with your situation, but if you're looking for something to do before the Super Bowl just follow this procedure....
With the machine unplugged from the wall remove the battery from the motherboard. Then with the machine still unplugged press the On button for several seconds to dissipate any remaining electrical charge on the motherboard. Then re-install the battery, plug the machine back into the wall and see if it will boot normally.
Good luck on your upgrade plans and as always I am more than glad to help.Message Edited by Majestic on 02-06-2005 07:53 AM
Kevin Osiowy
13 Posts
499
0
Posted February 6th, 2005 20:00
Just a quick update to wind up this thread. A clean reinstall of XP Pro resulted in a complete bootup of under 45 seconds. It's unfortunate that XP Pro apparently cannot automatically adjust to something as straightforward and common as a cpu and memory upgrade.
Thanks again to everyone who offered their time and advice!
Kevin

volcano11
2 Intern
•
27973 Posts
499
0
Posted February 3rd, 2005 18:00
I can't help with all of your problems, but will try to help with some.
First the most common cause of the delay in booting is if you have a card reader attached to a USB port. For example some multifunction printers have a card reader. The BIOS detects the card reader on the USB port and attempts to determine if it is a bootable device. This delays the boot process. So, my first advice is to remove any USB devices and see if that improves the boot time. If it does, you might want to go into the BIOS and either disable legacy USB support or, if the option is available, set it to "No Boot".
You would not be able to flash the BIOS on your system with one for the 4500C. The flash BIOS program checks to see if the model is correct before allowing the flash program to run. Similarly, if you flash to the Intel BIOS, you may find that it doesn't work because the Dell motherboard is proprietary. Then, if you try to flash back to the Dell BIOS, it won't allow it, because the Dell flash BIOS program first looks for a Dell BIOS. If it only finds the Intel BIOS, it won't allow the flash.
Steve