UNSOLVED

haterproof99

updated

22 years ago

0

8523

May 18th, 2005 19:00

Help me choose my vid card! 5700 vs 5700LE

Hey guys, im buying a new video card so i can play Doom 3 and MOH: Pacific Assault and games like that. Ive been searching around and narrowed my search down to 2 cards. BTW, I have a 4600 dimension w/ 1 gig ram, 2.8 p4,  and a 250 W power supply :(
 
the 5700 LE
 
and the plain ol' 5700
 
I really don't want to break the 100 $ limit and any new suggestions are welcome.
  • PastaBusta

    33 Posts

    318

    0

    Posted May 18th, 2005 20:00

    Can't you spare an additional $20 and get this instead:
     
     
    This is really a great deal!
     
    PB
  • duhvoodooman

    413 Posts

    318

    0

    Posted May 18th, 2005 22:00

    Of the two cards you reference, though the 5700 is cheaper than the 5700 LE, it is actually the better card. So if you need to keep it well under $100, that would be a good choice. But if 3D gaming performance is the objective, I would STRONGLY recommend spending $120 for the Radeon 9800 Pro that PastaBusta mentioned (gee, wherever did he find that?? :smileywink:). It is FAR superior to either 5700 card. Check out this vid card comparison table that I grabbed from AnandTech.com:

     

  • herb366

    1517 Posts

    318

    0

    Posted May 18th, 2005 23:00

    I recommend a better card too but if $100 is your budget then get the 9600XT instead of the 5700.
  • 318

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2005 00:00

    I have been thinking long and hard and I think im gonna get the radeon 9800 pro. But im really worried about power, I didn't know the 9800 pro had it's own power connector my specs are:
     
    4600i
    250 W power
    P4 2.8
    1 gig RAM
    80 gig HD
    wireless card (I can take out)
    and my 9800 pro
     
    Will I be fine?

    Message Edited by haterproof99 on 05-18-2005 08:48 PM

  • PastaBusta

    33 Posts

    318

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2005 03:00

    Credit goes to duhvoodooman since he provided the link to the 9800 Pro in another post :). 

    Yes, you should be fine with the stock PSU for the 9800 Pro.  I'm currently using a BFG 6800 OC with a stock 250watt Dell PSU since January and I haven't encountered any problems.  You'll read, time and again in different posts that the 250watt Dell PSU has a maximum capacity of 305watts so you'll be fine.

    PB