UNSOLVED

obrien040362

updated

24 years ago

O

obrien040362

129 Posts

0

89739

December 22nd, 2002 01:00

Dude Don't Buy a DELL

Why is everyone telling me not to buy a Dell ?  Four years age when I bought my CTX everyone told me i would be sorry I should buy a Dell.  I planning on buying either the 4550 or 8250 sometime after Christmas.

 

Jump to Page 6 for my follow up comments

Message Edited by obrien040362 on 12-26-2002 12:23 PM

  • kippy50

    895 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 01:00

    Its actually a great question.  People generally cut down other products to justify the brand they bought.   It really has nothing to do with how good or bad the other brand is, they just like feeding their own ego's.   If you ask anyone what is the best PC on the market, generally, and I mean generally, its the brand they currently own.  But as I said, its not necessarily because its a great brand, its just to justify the reason why they originally bought it.  As for me, there is one telling fact that can't be disputed.  Pick up a copy of the Consumer Reports 2003 buying guide.  Look in the reliability chart and you will see that by a far margin, Dell users have less repair problems than other major brands, including the Mac.  To me thats says it all, at least from this consumers viewpoint anyway.   Kip
  • bath

    68 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 02:00

    Too true...Mind you i build my own but i don't swear by it, It's stable,Fast,But that doesn't mean it's not great, I think one of the most important things to consider when buying a pc is the support...And Dell do pretty well on that front..I don't tend to diss things until i've tried them..

  • meredit42

    89 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 03:00

    There's probably a reason Dell sells more computers that any other company, don't you think. I have bought Dells

     for a long time

    DellsDimension 4400
    Windows XP Home Edition, SP1
    1600 megahertz Intel Pentium 4
    D845PT AAA67834-304 Mother Board
    512 Megabytes PC2100 DDR RAM
    BIOS: Intel Corp. A04 02/12/2002
    40 Gigabyte WDC Hard Drive
    16MB ATI Rage 128 Ultra
    SoundMAX Integrated Digital Audio
    16X CD-RW Drive
    Realtek RTL8139 PCI Fast Ethernet
    Lexmark X83, Multipurpose
    Norton Anti-Virus 2002
    External 100MB Iomega Zip Drive
    Dell 206, 120V Speakers
    Phillips 17" Monitor
    Motarola SB4100 Cable Modem.

  • Wolfin13

    149 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 03:00

    Maybe they are telling you not to buy a Dell because they don"t want you to have a better one then they have.. No but seriously There are some people out there that have had some bad experiances with Dell, but I think you will find the over all are all very happy ..I have had mine for over two years and would buy another in a heart beat..My son just bought his second one.. My friends all have them you will find no complants here from my friends or me... Don't listen to others make your own desision....

    My mind works like lightning one Brilliant flash and its gone!!!

    Dell Dimension 8100
    Intel Pentium 4
    Windows ME
    Ram 384 MB
    40gig Hard Drive
    AVG 6
    Zone Alarm 3.0

  • Greatone1601

    2 Intern

    •

    907 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 04:00

    I'll never insult a computer I havent tried, however...when it comes to MAC's, I wouldn't touch one with a 100 foot pole. Nothing is compatible, no one has them anymore, etc etc. MAC is basically in a LOSING battle with Microsoft and Windows....and it's REALLY LOSING. The only thing keeping MAC alive are the IMAC's that people who dont know a thing about computers buy (or who want a CHEAP all in one from a retail store) and small business, which seems to love MAC's, especially marketing companies. (this is MY experience).

    IMHO if youve got a PC or ANYKIND your doin fine.

  • 1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 04:00

    I had a Dell 166 Pentium at work from 1995-1998 (never had a problem)

    Owned a Dell XPS T700r from 1998-2002 (never had a problem)

    Just bought a Dell 8250 on Dec 18, 2002 (I don't expect any problems, but we'll see)

    There's absolutely nothing wrong with building your own (it's fun and educational) but for a "package" deal you can't beat Dell for price or quality.

  • LiptonIce

    55 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 05:00

    Greatone, did you know people with certain jobs sell their PCs to get a mac because macs are better for things like graphic editing, videos, graphics design etc. Macs might not be good for what YOU do which is gaming, and there is a reason buisnesses want MACs instead of pcs...it performs better with what they do.

    As for buying a dell the reason people tell you not to buy them is because:

    1) Propritary hardware, which makes upgrading a hastle and costly

    2) Iffy technical support

    3) The $500-600 mark up you pay just to have the dell logo on it when you can build on yourself over the weekend.

    Message Edited by LiptonIce on 12-22-2002 01:50 AM

  • 1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 06:00

    Depending on the special deals offered at the time, they can be just as cheap as a custom built machine.  You just have to keep your eyes peeled for them and be willing to be flexible on your purchase date. 

    The Dell still has some of its proprietaryness and its quirks, but you can still get one for the custom built price (or near it) if you're lucky enough. 

    I got a 8250 with a P4 2.4, 512M 1066 RDRAM, Turtle Beach sound card, Ati 9700TX, 120Gig Western Digital 8Meg Buffer (1200JB) disk drive (but without the nice SE warranty), WinXP Home, and 16X DVD Drive for $1017 including tax and shipping, if the rebate comes in.  This was ordered 11/26.  At the time, with a cursory check of prices on Newegg, I could not beat that price by matching comparable components.  You probably could have beat the price with careful shopping since then, but I doubt it would have been much more than maybe 10% cheaper.  If you are a klutz like I am I figure I saved myself at least that 10% by not having to build it myself and deal with all the cards I didn't seat properly, the wires I forgot to plug in, the jumpers I set incorrectly, etc.

    Only thing I don't like is the 1 year warranty on the WD drive, which would have been 3 years had i bought retail, but I'm hoping that by the time my warranty runs out next year, I will see some more deals like the $90-100 after rebate WD 1200JBs like they had this Christmas shopping season.  I think I might have seen some cheaper but it was probably a "camp out Thanksgiving night for the sale in the morning" type deal to snag one of those.

    However, had I missed special offers that were offered at the time of my order, my system from Dell would have been at least a good $100 more expensive on the 27th of November.  At that time, Dell was not a good deal at all and you would have done much better by building yourself or trying another pre built vendor.

    Just compare prices across vendors and make sure Dell isn't the most expensive at the time of your purchase hehe.

  • Greatone1601

    2 Intern

    •

    907 Posts

    1441

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 06:00

    Liptonice I refuse to get into an argument with you, but I will point out one thing.

    If you can build a system identical to a Dell top of the line 8250, counting the case, fans, power supply, mother board, DVD, CDRW, P 4 at 3.06ghz HT, 512MB 1066 RAM, Radeon 9700 PRO, 80GB HD, Sound Blaster 2, Modem, Ethernet Card, USB 2.0, 6 months of AOL, a 3 year warranty (inclusive, which means whole system troubleshooting and repart), SPEAKERS/w subwoofer (which many forget on homegrown) keyboard, mouse, mouse pad, Windows XP PRO, Microsfot OFFICE XP, (all other included software as well) oh and a monitor equivalent to a 19 inch trinitron on the dell site...for LESS than you can home build it ( 500-600 less?) I'll be shocked. I was bored at work one day and tried to do that with newegg and I couldnt do it. If you can than more power to you, but my figures werent close to that, in fact I went over Dell's 8250 price.

    Message Edited by Greatone1601 on 12-22-2002 03:15 AM

  • bunrano

    37 Posts

    833

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2002 07:00



    Greatone1601 wrote:

    If you can build a system identical to a Dell top of the line 8250, counting the case, fans, power supply, mother board, DVD, CDRW, P 4 at 3.06ghz HT, 512MB 1066 RAM, Radeon 9700 PRO, 80GB HD, Sound Blaster 2, Modem, Ethernet Card, USB 2.0, 6 months of AOL, a 3 year warranty (inclusive, which means whole system troubleshooting and repart), SPEAKERS/w subwoofer (which many forget on homegrown) keyboard, mouse, mouse pad, Windows XP PRO, Microsfot OFFICE XP, (all other included software as well) oh and a monitor equivalent to a 19 inch trinitron on the dell site...for LESS than you can home build it ( 500-600 less?) I'll be shocked.


    First, let's be honest and cut through the rubbish.  You're not going to build a computer for 500-600 less with similar components.  That's just absurd.  You're going to build a better computer at the same price or reasonably lower cost.   And 6 mo's of AOL, 3 year warranty, mousepad...  Come on.  The weight of your decision to buy a computer does not rest on the aforementioned, particularly the warranty of questionable worth.  You cannot deny that you've complained and moaned about how difficult it is to get anything done with dell tech support.  Also, you've gone on about how keeping a computer for only 18 months is reasonable to you when looking at high-end systems.  Why would a 3 year warranty be of so much importance to you then?  I can't see how you'd pick bones about their warranty being in the equation.  And "all other included software" they throw in...  You're not getting much.  You're getting a 90 day trial version of antivirus, a freebie version of Musicmatch,... what else?  Nothing of any consequence.  Software like cd-burners, etc., come with the components you buy.

    If you built your own system, you'd buy a better motherboard then what dell would give you, first off.  In addition to having complete control over it, most of these motherboards have onboard LAN, SATA, RAID, sound, not to mention firewire and USB 2.0.  This will leave you with far more PCI slots open than what you will get with the 8250.  Moreover, the computer you build with top-notch components will indeed be faster than a similarly equipped dell.  If you're into a performance computer, then you build you're own.  If you want a consumer-level computer, then you buy a dell.  But, most importantly, when you upgrade your system down the road, you're ultimately saving money.  You don't need to scrap your entire system when you want to upgrade it...do you remember the dimension 8200?

    Edit: However, in defense of Liptonice's claim about the 500-600 markup.  He's probably on the mark with that...dell does buy oem products in volume.  I'm sure they get a huge discount.  But most of the components aren't anything special to justify the markup.

    Edit #2: I did manage to price build a similar system to dell's, and it was $600+ cheaper.  I take back the above that it is not possible.  But, and this goes without saying, if you spend the same amount as you would on a dell, you would have an amazing machine in comparision.

    Message Edited by bunrano on 12-22-2002 03:32 AM

    Message Edited by bunrano on 12-23-2002 12:30 PM