
UNSOLVED
S
shdbcamping1
475 Posts
0
72959
June 25th, 2008 05:00
Dell's 630i PCIe X? fiasco.
Dell-Chris_M,
Please have engineering clarify the MOBO hardwiring to th two PCIe X16 cardholders.
1) How many Physical Paths/Lanes are run to the primary PCIeX16 cardholder 8 or 16?
2) How many Physical Paths/Lanes are run to the secondary PCIeX16 cardholder?
If there are 16 hardwired Paths/Lanes then Dell advertised the two PCIeX16 slots correctly. If there are less than that number the should not have called the slots X16 slots. Just as if there are only 1 hardwired path/lane to the PCIeX8 cardholder it should not be advertized as a PCIeX8 slot.
Conversely, If there are in fact 16 hardwired paths/lanes then it should only be a software/firmware fix to get the 650i chipset to flow all 16 paths to the first slot if there is no card detected in the secondary slot. I have a washing machine that selects the right wash time based on the weight of the clothes when I select a cycle. It also adjusts "on the fly" during the cycle. This is not rocket science.
You can't advertise a yugo as a Cadillac just because you put a cadillac hood ornament on it. Then turn around and blame the customer (who orders over the internet) because they didn't read the service manual. Wher does that come from?
Sean
Responses (37)
Solutions (0)
shdbcamping1
475 Posts
871
0
Posted June 25th, 2008 05:00
Thanks Chris,
I would love to put this one to bed one way or the other. Before Mulder and Skully end up getting involved. lol.
Sean
dontexpectmetob
100 Posts
871
0
Posted June 25th, 2008 18:00
DELL advertised the slots as x16, x16, x8, x1 is correct because the slots are, in fact, x16, x16, x8, x1. A x16 slot will take your x16 add-in card, and your card will work with no problem, though they should have had a note saying only 8 physical lanes are connected to the x16 slot, same as 1 physical lanes to x8 slot.
First of all, PCIe specification states that it supports up-plugging, not down-plugging. What it means is you can plug a physically shorter add-in card into a longer slot (like a x1, x4, or x8 card into a x16 slot) and it is still functional, but not the other way around (downplug: x16 card into x8 slot).
Now if you only have 8 available PCIe lane, as a board designer, which physical slot will you route it to? A x8 slot or a x16 slot? The x16 slot would obviously cost you more than a x8 slot but will enable your customer to use their x16 video card (as most cards are x16 now), albeit with reduced bandwidth. I'd rather run my card at reduced performance (debateable - because most cards don't even yet utilize the 8 lanes bandwidth) than not being able to use it at all. If you are doubtful, play your games or run benchmark with the same graphic cards on a 680i (which has 16 lanes/ x16 slot) and on this 650i mobo and see how big the difference is.
The XPS630 is meant for mainstream, not hardcore, gamers. Comparing to real gaming rig, which cost ~ $4000+, its price point of $1000+ justifies the reduced performance (650i mobo). If you demand superpowerful system, with max performance, feel free to go with the XPS730. If you want a good performace system that allows you to play newest games without going bankcrupt, then buy the 630, but don't complain about its limitation. Reading 50+ user reviews on DELL site, I've seen no complaints about this rig's performance. All the complaints so far are about features (ESA, light FX).
At the end of the day, you get what you pay for. To me, given these limitations, this rig still allows me to play the latest games at highest settings, and that's my definition of best bang for the buck.
Message Edited by dontexpectmetobeyourfriend on 06-25-2008 02:41 PMMessage Edited by dontexpectmetobeyourfriend on 06-25-2008 02:48 PMRafael Polit
175 Posts
871
0
Posted June 25th, 2008 19:00
I'm sorry to disagree... an x16 is: a physical slot + a speed of connection. I believe it's misleading to claim two x16 connections when in fact none is x16.
Also, the XPS 420 does have a x16 2.0 PCIe, so your argument about price is questionable.
Rafa.
Message Edited by Rafael Polit on 06-25-2008 03:28 PMSorry, this isn't quite right. The x16 has nothing to do with speed, it can refer to the size of the slot, or the number of lanes.
A PCI-E x16 slot will accept a PCI-E x16 card.
A 630i has two of these, as advertised.
Counting capacitors on the motherboard, I can see that each slot has 8 lanes wired up, so that when using two cards in SLI mode, each card uses 8 lanes. This is as much as the 650SLI chipset can manage.
BUT, when using a single card, it won't use all 16 lanes, as they aren't wired up.
It would have been useful for Dell to mention this in the specs (8 active lanes per PCI-E x16 slot), but isn't exactly false advertising. Also, bandwidth: shouldn't be an issue, unless you were planning to run a single GTX280 or similar.
Real solution if you want 2x PCI-E x16 is to use a different motherboard chipset!
dv.
Why?
The 630i specs clearly state that it uses the 650SLI chipset.
The 650SLI chipset hits it's sweet spot with ...
...
wait for it
...
two graphics cards using SLI (or crossfire, or whatever).
Using two 8800GT's, 8 lanes per card is not holding anything back, as 8 lane bandwidth is way beyond what the cards can transfer.
dv.
The first test does show a difference with one ECS mobo, but the conclusion "it must be because it's the only one with both slots wired x8" isn't very scientific.
I'm looking at the second test, but it's not easy to interpret.
I'm looking for two cards, both PCI-E 2.0, one x8, one x16 ??
As far as I can see, that test was trying to see if PCI-E 2.0 was "worth it" compared to PCI-E 1.0a
And the conclusion was ... "not really".
Any comparison between a PCI-E 1.0a x8 card and a PCI-E 2.0 x16 card isn't helpful, as they use different signalling rates.
dv.
Message Edited by dvinell on 06-25-2008 04:55 PM
@dvinell wrote:
Why?
The 630i specs clearly state that it uses the 650SLI chipset.
The 650SLI chipset hits it's sweet spot with ...
...
wait for it
...
two graphics cards using SLI (or crossfire, or whatever).
Using two 8800GT's, 8 lanes per card is not holding anything back, as 8 lane bandwidth is way beyond what the cards can transfer.
dv.
why becuase most nforce 650i support 16 lanes if using one video card, which is what we all thought when we purchased the machine under misleading advertising
as you can see from this review
take a look at this review
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/650i-sli-motherboards-compared,1609.html
the 650i SLI gets fewer than half as many lanes at a total of 18, sixteen of which must be either sent to a single graphics card or divided among two cards in an x8 plus x8 configuration. One more piece of hardware dragged up from the past - and one that we weren't hoping to see again - is the "paddle card" PCI-Express slot selector. Most of the boards we tested support either two x8 or one x16 pathway by manually removing and re-installing a small card from between the graphics card slots
and like i said from my other thread single card users in pci-e x8 lose 7-8% performance
so to say it does not make a difference is a lie
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/crossfire-meets-pci-express,1761-6.html
As mentioned above, a single card loses between 7 and 8 percent performance when operating in an x8 slotMessage Edited by denec on 06-25-2008 04:23 PMMessage Edited by denec on 06-25-2008 04:26 PM
@dontexpectmetobeyourfriend wrote:DELL advertised the slots as x16, x16, x8, x1 is correct because the slots are, in fact, x16, x16, x8, x1. A x16 slot will take your x16 add-in card, and your card will work with no problem, though they should have had a note saying only 8 physical lanes are connected to the x16 slot, same as 1 physical lanes to x8 slot.
As a cautious consumer I did my due diligence when I noticed Dell's lack of detailed information(see here) about the hardware configurations. So I did my research(here) based on what information Dell did provide, that being a motherboard with the Nvidia Nforce 650 SLI chipset. While some people don't plan in advance what they will do for upgrading their system I do and part of that plan is to upgrade my video card to PCIe 16x with 16 lane support. There may be negligible benefit now with current video cards running PCIe 8x but that will not hold true when full PCIe 16x capable videos card are released. Whether a customer wants to upgrade or not is really a moot point anyway as Dell advertised the XPS 630 with certain specs and as customers we are entitled to receive just that. At no point has anyone mentioned we want a $3000 free upgrade to fix these problems nor would I ever expect that, all I want is for Dell to deliver on the system they advertised.
@dontexpectmetobeyourfriend wrote:
The XPS630 is meant for mainstream, not hardcore, gamers. Comparing to real gaming rig, which cost ~ $4000+, its price point of $1000+ justifies the reduced performance (650i mobo). If you demand superpowerful system, with max performance, feel free to go with the XPS730. If you want a good performace system that allows you to play newest games without going bankcrupt, then buy the 630, but don't complain about its limitation.
Dell seems to disagree with you about what market the XPS 630 is geared towards.
The only limitations I have problems with and am "crying" about are the ones Dell imposed when they didn't provide the hardware as they advertised.
@dontexpectmetobeyourfriend wrote:
Reading 50+ user reviews on DELL site, I've seen no complaints about this rig's performance. All the complaints so far are about features (ESA, light FX).
I doubt you will ever see a bad review on Dell's site. All reviews have to be approved by Dell before they will be posted. What chance to you think a bad review or anything less then 3 stars well get on the site?
@dontexpectmetobeyourfriend wrote:
At the end of the day, you get what you pay for. To me, given these limitations, this rig still allows me to play the latest games at highest settings, and that's my definition of best bang for the buck.
Actually that's all I'm asking for, to get what I paid for. It's not my fault Dell misrepresented themselves when selling the XPS 630. Still not convinced of Dell lack of ability to advertise accurate information? Read this post. Dell has misled the purchasers of the XPS 630 either by design or by bad planning and we are now paying the price for that.
For those that still aren't convinced that Dell has engaged in false advertising then try googling the italicized phrase and see what happens.

DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
871
0
Posted June 25th, 2008 05:00
I have emailed them.
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell