UNSOLVED

john1204

updated

26 years ago

J

john1204

8 Posts

0

14631

May 9th, 2001 00:00

Dell Pentium 4 is not useful

Anyone out there have a P4 Demension that will ACTUALLY boot? I am on box #2 from Dell and it will boot 1 in 8 or 9 tries. Read the following carefully: There are NO conflict or hardware problems which show up ANYWHERE! Once this useless machine is finally up an running, ALL applications function NORMALLY. I am loading ONLY SYS TRAY, SCAN REGISTRY in MSConfig and my system resources are 97% free. One problem - it won't reliably boot - never has and Dell has no clue.

TIA,

John

  • joecapp

    2 Intern

    •

    632 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 00:00

    When you say it won't boot give some detail about what you are actually seeing?

    Do you get the Dell logo? Can you F2 into the BIOS?

    Do you get the Windows ME splash screen? Can you boot via a diskette?

    As much info as you can provide.

  • john1204

    8 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 13:00

    Thanks for the reply. Sorry I was not very specific.
    I am running win 98SE because there are few drivers available for some of the high-end appz in which I have invested considerabe money. When the drivers catch up I'll be running Win 2K Pro.

    I get the Dell screen, followed by the Windows splash screen, followed by the remarks on the DOS screen, followed by the windows splash screen followed by nothing. No cursor, nothing. It flakes out at that point JUST BEFORE the hourglass appears as windows builds the desktop.

    Next, I'll power down and let it boot to safe mode - I change nothing in safe mode and and do a restart and it USUALLY reboots normally. Sometimes not.
    Again, I have NO conflicts showing up anywhere in Windows, whatsoever. Very strange.

    I think the P4 is very incompatable with Win '98SE and Dell won't admit it - but they assured me "it will work just fine" -Heard that before.

    John

  • volcano11

    2 Intern

    •

    27973 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 15:00

    John1204,

    We might be able to narrow down the problem if you would provide us with more details about your system. Does it have a USB mouse and USB keyboard? What graphics adapter and sound card does it have? Are there any other devices connected throught the USB ports? Is Norton Antivirus installed and running? It's hard to beleive you have received a non-working computer twice (is that the case?) You say you have eliminated all programs from running from startup except systray and explorer. What other modifications have you made?

    Steve

  • john1204

    8 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 17:00

    Thanks, Steve:

    I have a fair mount of hardware on this box. I have a compact flash reader on one USB and a DirectPC Satellite modem on another, (there are 4 USB Ports total) I am using an Elsa Synergy III, dual head Videocard with two 19" Trinitrons running in dual display mode. I have a 9 gig 10K RPM Seagate scratch drive and and external 16X CD-RW Yamaha writer. I have 256 Mg system RAM and a pair of 30gig EIDE Drives. The box has five bays and I'm using them all.

    (BTW: acciording to Dell, I have no business putting any hardware or software on the machine - even if I did spend $2900 on it)

    What really frustrates me ia that I had all the SAME equipment running FLAWLESSLY on a Gateway PII 450 box for a couple years with never a failure of ANY kind.

    This is set up as a graphics workstation, as I teach Photoshop and do other graphics stuff.

    Norton Antivirus is on the box, but I turned it off because I have never had any luck with it running.
    I am loading systray only and, yes, this is #2 from Dell.

    TIA,

    John

  • volcano11

    2 Intern

    •

    27973 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 18:00

    john1204,

    While I sympathize with your frustrations, I must also say that with so many things added to the system, how can you expect Dell Tech Support to be able to say what is causing the problem. How can they possibly know what effects all of these devices can have on your system. If I had added all of this to my 8100 (which is working quite well), I might expect to run into a few glitches as well. If I wanted to troubleshoot the problem I would start by detaching the USB devices - the 4 ports on the 8100 have different capabilities. Are the keyboard and mouse also USB devices? The reason I say this is because it sounds like Windows is having trouble during the hardware detection phase of bootup. If you can narrow the problem down to one of the devices then you have a shot. You may need updated drivers, or perhaps the extra speed of the P4 is not compatible with one of these older devices. What about the video cards - did Dell provide them or did you buy and install them? Did the system work correctly with the original video cards? Do you have the latest drivers for the video cards?

    I'm not trying to defend Dell, I just think you can't expect Dell (or Gateway or Compaq or IBM) to offer full support for their systems plus all of the other possible devices that someone might install. If you installed an aftermarket carburater on your Ford and it then didn't work, would you expect Ford to cover it under their warranty?

    Anyway, let's try to troubleshoot this and see if we can narrow down the problem.

    Steve

  • john1204

    8 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2001 20:00

    Thank you, Steve:

    I have updated every driver that was "updateable".
    Strange that I am seeing no hardware or software conflicts; no I/O or IRQ conflicts.

    I'll try as you suggested.

    John

  • DaleBett

    57 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 10th, 2001 13:00

    I don't think he wants to "proceed methodically to solve the problem." It seems he just wants to b!tch and moan and tell people how it's all Dell's fault, secure in his ignorance of what the real problem is.

  • john1204

    8 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 10th, 2001 23:00

    Thank you for sharing, Gomer.

  • DaleBett

    57 Posts

    500

    0

    Posted May 11th, 2001 13:00

    John,

    Thank YOU for sharing. I know based on the response from the other posters, that your story was interesting and informative...at least as a demonstration of how not to approach actually trying to solve a complex computer problem.

    Honestly though, I do hope you can solve your interesting problem. I think the best advice is to start fresh (meaning unistall all hardware, backup data, reformat hard drive and then reinstall Windows -- not just unistall the hardware as that stil leaves remnants). Then install peripherals one at a time. Dell tech support is helpful in guiding you through a clean install of Windows and factory installed programs (in fact, I think they are too quick to recommend that option sometimes).

    Once you figure out what actually caused the problem, then repost here and check out the manufacturer's site to see if there are any known workarounds. I also would suggest (once you've narrowed things down) going to Deja.com (now run by Google) to search the newsgroup postings for solutions.