UNSOLVED

andrerc

updated

26 years ago

A

andrerc

3 Posts

0

10019

March 28th, 2001 04:00

Dell Diagnostics

Are the tests performed by Dell Diagnostics reliable? I mean, does it spot defects in the PC hardware for sure? My HD makes a strange noise, can the Dell Diagnostics tell me if there is a problem with it?
  • Sandab

    28 Posts

    199

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2001 12:00

    I don't know if there is a definitive answer to that. My hard drive started failing (repeated tries to read data accompanied by a ratcheting or clicking noise and sectors being locked out by scandisk but my system was still operational but with sporadic read/write errors). I ran the Dell detailed diagnostics and the hard drive failed them. I ran the diagnostics in Resolution Assistant and the hard drive failed them. I then contacted Dell through Resolution Assistant (it's an online real time contact like instant messanging) and the Dell representative was able to confirm online with additional online tests of my hardware that my hard drive was failing. The next morning (literally) a technician called my house and said he would be there between 10 and 2 to replace my hard drive. He was at my house on time, replaced the hard drive and started the recovery disk. The entire operation took slightly over 30 minutes. I never contacted Dell by email or phone, never spoke to Dell by voice and never had to wait in line. The only paperwork I had to fill out was the signing of my name on the technicians work order confirming that he had replaced my hard drive. The time between my decision to contact Dell and the replacement of my hard drive was slightly less than 30 hours. I thought then (Feb 2001), and still do, that Dell's hardware problem resolution is top notch. If you do decide to contact Dell through Resolution Assistant, I'm under the impression that it is manned by live technicians from 9-5 central time, though I'm not sure of that. As to your original question can the hard drive be failing and the diagnostics not detect it, who knows? I can only repeat my experience for whatever value it may be to you.
  • koc77

    23 Posts

    199

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2001 13:00

    The diags can and do miss physical problems with hard disks sometimes. Before you call about the problem, you might want to try booting to the dell resource cd, and going to the x:\advdiag\90-90 directory (x:=your cdrom drive letter.) and run hddct.exe.
    This is the hard drive confidence test and is pretty good at letting you know if the drive is ok or not.
    Good luck
  • Sandab

    28 Posts

    199

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2001 16:00

    I'm sorry I forgot to mention it earlier, but you should take the following action to protect the integrity of the data files on your hard drive if you think it may be failing and if your OS is Win 95 or 98: Search for the file "autoexec.bat" on your hard drive. Open it with Windows Notepad. Insert a new line with the text "verify=on" without the quotation marks. Close and save the file. This is an old DOS command that is still functional. What it does is force your hard drive to check every piece of data it writes to the drive after it writes it against the original data still in memory. This ensures any data files you are using can't be corrupted by faulty write operations. It also ensures that your OS isn't garbled when you do a defragment operation. The additional time your hard drive uses in this operation is negligible and it will give you peace of mind that everything being written to your hard drive is accurate even if your hard drive is in the process of failing. I use this on my system just as insurance even though I have good confidence in my present hard drive.