UNSOLVED

Jeorne

updated

19 years ago

J

Jeorne

69 Posts

0

10801

February 4th, 2008 07:00

Defrag taking over 10 hours (2% framentation)

I ran Vista's Defrag utility on my 1000 GB HDD (raid 0). It only had 209 GB of files @ 2% fragmentation. 

 

10 hours later it was still running!!! :smileysurprised:

 

Even when I had nothing but the OS installed, defrag took 3-4 hours to complete - at the time, I assumed Dell sent me a badly fragmented drive - which wasn't the case.  I even ran it 4 more times before adding files, with no decrease in the time it takes.

 

My old PC had a lesser CPU, 1 GB RAM, far more files which were often 5 - 10% fragmented.  Yet it could do the job in less than 2 hours max.

 

Why is it taking so long?  Does vista's defrag have trouble coping with Raid 0 striped drives? Or could it be that it doesn't like volumes that are too big.  (Diskeeper can only cope with 768 GB volumes).

 

Seriously, this is taking too long - I dread adding more files.  Can I fix this?

  • joecapp

    2 Intern

    •

    632 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 4th, 2008 10:00

    Defrag is mainly a function of the size of the drive.  Maybe you should try booting into "safe mode" and running it overnight.

  • fishywishy

    107 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 4th, 2008 10:00

    im gonna go with the size of your hard drive and the ammount of free space you have
  • jimfred

    175 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 4th, 2008 11:00

    try auslogics disc defrag i use it which i have windows xp but its vista compatable and its by far better and faster than the default windows defragger. and its free

    http://www.auslogics.com/disk-defrag

  • Jeorne

    69 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 4th, 2008 13:00

    Thanks all.  In the end I downloaded Diskeeper 2008.   When I did finally run it, it did the job far more quickly.  I had to shrink my partition to run it though (768 GB limit), so partition size could have been a factor - guess I'll have to run vista's version to find that out. 

     

    The volume map shows files all over the place - even after using diskeeper.  Not consecutively as I expected.  Must be a reason for that. It didn't seem to be good at consolidating white spaces either.

     

    Some Files are not defragged for some reason.  But when I checked it out the stats using vista's defrag in cmd box mode, it didn't pick those up.  Must be some files are untouchable.

     

    Diskeeper also has a boot time defrag to work on Master File Tables & paging files, but it caused an exception error for some reason, and didn't run. :smileysad:

  • RainDIPset

    21 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 4th, 2008 21:00

    Get Perfectdisk8.0 and use there smartplacement. Trust me it will be worth it.
  • Jeorne

    69 Posts

    205

    0

    Posted February 5th, 2008 07:00

    I agree, Perfect Disk does seem more feature rich.  The excuses Diskeeper gives for not fully defragging or consolidating all the white space is not so good.  The fact DK it not certified by MS is intriguing.