UNSOLVED

minarikka

updated

5 years ago

M

minarikka

1 Rookie

•

6 Posts

0

3030

August 9th, 2021 19:00

Dell Latitude 5310 and WD19 Thunderbolt Dock NOT Working

Having a problem getting a WD19TB Thunderbolt dock to work on a Dell Latitude 5310 laptop with Windows 10 Pro. When I plug in the dock, the computer makes a sound like it is recognized, then seconds later another sound to indicate the device is being disconnected. This is verified by keeping open the Thunderbolt Control Center app. It shows it is connected, then quickly disconnects within a second. Here is what I have done for troubleshooting:

1. Ensured Thunderbolt and Thunderbolt Boot support are enabled in the BIOS.
2. Reinstalled Windows 10 Pro (did this about 5 times, no lie) including all updates
3. Made sure all drivers were loaded using Windows Update and Dell Command
4. Updated laptop BIOS, Thunderbolt frmware, and WD19TB dock firmware (had to use my Latitude 5290 to update the dock since that sees the WD19TB no problem)


So this is NOT a firmware issue as all firmwares are up to date. It is NOT a broken WD19TB dock as it works perfectly on both a Latitude 7390 and Latitude 5290 (both are Thunderbolt enabled).

Based on how the PCI bus enumerates the embedded Thunderbolt USB hub on the Latitude 5290 and 7390 (it creates a separate USB 3.1 xHCI controller), my Latitude 5310 seems to act different. What I can see is that somehow the dock's Thunderbolt port is being ported under Port #1 of the root USB 3.1 xHCI controller hub as seen in first picture (Realtek Semiconductor PID=F192 is the dock). This essentially then creates a hub within a hub which fails and causes the dock to disconnect (Thunderbolt needs its own USB 3.1 hub on the PCI bus to work as it needs PCI Express x4 bandwidth). Further, if I disable the root USB hub, then the Thunderbolt dock correctly enumerates to the PCI Express Root Port #5 and works normally. However, this is unacceptable because disabling the root hub renders the USB ports on the laptop useless. Not what you would expect or desire from a $1000 laptop and $200 dock.

Has anyone else had this issue where the WD19TB dock does not function correctly on the Latitude 5310? Why is Thunderbolt being ported to Port #1 of the root USB 3.1 xHCI hub when that is an invalid configuration for Thunderbolt operation? Is there a way to force it to always connect to PCI Express Root Port #5 where the actual  Thunderbolt bus is located? Is this a bug in the Comet Lake chipset drivers? Would appreciate any help in this matter.WD19TB Not WorkingWD19TB Not WorkingWD19TB With Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDWD19TB With Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDRoot USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDRoot USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDApp sees WD19TB with Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDApp sees WD19TB with Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDUpdated TB Software and FirmwareUpdated TB Software and Firmware

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    1867

    0

    Posted August 9th, 2021 23:00

    @minarikka  Any chance you have any other Thunderbolt or even USB-C devices to test, just to rule out a problem with that port on your specific unit?  If not or if you've tried that and some other device works fine, then this may be an as yet unresolved firmware interoperability issue that affects that specific combination of system and dock.  The fact that your firmware is all up to date does not mean it couldn't be a firmware issue.  I know the XPS 13 9300 for example had problems running dual 4K 60 Hz displays through a WD19TB for quite a while, even though that was supposed to work.  (And then at one point Dell issued a BIOS update that broke the ability to use USB-C to DP/HDMI adapters with that system, which required a second BIOS update that arrived months later in order to resolve.)

    And if you're just doing this for testing to simplify your setup, then fair enough, but looking over your post and screenshots, you shouldn't enable Thunderbolt boot support unless you actually need it for something like PXE booting through the dock's Ethernet interface, and you definitely should not set your Thunderbolt port security to No Security.

  • Martin5

    5 Posts

    1859

    0

    Posted August 10th, 2021 03:00

    Facing The Same Problem.......

    Thanks For Sharing....


    @minarikka wrote:

    Having a problem getting a WD19TB Thunderbolt dock to work on a Dell Latitude 5310 laptop with Windows 10 Pro. When I plug in the dock, the computer makes a sound like it is recognized, then seconds later another sound to indicate the device is being disconnected. This is verified by keeping open the Thunderbolt Control Center app. It shows it is connected, then quickly disconnects within a second. Here is what I have done for troubleshooting:

    1. Ensured Thunderbolt and Thunderbolt Boot support are enabled in the BIOS.
    2. Reinstalled Windows 10 Pro (did this about 5 times, no lie) including all updates
    3. Made sure all drivers were loaded using Windows Update and Dell Command
    4. Updated laptop BIOS, Thunderbolt frmware, and WD19TB dock firmware (had to use my Latitude 5290 to update the dock since that sees the WD19TB no problem)


    So this is NOT a firmware issue as all firmwares are up to date. It is NOT a broken WD19TB dock as it works perfectly on both a Latitude 7390 and Latitude 5290 (both are Thunderbolt enabled).

    Based on how the PCI bus enumerates  the embedded Thunderbolt USB hub on the Latitude 5290 and 7390 (it creates a separate USB 3.1 litebluex HCI controller), my Latitude 5310 seems to act different. What I can see is that somehow the dock's Thunderbolt port is being ported under Port #1 of the root USB 3.1 xHCI controller hub as seen in first picture (Realtek Semiconductor PID=F192 is the dock). This essentially then creates a hub within a hub which fails and causes the dock to disconnect (Thunderbolt needs its own USB 3.1 hub on the PCI bus to work as it needs PCI Express x4 bandwidth). Further, if I disable the root USB hub, then the Thunderbolt dock correctly enumerates to the PCI Express Root Port #5 and works normally. However, this is unacceptable because disabling the root hub renders the USB ports on the laptop useless. Not what you would expect or desire from a $1000 laptop and $200 dock.

    Has anyone else had this issue where the WD19TB dock does not function correctly on the Latitude 5310? Why is Thunderbolt being ported to Port #1 of the root USB 3.1 xHCI hub when that is an invalid configuration for Thunderbolt operation? Is there a way to force it to always connect to PCI Express Root Port #5 where the actual  Thunderbolt bus is located? Is this a bug in the Comet Lake chipset drivers? Would appreciate any help in this matter.WD19TB Not WorkingWD19TB Not WorkingWD19TB With Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDWD19TB With Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDRoot USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDRoot USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDApp sees WD19TB with Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDApp sees WD19TB with Root USB 3.1 Hub DISABLEDUpdated TB Software and FirmwareUpdated TB Software and Firmware



     

  • minarikka

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    1857

    0

    Posted August 10th, 2021 03:00

    I forgot to mention, I tried an older TB16 Thunderbolt dock and it works fine as well (too bad the USB cable on those were so short).  I have also tried a WD15 dock as well as a USB-C external drive and they work fine, so I know the USB-C port works in both Thunderbolt and regular USB-C mode.  It just seems when it sees the WD19TB dock, it does not know where to correctly put it, so it places it at Port 1 of the root USB hub and fails as it can't really work there.

    I have tried every combination of Thunderbolt setting in the BIOS (Thunderbolt on with boot support off, etc) with no change.  It is set for No Security as well as it is just me that uses it.  I have tried other security levels as well, same result. The weirdest thing is I set up the same exact model laptop with the exact same specs (Latitude 5310 with Thunderbolt) and WD19TB dock for one of my kids last month and it works perfect, still to this day.  The only hardware difference I saw was the webcam/IR camera was from a different manufacturer (Her 5310 shows webcam/IR camera manufacturer from RealTek, mine shows Sunplus)  And yes, I've tried unplugging the webcam from the motherboard and reloading Window 10 to see if that was the issue and same thing happens.  I also ran the camera firmware update tool as well.  Nothing seems to help.  I have also unplugged the battery and coin cell, pressed power button for 30 seconds to erase all of the NVRAM.  I have also run FPTW64.exe -greset to do a global reset.  I have also downgraded to an earlier BIOS (ver 1.4.2)

    Is it a BIOS issue?  Maybe an Intel ME firmware issue?  I know the Intel ME runs a lot of the computer behind the scenes, so is that what is incorrectly redirecting the WD19TB dock to the wrong USB hub?  At a loss here and a day and a half of troubleshooting has already gone into this $1200 of hardware and as you can imagine, this has not made me happy.

  • minarikka

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    1852

    0

    Posted August 10th, 2021 07:00

    Interesting to see someone else had same issue (Martin5).  Like I said earlier, only physical hardware difference on the 5310 that works and the one that does not is the webcam/IR camera.  Out of curiosity, which webcam/IR camera manufacturer is yours?  Hope someone can figure this out for us.

  • minarikka

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    1793

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2021 07:00

    After 5 days of troubleshooting, it ended up being a incompatible and/or bad Thunderbolt cable, Dell part 2HV8N.  Note that the removable Thunderbolt module/circuit board was fine, just the removable cable itself was incompatible/bad.  There is evidently circuitry in the cable end and I assume that some older cables may be incompatible with the newer Thunderbolt chipsets/firmware.  I originally thought it was the Thunderbolt firmware in the removable Thunderbolt circuit board module, but after updating and downgrading EC, TB, MST, and USB hub firmware many times, it was not fixed.  It was not until I removed the cable and swapped cables from a WD19TB dock that works was I able to confirm this.  So for others having this issue, see if you can get a replacement Thunderbolt cable from Dell, part number 2HV8N.  Maybe there is some firmware in the cable that can be updated, however there is no update I could find to do this.  Hopefully Dell will step up and replace the incompatible cable.  I miss my old E-port docks that were simple and just plain worked.