UNSOLVED

augustl

updated

8 years ago

Closed

A

augustl

1 Rookie

•

108 Posts

4

7812

October 15th, 2018 12:00

Dell G7 BIOS 1.4.1 and 1.5.0 cause high temp CPU throttling

We need an update ASAP

This conversation is no longer open for comments or replies and is no longer visible to community members.

  • augustl

    1 Rookie

    •

    108 Posts

    4922

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 14:00

    BIOS 1.3.0 and below do not suffer from this problem

     

  • 4918

    4

    Posted October 15th, 2018 14:00

    I could not agree more. Just opening a browser causes Core 0 to jump to 94C. what the heck is that foolishness? This is insane and completely unacceptable. 

  • augustl

    1 Rookie

    •

    108 Posts

    4885

    3

    Posted October 15th, 2018 16:00

    No CPU should reach 100C when BROWSING even for a millisecond. Disagree

    Also complaints of noise? No, users expected this with a hefty cpu like this (especially Intel)

    Also quiet/hot or noisy/cool shouldn't be the only two options. That's Intel's problem since AMD wasn't in laptops of this price range yet

  • MikeNeutral

    12 Posts

    4883

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 16:00

    AMD simply put desktop Ryzens in laptops and it spins fans like Boeing.

    I've read many complaints about noise because G7 and G5 had strange fan profiles, it literally drove you crazy, but it was cool.

    Maybe Dell can make it better - simply spin fans at 1000 RPM all the time and stop passive cooling. But I like what they did if it doesnt hurt CPU (yes, maybe it hurts, but real temperature death limit is higher than 100 С).

     

    FYI - It's worst laptop I ever bought and would return it if I was able to. But I can't and it works for my purposes...

  • MikeNeutral

    12 Posts

    4889

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 16:00

    Users are so funny. At first you complain that notebook with a power of middle-end desktop is too noisy. Dell says ok and tries to make it quiet. How? Thermal throttling when CPU is without load. Yes, you may get 100C even when browsing (for a millisecond), but it's quiet.

    So, what do you want: quiet and hot or noisy and cool? There is no other way with 8750H. They all are noisy.

    But all these games with fan profiles are waste of time. For now I think I'll buy desktop again + simple laptop, Intel didn't understand what they did when they created 6-core mobile CPUs. Physics are against it on this techlevel

  • MikeNeutral

    12 Posts

    4855

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 17:00

    I experience spikes only when browsing or similar activity and didn't notice them before this thread. When there is any real cpu load fans turn on.

    The "real temperature death limit" is not higher than 100C. It IS 100C. This is specified in the actual Intel datasheets

    If it was so, our laptops would be dead already because our CPUs temps already exceeded 100 degrees many times.

  • MikeNeutral

    12 Posts

    4831

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 17:00


    But reaching the MAX allowed temp of 100C repeatedly WILL shorten the life of the cpu.


    Of course. Nowadays manufacturers don't create products that last long and that's why they created this extreme cooling profile in bios 1.5 - laptop will 100% work for year or two and then user buys newer model without warranty case or return caused by noise level. They tell you fit or die lol

  • augustl

    1 Rookie

    •

    108 Posts

    4868

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 17:00

    Ryzen 2 series will be much cooler in laptops. We're already seeing that

    It does hurt CPUs - the throttling causes lag spikes and software to slow down quite a bit because it's hitting the max safe temperature of 100C. The "real temperature death limit" is not higher than 100C. It IS 100C. This is specified in the actual Intel datasheets

  • augustl

    1 Rookie

    •

    108 Posts

    4839

    1

    Posted October 15th, 2018 17:00

    Refer to https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/docs/processors/core/8th-gen-core-family-datasheet-vol-1.html

    Table 5-3 on page 100.

    HU-Processor Line Thermal and Power
    Specifications

     

    Ok, obviously there will be some buffer before the whole chip melts. But reaching the MAX allowed temp of 100C repeatedly WILL shorten the life of the cpu.

  • itsgamer

    9 Posts

    1764

    0

    Posted October 15th, 2018 18:00


    @augustl wrote:

    It isn't possible to downgrade back to 1.3.0 or below.


    and that is the main reason why i hate this bios update. At least give users the option to downgrade. But no. Lets completely mess up this update even more by blocking the option to downgrade. If you try, you will get an error message. Bios recovery doesn't work either