UNSOLVED

kingtrw

updated

16 days ago

K

kingtrw

1 Rookie

•

13 Posts

•

8 Points

0

316

August 13th, 2024 14:29

OME not able to reliably perform graceful shutdown on Windows servers

The only way I can get firmware updated to work reliably with OME is if I select the "stage for next server reboot" option and then reboot the server manually.

OME is just not able to reliably perform graceful restarts on my Windows servers (R6515). Everything is up to date and the service module is installed.

If I select 'graceful restart without forced shutdown' then the job fails with a 'host didn't restart' message - if I select 'graceful restart with forced shutdown' then it hard resets the server and that makes Windows unhappy.

It has *occasionally* worked - but it's not reliable, and I'd say fails 80-90% of the time.

Does anyone have any ideas? I can continue to update firmware with manual reboots, but it takes a lot more time than I think it should.

Thanks!

  • DELL-Charles R

    Moderator

    •

    4730 Posts

    •

    25476 Points

    1

    1

    Posted August 13th, 2024 18:51

    Hello,

     

    I haven't seen this myself.

     

    Can you try as a test: reboot the DRAC first, this does not require a host reboot, and then try the update from OME?

     

    How did you Discover the Window OS?

    To perform Windows driver update, ensure that the Windows servers are discovered in-band using the supported OpenSSH

    Protocol.

     

    If you are experiencing this 80-90% of the time, you may want to call in to Support and a technician can get a look with you.

    DELL-Charles R

    Social Media and Communities Professional
    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
    #IWork4Dell

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Accept as Solution’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

  • kingtrw

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    •

    8 Points

    2

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2024 14:53

    @DELL-Charles R​ Thanks, I haven't tried using the reboot idrac first option, I will test that for the next updates.

    Host OS was discovered via standard discovery, using host type as Windows and providing admin credentials (with SSH enabled).

    I did consider raising a support call, but because I can't reliably replicate it I didn't think that was going to be very useful!

    Edit - also, the host OS integration shouldn't really be required - the host OS will perform a graceful shutdown if the power button is pressed, and the iDRAC is certainly capable of doing that.

    (edited)

  • DELL-Charles R

    Moderator

    •

    4730 Posts

    •

    25476 Points

    2

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2024 15:26

    Hello,

     

    Thank you for the update. I'll make a check with one of our Systems Management engineers.

     

    If you could try reboot the DRAC first on the next time.

     

    If you have the issue at that time, maybe worth contacting Support directly and an engineer can get a look with you.

    DELL-Charles R

    Social Media and Communities Professional
    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
    #IWork4Dell

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Accept as Solution’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

  • DELL-Charles R

    Moderator

    •

    4730 Posts

    •

    25476 Points

    3

    0

    Posted August 15th, 2024 17:20

    Hello,

     

    I found the KB article that explains what you are seeing.

     

    Knowledge Base Article Number #000224986

     Graceful Shutdown or Graceful Restart operations using Redfish fails for Windows Server

    https://dell.to/4cngL0k

    DELL-Charles R

    Social Media and Communities Professional
    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
    #IWork4Dell

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Accept as Solution’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

  • cwswattsi

    1 Rookie

    •

    2 Posts

    •

    5 Points

    4

    1

    Posted November 4th, 2026 20:55

    So today I tried using OME to apply updates by scheduling and opted for the graceful shutdown with forced reboot.

     

    As usual, it forced the reboot and the event log reflected that.

     

    Can Dell provide a KB on how to configure PowerEdge and Windows Server with OME such that this option works consistently?  I have more than a few servers and saying "just restart the iDRAC" is not a satisfactory answer in any case.

     

    Pending the updates and scheduling an OS restart has been fine.. but I would prefer to have OME take point as it was created for.

  • DellMartinS

    Moderator

    •

    3885 Posts

    •

    25816 Points

    2

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2026 07:02

    Yes, Dell actually acknowledges this limitation in official documentation. In Dell KB Article 000224986, titled "PowerEdge: Graceful Shutdown or Restart Operations using Redfish Fails for Windows Server", Dell explicitly states that initiating a graceful restart or shutdown using modern Redfish APIs (which OME uses exclusively to orchestrate jobs) frequently fails on the Windows Server operating system.https://www.dell.com/support/kbdoc/en-rs/000224986/poweredge-graceful-shutdown-or-graceful-restart-operations-using-redfish-fails-for-windows-serverpoweredge-graceful-shutdown-or-graceful-restart-operations-using-redfish-fails-for-windows-server

    with kind regards Martin/ Liebe Grüße Martin

     

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

     

    DELL-Martin S

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell


  • kingtrw

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    •

    8 Points

    2

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2026 13:27

    Dear Martin,

    Thanks for updating, I had actually forgotten about this! 

    It is still a rather annoying problem, especially given that the previous version of OME was able to do it without issue.

    The question that comes to my mind is - why does OME not use Redfish to ask the iDRAC to initiate a graceful shutdown/reboot? OME is clearly capable of interacting with the iDRAC directly, and the graceful shutdown options that you can invoke via the iDRAC menu work perfectly.

    I also think that OME should be smart enough to identify whether the graceful restart operation has occurred successfully, and either retry or halt the update process.

    Having systems hard reset without graceful shutdown is a real problem!

  • DellMartinS

    Moderator

    •

    3885 Posts

    •

    25816 Points

    2

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2026 13:40

    Modern OpenManage Enterprise (OME) is an out-of-band Linux appliance that communicates only via Redfish APIs to the iDRAC. It has no direct access to the Windows kernel, unlike legacy OME which used in-band Windows agents.

    with kind regards Martin/ Liebe Grüße Martin

     

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

     

    DELL-Martin S

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell


  • kingtrw

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    •

    8 Points

    3

    1

    Posted November 5th, 2026 14:03

    Dear Martin, 

    I was referring to the previous version of the Linux appliance OME which handled these reboots properly.

    If I log in to the iDRAC web interface and invoke a graceful shutdown or restart, the system handles it properly - it sends a shutdown system to the OS, and the OS shuts down cleanly. If OME is communicating with the iDRAC, I do not see why this isn't happening.

    Also, OME can communicate directly with the operating systems if you enable SSH and provide it with the appropriate credentials - this is required if you want OME to inventory and update operating system drivers.

     

    (edited)