UNSOLVED

Terry McLaren

updated

4 years ago

Closed

TM

Terry McLaren

1 Rookie

•

4 Posts

0

1850

May 18th, 2023 12:00

XPS 13 9315, motherboard replacement, SSD data loss

Wow, the motherboard failed after 5 months and Dell replaced the motherboard but failed to tell the customer or the technician the SSD is integrated into the motherboard, so ALL the customer data is lost. What a fundamental design and engineering flaw! Has anyone else been blindsided by this fundamental problem? So, now I'm trying to get the original motherboard back from Dell and try to recover the data. Is that even possible if I can get the original mainboard back?

Any help or references would be greatly appreciated.

Terry McLaren

  • JOcean

    11 Legend

    •

    12621 Posts

    •

    69453 Points

    354

    0

    Posted May 18th, 2023 12:00

    You will not get the MB back as stated in the warranty conditions listed here. Specifically this segment as stated in the terms:

    "Dell owns all parts removed from repaired products and, in most instances, you will be required to return defective parts to Dell".

    I am not a Dell employee...I am forum volunteer

    Serious work on an E5430 and constantly building and working on an i5-6500 Desktop

  • ejn63

    12 Elder

    •

    31866 Posts

    •

    156343 Points

    344

    0

    Posted May 18th, 2023 13:00

    Unless the customer is prepared to pay $2,500 or more, which would be a conservative estimate of the cost to recover data from the system -- and even then accept that it may or may not be possible to recover it at all, the answer is no.  With any system, backups are critical -- even more so with any solid state drive, which range from impossible to recover to expensive to recover even when they're separate parts.  When they're part of the system board, the only sure path is a board repair plus data recovery.

    It's an expensive lesson in why backups are critical.

  • ejn63

    12 Elder

    •

    31866 Posts

    •

    156343 Points

    309

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2023 06:00

    The design started with Apple (all Macbooks have had soldered-on SSDs for some years now) and has continued to spread.  It's more common than not to have soldered SSDs on very slim systems. 

    And whether soldered or not, a major failure of a system board can destroy a solid state drive.

    No matter what you buy, keeping off-system backups is not just a good idea -- it's essential.

     

  • Terry McLaren

    1 Rookie

    •

    4 Posts

    312

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2023 06:00

    This mainboard failure should have nothing to do with the HD/SSD, however, it does by design. Bad laptop design, if the customer wanted a tablet they would have bought a tablet. The first mainboard only lasted 5 months, we'll see how long the next one lasts.

  • HGX592

    20 Posts

    30

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2023 21:00

    Indeed... backups are vital for any data you would be upset if you lost. Not just on systems that have soldered SSDs (bad, bad design decision), but on any system at all. Any SSD or HDD can suddenly fail, not to mention the possibility of malware or a failed update causing data loss.

    That said, it is unacceptable that the 9315 was designed this way. I expected better, Dell. These are disposable laptops being sold as premium units, at premium prices. I don't care that Apple did it first.

    FWIW, I will never buy a laptop with a non-removable SSD or without a headphone jack. Even Apple, who "bravely" removed the headphone jack from their phones, still has them on the Macbooks, as far as I know. I am typing this on my XPS 9310, which looks to be my first and last XPS, given the way they are going now.

  • Terry McLaren

    1 Rookie

    •

    4 Posts

    181

    0

    Posted June 23rd, 2023 05:00

    This unit mainboard has failed twice in the past 6 months and Dell is doing the run around so going for round 3. This unit is NOT reliable and has cost me time, money and lost data.

    Code of Conduct. Also read, Dell warranty, returns, compensation policies. DELL-Admin>

  • Simone B

    1 Rookie

    •

    2 Posts

    0

    0

    Posted August 18th, 2023 15:50

    Same issue, motherboard broken and SSD no more accessible. I lost 1 year of work. That is an incredible failure from a design point of view, considering that the XPS heats like a radiator. I will never buy again a Dell Laptop.