UNSOLVED

Dave_4100

updated

23 years ago

Closed

D

Dave_4100

1 Rookie

•

10 Posts

0

10264

January 15th, 2004 21:00

Hey! Broken Keys

I have a Inspiron 4100 thats about 2 years old now.  This morning, while catching the computer as it fell off a table, I broke two keys.  You know, the little plastic x scissor hinge attachments.  Not the keys themselves, and the little rubber tapper itself is fine.  Just one of those tiny tabs that hold the top half of the x down.

I'm sure you've all seen these posts before, I did do a search before posting.  Its not a rare issue.  Seems to happen a lot, actually.  The response is ridiculous- you have to replace the entire keyboard.  No, Dell doesn't carry individual keys.  Entire keyboard, because of a flimsy tiny little bit of plastic

I don't understand the economics of this.  It would alienate any rational customer to learn that he or she has to buy an entire new keyboard when something so simple breaks, something that would be easy for a company such as Dell to add onto the much flaunted "award winning customer support".  Sure, the profit margins would be small on a plastic hinge that must cost a couple cents, but to not carry replacement parts for an often broken part doesn't make sense.  I would suppose that the keys don't break down while on warranty to statistically justify it, but I'd guess that those keyboards that are replaced on warranty are 'professionally refurbished' with a few cents of plastic and then resold to the next poor fellow that buys a replacement keyboard.

I have two requests.  The first is to Dell.  So I can't get replacement keys, I'm off warranty and I have to shell out for a new keyboard.  I would like to know why this is the case.  I know that Dell doesn't sell 'individual keys', but since this is a common issue that appears to be easily fixed, I would like to know the reasoning that corporate dell is following, if it can be changed, and if so, how.

The second request is to anyone out there that has already bought themselves a replacement keyboard.  There is really no reason why I should benefit from your expense, but if anyone out there has an old inspiron 4100 type keyboard not being used, it would be greatly appreciated if you could salvage two or three of the standard key sized plastic scissor attachments and drop them in the mail to me.  Feel free to send me a private message if you are willing, or tell your friends or someone who can help.

Thank you.

Dave.

 

  • LogicalDecay

    1 Message

    1015

    0

    Posted January 16th, 2004 17:00

    I agree, this does seem to be a ridiculous issue. I recently purchased an Inspiron 600m laptop and if it were to suffer minor damage such as yours has I would be outraged at having to replace the entire keyboard. I hope Dell sees fit to change their policy regarding this.
  • Dave_4100

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1015

    0

    Posted January 16th, 2004 21:00

    Thanks for the support.  I'm pretty surprised that no one else has responded after a whole day though.  I thought that a dell representive would at least try to address my concerns.

     

  • jodiann23

    1 Message

    1015

    0

    Posted February 18th, 2004 09:00

    This has happened to me too. My cat mistook my keyboard for a scratching post. 2 of the keys that popped off went back on easily. But the N key is toast. That little scissor thing under the key cap is broken. This computer is only 2 weeks old but I doubt if my issue is warrantable. And I don't want to have to send this in. Does anyone have another option for me?
  • Dave_4100

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    1015

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2004 22:00

    Well jodiann23, as you can see, I never recieved a response to either of my questions.  Dell just doesn't seem to care about customers after they have already bought a computer.  At least that has been the case with my attepts at getting customer service and tech support.

    I ended up buying a non-functional keyboard on ebay for replacement keyhinges.  If you have a 4000 series inspiron and my parts would work, I'd be willing to send you a replacement for your key, if you haven't had much luck already.  Feel free to send me a PM.

  • labombard

    2 Posts

    1015

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2004 12:00

    My daughter's Inspiron 5100 has 2 broken keys, and it's 1 month old! This resulted from simply wiping the keyboard off. Dell has not responded yet to our e-mails re: this issue. Over the phone, the answer was as you have said - we need to replace the keyboard. Also, because we admitted to doing this, it isn't under warranty. And I'm sure the phone conversation was all recorded.

    I do wonder why Dell post directions on how to replace the keys, yet they won't sell (give!) us replacement keys:  http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_input&message.id=14096