
UNSOLVED
Closed
Difference between Nvida 5650 and ATI 9600
Have to say that I think all owners of Nvidia 5650 are breathing a sigh of relief... The performance of the ATI 9600 in no way reflects the hype that surrounded its inclusion in the 8600.
I have a 5650 and was desperate to swap it based on the hype but with a 3DMark01 score of 10090 and 3Dmark03 of 2700 it looks like it can compete fairly closely with what the ATI is doing so I'll wait for the next generation of DX9 chips to come out and stop listening to people like AnandTech
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
beastyben1
138 Posts
370
0
Posted December 20th, 2003 22:00
dont be too sure, the 5700 might put up some good numbers

Vandal98
13 Posts
370
0
Posted December 19th, 2003 15:00
The FX 5650 is not a bad card and it can handle most current games well. Anandtech (and other reviewers like Gamers Depot) showed similar benchmarks with 3DMark01 and 03 when comparing the 5600 Go cards to the 9600 Mobility line. The problem is that it can't do DX9 well and this is reflected in the 5600's poor performance in real game benchmarks using DX9 features. In the tests shown on their reviews, the 9600 scored 2-4 times higher framerates than the 5600 in numerous games. Again, this was using real games and not the synthetic benchmarks that Futuremark produces.
I purchased an I8600 last month with the 5650 card and was impressed with it for a lot of games such as Warcraft 3 and Max Panye 2. There were a few games however that did not preform well at all and could not be played with certain anti-aliasing or features that used DX9 pixleshading. It was because of this and the availabilty of the 9600 in the I8600 that I decided to return the system and order a new one. It might seem petty but considering the amount that I spent on the system I wanted to be fully satisfied with every aspect and felt, for me at least, the ATi card was a better product.