UNSOLVED

dunolde

updated

19 years ago

D

dunolde

24 Posts

0

3655

May 20th, 2007 20:00

please recommend HD partitioning software

Just received and set up an XPS withlarge HD (320 G).  I want to break up the one 'C' drive into 3 or more smaller drives.  I have an older version of Partition Magic but am wondering if there are any newer and possibly ore reliable solutions?  TIA
 
PS:  XPS is running just great!
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    252

    0

    Posted May 20th, 2007 21:00

    Assuming it's running Vista, you'll need a new utility. Partition Magic is one, and Acronis Disc Director another. There are others as well.
  • keithg2

    2 Intern

    •

    935 Posts

    252

    0

    Posted May 21st, 2007 13:00

    Acronis Disk Director is compatible with both XP and Vista. This utility works very well.
    Partition Magic is not compatible with Vista.
  • 252

    0

    Posted May 21st, 2007 19:00

    You may want to consider the FREE; “Gparted: download here, it just works …

    http://gparted.sourceforge.net/

     

    Misha

  • dunolde

    24 Posts

    252

    0

    Posted May 21st, 2007 20:00

    thanks for the replies. Acronis really destroyed a previous computer, requiring three days of tech support to finally restore everything, that is, Reinstallation of WINXP and total loss of all data etc, so Acronis is not an option. In another thread or forum there is mention of the partitioning ability built into Vista itself, and that Partition Magic only "messes things up". I'm going to look into "Gparted."
  • 252

    0

    Posted May 21st, 2007 21:00

    Check it out, be careful, it simple interface and it boots form CD; make sure you have back-up if any important data on Hard Drive,  I use it often, Acronis and Partition-Tragic, may work for some people, I am staying clear off them, since I had repetitive bad experiences…

     

    Misha

  • dg1261

    623 Posts

    252

    0

    Posted May 21st, 2007 23:00

    Partition Magic and GParted are similar, so you probably won't find that one works and the other doesn't.

    The vast majority of problems with Partition Magic can be traced to users who try to install it and run it from within Windows. It's really a DOS program, and when run from a DOS boot disk or from the PM CD, version 8 has a reliable track record. Trying to change a partition you are actively booted into is less reliable.

    However, Microsoft ignores the partitioning rules when it comes to Vista.

    Since the dawn of time ... well, since 1981 when the PC era began ... partitions have always been sized in units of whole cylinders. That means partitions always begin and end on cylinder boundaries. (Ever notice how you can't always get a partition of an exact size? It ends up rounding up or down to the nearest cylinder boundary.)

    Vista, however, blithely ignores the industry standard and may create partitions that begin or end in the middle of a cylinder. Partition Magic and other tools that follow the rules will have trouble with such a partition layout.

    Note it's not necessarily that the operating system is incompatible, it seems to be the non-standard partition layout that is the problem. If your disk uses an industry-standard partition layout, Partition Magic should work (especially if used from DOS). Otherwise, you could have trouble.

    Vista systems that are upgraded from previous XP (or earlier) systems will often use a conventional partition layout. I've noticed many Dell systems that come with Vista preinstalled seem to use unconventional partitioning.
  • dougery

    2 Intern

    •

    89 Posts

    252

    0

    Posted May 22nd, 2007 23:00

    Acronis DD get's my vote.  Works flawlessly for me. 
  • sublime11

    1 Rookie

    •

    27 Posts

    252

    0

    Posted May 25th, 2007 14:00

    I must reply to this.  I have an XPS 710 core2 Duo cpu E6700, 2GB Ram, 500GB serial ATA 11 hdd, 512MB  ATI Radeon X1950 XTX crossfire video cards-great with XP, but I wanted to install Vista.  I purchased Acronis Disk Director Suite 10 so I could partition the hdd, would not work!  I spent hours on this, downloaded the latest version, contacted Acronis support and Dell and I still can't use this software to partition the drive.  I create the partition in the Director, assign the drive letter, set the partition as active NTFS, then when I do the required reboot the new partition just disappears.  Does anyone have any idea what I'm doing wrong?  I even did a check disk, but it seems ok. There are three partitions on my hdd now,  one NTFS set as active-primary, one FAT16 active and one FAT32 active.  Help?!?  Everybody recommends Acronis, but it sure isn't working for me
  • 252

    0

    Posted May 25th, 2007 21:00

    I lost hard drive, doing partitioning with Acronis, trying to install XP and Vista Dual Boot; luckily I did the back-up before the “event,” I have been using partitioning since 1975, when on my Toshiba laptop I installed 4 OS, back than it was a challenge, it is still not cake-walk; Acronis and Partition-Magic (Tragic) are in my opinion, over-promising, platforms with high rate of failure, Acronis have no Tech Support you can talk to; Try freebies like i.e. “Gparted” http://gparted.sourceforge.net/

    Download s/w  (ISO image) burn the CD from ISO, do backup, start your PC from the CD, the GUI is simple, If you need help the Forum is available on Gparted Web Site, like here many people over there are willing to help;  I used it on 40GB 5 years old PC and managed to squeeze Vista Ultimate and XP Pro and it worked  just fine after the Acronis disaster.

     

    Misha