Memory Configuration for 6x 16GB DIMMS, i think i might have them installed
incorrectly?
Hello, I have a dell r720 and 96gb ram in a 6x 16gb configuration. They are dual rank dimms @ 1866mhz.
I have the dimms installed in A1,2,3 & B1,2,3 slots according to the manual.
and its recognized in idrac as the following:
But I'm still getting slow performance in memory intensive apps, do i have them installed incorrectly? I notice the manual doesnt give an example option for having 6 sticks installed with 2 processors.
Do i need to get two more stick so that slot A4 & B4 are installed?
Whats the right way to install 6 dimms with 2 processors....or is this just something that I shouldnt do?
edit: I see the following in the manual around "populate 4 dimms per channel" does this mean i have to get 2 more sticks?
That is correct, you can go with 4 or 8. For maximum performance you would want to populate across all 4, but as you saw it wasn't stating it was an unsupported configuration at 6, but it isn't recommended based on performance.
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!
That is correct, as seen on page 45-46 in the manual found here , there isn't a 6 dimm supported configuration. Also you were almost correct, it is 4 dimms per processor, or 1 dimm per channel, across the 4 channels. So I would agree with you that you will need to add a couple dimms to maximize performance.
Let me know if this helps.
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!
Hi Chris, I'm really struggling here as my expected times are double what they should be so thanks for the response.
I just dont understand why 2 extra dimms for 6 total (in slots A3/B3) could cause the everything to slow down like that...I thought that as they're installed in pairs that and fill the channel on both processors that it shouldnt be an issue. But are we saying here that with two processors the dimms always need to be installed across all 4 channels for both processors?
So i can add 2 dimms, but could i also for now perhaps remove 2 dimms (for 4 total installed/2 per processor) to increase my performance?
As an FYI the 6 memory modules are all 16GB (1x16GB) Dual Rank x4 PC3-14900R (DDR3-1866) Registered CAS-13 Memory Kit
I wish I knew this previously, I've removed 2 of the DIMMS and have 4 and performance has picked up to where I think it should be...its definitely about 30-35% faster then before.
Thats quite a drastic dip in performance for adding the 5th,6th DIMM, IDRAC and the system were all reporting the memory as expected at 1866 without any issues, is there any way to tell that the performance from the installed ram is not optimal? Would a benchmark in something like AIDA 64 show this performance drop?
Thanks again, i suppose I'll run some more tests at 4 DIMMS, and then order 2 more (for 8 total) if the performance numbers stay where they should.
I wish I had asked here before, i've spent an uncountable number of hours troubleshooting everything else but the memory as nothing was showing an error (or unsupported).
DELL-Chris H
7 Practitioner
•
9682 Posts
•
48046 Points
529
0
Posted June 7th, 2021 06:00
That is correct, you can go with 4 or 8. For maximum performance you would want to populate across all 4, but as you saw it wasn't stating it was an unsupported configuration at 6, but it isn't recommended based on performance.
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!