UNSOLVED

raw4986

updated

25 years ago

R

raw4986

1 Rookie

•

22 Posts

0

1508

April 24th, 2002 16:00

Surges

i just bought a Power Sentry Surge protector from Costco

it was $20 and offers a $300,000 Lightening insurance

is this too good to be true?



XP Pro
512 Ram
P4 @ 2.2Ghz
40x Cd
16x DvD
80 gb HD
NVidia GEForce3 TI200
Telephony modem
Turtle Beach Santa Cruz Sound
Office XP Pro
Harman/kardon 206 speakers
Microsoft Visual Studio 6.0 Enterprise Edition (retail)
  • olefin56

    689 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 16:00


    Hi

    Never heard of the name.
    I will stick with APC, they cover my $2000 Dell.

    Dayton



    Dimension 8200 @ 1.8GHz
    In Service 12/06/01
    512MB RDRAM, 40GB, HD
    21 in. P1130 Trinitron Monitor
    Windows XP Home
    Toshiba PCX1100 Cable Modem
    Linksys BEF SR41 Router
    IE 6.02, Communicator 4.9 and 6.2
    Zone Alarm (Free)
    Criminals love gun control



  • sonoffred

    141 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 16:00


    raw4986 wrote:
    -- is this too good to be true?
    -
    No. But read the fine print on the warranty, and be sure your outlet is grounded.

    Dimension L550r
    Win98 SE
    384 MB SDRAM
    80GB Seagate Barracuda IV HD
    40GB Maxtor DiamondMax Plus HD
    Samsung SD-608 DVD-Rom
    ATI All-in-Wonder 128 32MB PCI
    Creative Sound Blaster AudioPCI 64V
    Aztech MDP3880-W 56k PCI Modem
  • Walfanski

    13 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 18:00

    Yes, in fact my new Dimension 4400 is being paid for by our homeowners insurance. A squirrel ate through the neutral wire on the transformer and destroyed electrical devices in over 25 homes. We lost our computer, stove, microwave, 2 televisions, ect...PSE&G (our local electric company) is also paying deductables and claims. Not all homeowners have coverage for electrical devices. Check your policy.

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 18:00




    Hi,


    Just a thought, I've been reading the posts about power surge/lighting protectors, has anyone ever collected or heard of anyone collecting for a loss?

    Bev.

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 19:00



    Hi, walfanski.

    I agree about the homeowner's policy, mine's the same. (less the deductible) But, I would like to know if the surge protector warranties have ever paid out?
    My power supplier also, covers 100% replacement with no deductible, any surges/lighting problems on all my appliances etc, that are connected to thier system for a fee of $5 per month, but the kicker is, the phone lines are not covered, hence my use of APC devices.


    Bev.






    Message Edited on 04/24/02 09:35PM by shesagordie
  • raw4986

    1 Rookie

    •

    22 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 20:00

    doesnt dell offer a new warrenty--

    isnt the complete care warrenty sort of like 'act of god' coverage?

    XP Pro
    512 Ram
    P4 @ 2.2Ghz
    40x Cd
    16x DvD
    80 gb HD
    NVidia GEForce3 TI200
    Telephony modem
    Turtle Beach Santa Cruz Sound
    Office XP Pro
    Harman/kardon 206 speakers

    Microsoft Visual Studio 6.0 Enterprise Edition (retail)
  • Walfanski

    13 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 23:00

    From what I've heard, the companies make you send them the burnt out surge protector for inspection. Then they determine X, Y, and Z and deny your claim. That's why I didn't even bother.


    Message Edited on 04/24/02 07:04PM by walfanski
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2002 23:00




    Hi, walfanski.

    That's what I've been thinking, it could be a "merchandising gimmick" thats why I asked about it.

    Bev.

  • olefin56

    689 Posts

    429

    0

    Posted April 25th, 2002 00:00


    Hi

    APC's warranty does require sending the burnt surge to them.
    That is only good business practice for if they didn't I can
    think of how many false claims that people would file.
    They also don't warranty it if it wasn't properly grounded.
    I can't question them for that. Plenty house wiring is improperly grounded.
    I can't blame APC for requiring that the terms of the warranty be met.
    I feel sure if you have a true claim APC would pay as their warranty states.

    Surge protectors do work:
    Several years back the line behind my house took a direct hit. It fried everything
    in my house that had a 115 volt transformer, except on one TV I had a very cheap
    surge suppressor, it fried the suppressor but only blew a fuse in the TV.
    My home owners policy covered all damage less the deductible.
    I still live in a lighting prone area and I turn off my desk power
    panel at a double pole switch every night or before a storm.
    The surge protector remains grounded.

    BTW, surge protectors are also used in all UPS.

    Dayton



    Dimension 8200 @ 1.8GHz
    In Service 12/06/01
    512MB RDRAM, 40GB, HD
    21 in. P1130 Trinitron Monitor
    Windows XP Home
    Toshiba PCX1100 Cable Modem
    Linksys BEF SR41 Router
    IE 6.02, Communicator 4.9 and 6.2
    Zone Alarm (Free)
    Criminals love gun control