UNSOLVED

skotwo

updated

20 years ago

S

skotwo

30 Posts

0

22416

June 17th, 2006 05:00

2407 A02--Problem with Banding in Vertical Gradients?

I received my replacement A02 yesterday (enormous thanks, ChrisM).
It appears to have corrected banding in horizontal gradients, but not vertical--has anyone else noticed this?  If this a continuing problem with these monitors, how do we go about getting it corrected?
 
The banding is quite noticeable when viewing the images on the following thread:
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=58783
and also while running the "Color Spectrum" test on CheckeMON.
 
Since I still have my A00, I decided to run the two monitors head-to-head (although I only have 1 DVI output from my video card, so the A00 is running in analog, that is no problem, as I understand that there are no gradient issues with the A00 running off the VGA input) and take a couple of photos of the screens--If anyone can help me regarding posting them, please let me know, I have both 5MP and 1MP photos [CHRISM:  is there any way I can get these photos to you for review?].  There is definitely a big difference between gradients on the A00 with VGA input and the A02 with DVI input.
  • 774

    0

    Posted June 17th, 2006 10:00

    I am waiting my A02 now and am worried if this issue still exists, because I will no longer be able to return this monitor when I will be getting A02.
    I found a pic regarding vertical gradients issue at japanese forum.
     
  • 774

    0

    Posted June 17th, 2006 14:00

    That photo is a pretty accurate picture of what it looks like. There is still banding in vertical gradients.
  • solidus667

    11 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted June 17th, 2006 21:00

    Please email the images you are displaying to test with. I can compare on my own 2007 A00, 2007 A02, and 3007 A01.

    chris@abichandani.com

    -Chris
  • Goldy67blue

    10 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted June 18th, 2006 22:00

    The banding on those pics doesn't look nearly as bad as mine, infact that pic looks negligable. Could just be the poor quality of the photo maybe?
     
    Those original images are in the link on the first post if you want to test your own monitor
    Images:

    Message Edited by Goldy67blue on 06-18-200606:24 PM

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    774

    0

    Posted June 20th, 2006 12:00

    All,

    You must be in the Optimal preset resolution (1920 x 1200 at 60 Hz) and in Desktop Mode, not Gaming or Multimedia.

    Are any of you using Gamma Correction software?


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • 774

    0

    Posted June 20th, 2006 13:00

    Yup. Everything is default, no changes to the gamma or colors in the output. The monitor simply seems to have a problem with vertical gradients.
  • raizing

    3 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted June 20th, 2006 15:00

    Please Test this image in (DVI) Desktop Mode.
    http://hetyo-wiz.mydns.jp/hw_upload/~2407wfp/file/up2407WFP_0044.png

    And you will be able to confirm this result.


    There is banding in vertical  gradients x1 to x10.
    http://hetyo-wiz.mydns.jp/hw_upload/~2407wfp/file/up2407WFP_0062.png

    And,you can find there is banding in horizontal gradients x1 to x2,too.
    http://hetyo-wiz.mydns.jp/hw_upload/~2407wfp/file/up2407WFP_0074.png

  • skotwo

    30 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted June 20th, 2006 19:00

    As with WHOAguitarninja, confirming that I am running everything at default in desktop mode (1920 x 1200 @ 60 hz), with no gamma correction software.
  • dantehu

    3 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted June 21st, 2006 08:00

    as a pool people using the A00 until now, I have to say~I am waiting for the banding problems been solved
     
    for people who already got their A02.....you will do it again --- send back to DELL ---
     
    folks~ waiting for A03...
  • Gpinner

    34 Posts

    173

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2006 21:00

    I've done tones of test....and I too have the same problem on a A02. So, if this happens to most A02 and Dell has no plans to realese A03....what can I do?

    Refund seems to be the only option.

    For all graphic designer outthere: The color picker in Photoshop clearly shows the banding!!!