I wish to thank everyone on the forum for providing insights on the various pros and cons regarding Dell's monitor. I've read a lot of them, often negatively flavored, but still decided to purchase the monitor based on price and overall reviews on the net (did an extensive google search, also of newer revisions).
But to the point, the negatives I associate with the monitor I received was:
- brighter from left to right side, but this is a lot less noticeble when lowering brightness to 30 (I understand this brightness issue might be related to limitations of production and technology...).
- had a few bad pixels, but no clustering of these
- horizontal lines in the lower end of the monitor, easily solved by lowering sharpness
- not entirely horizontal, but this was adjustable
- when output via vga from xbox 360 image is stretched when running 1920x1200 compared to "native" 1080p.
Of positive notes:
- VGA and DVI worked perfectly, I dont care about component (havent even tried it). DVI is for PC, VGa for XBOX 360.
- I didn't notice the horizontal lines on the monitor, when sharpness was set to 50, unless I focused on this. I consider this more than acceptable to live with.
- I consider the image stretching to be very minor, 120 pixels, and dont necessarily prefer 1:1 reproduction to a larger image (IF the stretching is "minor")...
- AND MOST IMPORTANTLY (to me): The shaprness, color reproduction, screen size, adjustability/stability of foot, number of inputs and the comprehensive menu + fast switching button between signals, more than make up for the shortcomings listed above. I love it when I play games and I also love it when working on documents at home (I work as a researcher at the Univiersity of Stavanger, so I have some experience with word editing). Text reproduction is spot on, coupled with pretty solid white levels and good contrast to my subjective eye at least, since I have not done any objective measurements or benchmarkings as of yet. Dark is not entirely dark, but dark enough. At least compared to my old Benq 937+ monitor. But I think this goes as a general note, and not as a criticism of the Dell monitor; lcd monitors, and also television sets, obviously have a way to go until they reach CRT levels of contrast and also perhaps color reproduction.
Only regret I have, I wish this monitor was present at my office now when I do the time consuming and utterly boring transcription of interviews. 19" just aint an option anymore. I might just have to suggest a new investment here at the faculty, at the next budget meeting :p
I hope this review was objective enough. This was the least I could do to credit the forum and users here, including you Chris.
I have to add another minus to the monitor concerning the green trail you get when you scroll explorer pages etc. But, this is again a minor gripe that I believe you will get used to pretty fast.
So to answer your question, I would buy it again without hesitation considering the vaule for money and the overall pros ans cons. I am indeed craving it for my office. Anyway, you better ask me this question in a month or so when I really get the "feel" for the monitor. I might be too positive minded right now. But if it doesnt break down by then I strongly predict I wont wanna part with it anytime soon.
If you can PUT UP WITH all of these problems, and the many others you have not covered, its a adequate monitor, it displays a image.
Or yer you can always get USED TO these defects.
Its cheaper than other 24" coz its got problems..........
So i think your fooling yourself in thinking you are getting a bargain when you buy the 2407wfp, i think in reality its more like your getting ripped off ?
But the 2407 just looks soo good dosent it, really impresses your friends.....
It seems just as you have misinterpreted these minor problem, you also misinterpreted me. Man.... I thought i was very constructively civilized and indeed got your point and i never recived the wrong impression from you, so please there is no need to apologise to me, but thanks anyway.
Fraid you missed my point.
I see the problems I listed as minor, even though you may not, and I also see many strenghts overshadowing those issues. There are also many aspects I've not covered, since they dont affect the usage I have of the monitor at the moment. That might change in the future. These are after all FIRST IMPRESSIONS. And I did not buy the monitor for its looks. I was also considering an Eizo monitor, and at at time also Samsung and Acer models. Of course there is no denying it sits well on the desk indeed, wont complain there. Thanks for making that point :)
Sorry if you got the wrong impression... I just tried to provide another input. And next time, please be more constructive in your comments. No need to hammer a civilized dicussion.
Well, I am like you, I am really happy with my Dell 2407. I have the A02 revision. there is no banding, no ghosting nothing like that. There is the small lag in games, but that is inherent in all LCD's.
But, I notice you are having a problem with green bars when you scroll though some websites, this on is a good test for it. Well here is the solution.
In the dell menu change the colours to less 90 or less. Brightness no more than 40. I think if you use red at 87, green at 82 and blue at 90 you will have no problems.
Btw, I was playing SC: Double Agent last night. The picture was fenomenal, a real showcase HD-game for both xbox 360 and the monitor. Even the smallest sweat trails, veins and muscles on Sam Fischer's face were made apparant (a good place to sample this is on the prison break mission). The texture of the agent outfit he's wearing when capturing the oil tanker was no less impressive. Cheers :D
I am glad that worked. I used the monitor calibration tool in Vista, and it works a treat!!
Yeah I had big issues with my monitor at the start, but now I love it. Like you say, everything looks so good and clear on it. And with the colours and brightness configured right, it is awesome!!!!!
europa303
1 Rookie
•
4428 Posts
1015
0
Posted November 22nd, 2006 18:00