UNSOLVED

ebrahms

updated

21 years ago

E

ebrahms

6 Posts

0

8816

July 6th, 2005 22:00

BIG Problems with 2405FPW Hardware/Software

In the title I stated BIG problems with the Hardware/Software. I say HW/SW because after 9 hours on the phone with 4 different Dell departments and 3 different "unknowledgeable techs" in the chat help room, no one knows how to solve this problem and if it is hardware or software related.

I bought the 2405 to accomplish one thing...use my 2 desktop computers with a single monitor and allow me to operate or at least view, both desktops on the monitor by taking advantage of the PIP feature or the PBP feature.

After scouring hundreds of searches and posts I know one thing for certain..you cannot use the analog (d-sub) from one computer and DVI from another and get PIP or PBP. That has been my experience and those of at least 5 others I have read about on these and other forums, so we know the problem isn't a defective monitor. We all can toggle between sources but, they cant be put side by side or with PIP.

So the question becomes: Is it possible to use 2 computers on this monitor and get PIP or PBP and if so, how on earth can it be configured to so so? The back panel only has a single DVI and a single analog input. The other 3 are composite, component and s-video. At this point I will use shoe string and a paper clip with 86x77 resolution, I just want this thing to work as advertised and even a low res PIP in the corner will accomplish my goals.

I just dont think its possible and shipping this thing back to Dell will be a royal PITA.
  • luuie

    14 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2005 00:00

    I suspect it's not possible. May I ask: why buy a huge monitor just to have two desktops side by side in little rectangles? Why not get two 2005fpw for about the same price, and get a multi-monitor arm set up like these (for example). http://www.lcdmonitorarm.com/lcd_arm_5.htm
  • delta7000

    2 Intern

    •

    454 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2005 10:00

    Have you tried posting your question here? They have a lot of discussions going on the 2405?

    http://www.hardforum.com/

    delta

     

  • ebrahms

    6 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2005 12:00

    Just joined that forum and about to post the same question.

    Thanks.
  • polasy

    18 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 8th, 2005 12:00

    The only way I see with this monitor is to have grafic card with video output. Also the quality composite video for the PIP mode would be enough.
  • ebrahms

    6 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 8th, 2005 13:00

    My card does have S-video out and I tried it. I can say it "works" but the issue with the s-video output is extremely poor resolution.  It is essentially unviewable.  Furthermore, when using the S-video output, the PIP box is locked on the "small" size and cannot be made larger.

    A suggestion from the other forum is to use a DVI to component video adapter.  The component input is able to recieve a much higher resolution than S-video.  I will assume it will work the same way as the S-video and allow me to accomplish my goals.  We'll soon see I just ordered the adapter on ebay at this link:

    http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=61396&item=5787305248&rd=1&ssPageName=WDVW

     

  • polasy

    18 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 8th, 2005 13:00

    I have a DVB-T TV receiver connected to the S-Video input and I can select 3 different sizes, but all three are quite small.

    Are you sure that inserting a component signal increases the PIP size?

  • ebrahms

    6 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 8th, 2005 14:00

    All 3 should be identical in size if using the s-video input. You can select small, med, large but, they are all the same size.

    How is the resolution/picture quality thru S-video? What resolution are you setting the screen for?
  • polasy

    18 Posts

    308

    0

    Posted July 11th, 2005 06:00

    In my understanding the assumption was that component input gives a bigger PIP size, which I doubt. It seems for me that the PIP size is independant of the input, also the 1900x1280 DVI input is very small in PIP mode.

    I can see small changes in size if I set small, medium, large.

    The s-video quality is OK. You have 5 image smooth settings. For me the smoothest setting is not smooth enough. You can not set a resolution for s-video. It is PAL format in Germany 720x576.