I received my new A02 2007wfp replacement - Thank you Chris for being so prompt!
No dead or stuck pixels, and text is so sharp - I love it. However, I don't know what to think about the banding issue, which is after all, the initial and most stressing problem. I am using the VGA, so banding should be reduced somewhat.
Now comes the strange part: there is no banding whatsoever when doing any gradient test (checkmon, etc), but there is significant banding when doing a simple gradient in photoshop or even powerpoint. Websites with gradients: some OK, some bad. Same with pictures.
However, banding is identical to my initial A00 monitor. And since I use the 2 apps mentioned a lot, the banding is upsetting for me. That's why I initially requested the replacement.
Now I have to return a monitor. If I return the A00 one, there is no way to ask for a replacement again (for me the banding is still there). On the other hand, if I return the A02, I will miss its sharpness, but maybe, maybe, I get another one with no banding.
What to do? Is my replacement a bad one? Should I ask for another one? Is it even possible to do this?
Anyone experiencing the same problem?
PS. Banding is identical in all 3 modes: desktop, multimedia and gaming
@Tekviper wrote:
The replacement A02 I recieved had exactly the same if not worse color banding. I sent it back and am waiting for another replacement.
Tekviper, did you PM Chris or talked to a representative about the new replacement?
I have talked to Chris about the problem and have sent the monitor back. I checked my dell account and i see another monitor has been shipped as an exchange, crossing my fingers that this one corrects the problem.
It is my opinion that you/we are looking at the limits of 24 bit color representation with the products entering the market today, such as the 2007. The brightnes of recent display technology is so high and the gamut so wide that banding (contour) resulting from the limits of 8-bit per primary channel and the nature of human vision as it is adapted to common working environemnts is to be expected, especially in the shadows.
At the 2007WFP price point, design features that could relieve the problem to provide the highest fidelity are not be expected.
Beyond manufacturing tweaks such as fixing the config error in the 2007WFP A00 firmware, you will not see this banding problem addressed until the design of the entire graphics pipeline, from data representation to applicaton/OS to graphics card to display cabling to panel is revised.
If you want to spend three times as much money as the commodities 2007WFP on a 20 inch display you can get slightly smoother performance from some NEC panels. If you want to spend ten times as much you can get an Adobe RGB capable display that will expose beyond a shodow of a doubt that the whole graphics subsystem needs to be revised and updated.
Basically, you are living in a golden age of the existing design and the "problem" you think you have is less-so a product defect and more-so that you are 'seeing' the limits of low cost design an old design exposed by the recent advances in LCD panel technology.
After my previous post I realized I had not read the original post carefully enough. My previous comments do not withstand the following situations:
- are you certain the display is being used in "desktop" mode which according these forums is the only mode which the firmware adjustment affects.
- banding can be a consequence of the graphics card, and/or the app/OS config, and/or monitor calibrartion software, and/or display ICC profiles. Are you using the display in 24-bit (32-bit) color mode? Is there an problematic ICC profile assigned to the display in Windows? Is a specific application affected more than others?
My intention is to provide some context for understanding performance problems. Forgive me if my hand-waving is not really helping anyone.
It is not my intention to distract anyone from Dell's taking meaningful steps to address what is clearly a significant performance problem, and I want to say how much I appreciate that Dell is addressing the issue on these forums.
Thanks all for your replies. It was 32-bit, desktop mode, all color profiles tried and deleted, etc. Banding identical with A00. Contacted Chris, he suggested that my A02 is OK.
Anyway, I got tired of replacements and phone calls and arguing. I sent the A00 back, I am keeping the A02 for its sharpness, and probably I will treat it as it it - a cheap piece of equipment.
Mudcrutch
44 Posts
473
0
Posted June 29th, 2006 01:00
there is some banding on MOST lcd monitors in this price range.
you are pushing your luck trying to get another one -- it could have dead pixels, the same banding, backlight bleeding issues, etc.