UNSOLVED

DRMRyan

updated

18 years ago

Closed

D

DRMRyan

3 Posts

0

86941

September 24th, 2008 14:00

Inspiron 2200 battery compatibility

Hi everyone, first post so be gentle with me :) I did do a search first and couldn't find the answer.

 

I have an Inspiron 2200 and the battery life is now down to minutes. I bought a new battery for it (genuine Dell), but it differs. Physically it's identical and looks like it should fit.

 

The old battery is NiMH 9.6v, part number P5413.

The new battery is Li-Ion 14.8v, part number M5701

The laptop part number is PP10S

 

The seller assures me that it'll be fine, and I'm reasonably confident that this is correct.

 

Can someone confirm that it's ok and I'm just being paranoid? I went for a genuine part to avoid causing problems.

 

Thanks

 

Darren

  • Balaji Ramanath

    2 Intern

    •

    1765 Posts

    1347

    0

    Posted September 24th, 2008 19:00

    If the battery voltages are different, I doubt it will work.  In fact, if the replacement battery is a much higher voltage, be extremely careful.  In many cases, higher voltage will irreversibly damage hardware components on the laptop.  Maybe the difference in battery chemistry has something to do with the voltage difference, but unless the battery supplier is willing to insure your laptop against electrical damage caused by his battery, I would not take his word on it.
  • DRMRyan

    3 Posts

    1347

    0

    Posted September 24th, 2008 19:00

    It's a voltage rating though. Surely that's max capacity of draw rather than what it'll spit out all the time.

     

    The seller of the battery tells me that it was an option when the machine was sold. I've tried to look this up on Google but it's a 4 year old computer so I'm not getting any joy.


    Daz
    Message Edited by DRMRyan on 09-25-2008 11:21 AM
  • DRMRyan

    3 Posts

    1347

    0

    Posted September 24th, 2008 20:00

    Thank you for the reply. I believe that the M5701 has built in regulatory electronics to prevent it frying the computer, or the battery. But my concerns are the same as yours, I want to be sure that it's safe *before* I try it. Otherside I'll send it back.

     

    What I want to know, is does anyone have information that confirms that this battery will work with my 2200. Indications are from here and the internet than both the P5413 and M5701 will work with an Inspiron 1000. I'd like a positive (or negative) response to my question rather than a supposition.

     

    Daz

  • Balaji Ramanath

    2 Intern

    •

    1765 Posts

    1347

    0

    Posted September 24th, 2008 20:00

    There is no difference between voltage and voltage rating as there is between current and current rating.  The voltage listed is the voltage that exists across the pins of the battery.  If you connect a circuit between the pins of such a battery, it will exert a potential of 14.4V (or whatever the rated voltage is) across that circuit.  That will force a certain amount of current through that circuit depending on the characteristics of that circuit.  If the circuit was designed for 10V and you push 15V across it, the current through the circuit will increase by 50% and the components on that circuit may react pretty badly to the increase in current (which will cause increase in heat produced proportional to square of the increase in current, so in this case the heat produced will be 2.25 times the heat produced at 10V).

     

    In the case of current and current rating, the actual current depends on what the circuit decides to draw and the battery only limits the maximum current that it can supply.   The actual current depends on the voltage and characteristics of the circuit.  So for practically any circuit (not just electronics like laptops, but even for appliances like light bulbs), there is a voltage it is designed for and higher voltage will most probably cause failures, somtimes spectacular failures (try plugging a bulb designed for 110V into a 220V circuit, but do it from a safe distance!).

  • gotajet

    1 Message

    1347

    0

    Posted December 3rd, 2010 09:00

    I have a Inspiron 2200 and bought a 5701 Battery and it is NOT recognized and will not charge in my pc.

  • 1347

    0

    Posted January 2nd, 2011 12:00

    I bought a 14.8v battery for my 2200 and it does NOT work. It will recognize that there is a battery but will not charge it. VERY frustrating as my understanding was that the 2200 was made to work with both 14.8 and 9.6. This apparently is not the case. If you have a 9.6v, you'll need to buy a 9.6v battery.

    Luke

  • KyTourist

    1 Message

    1347

    0

    Posted November 20th, 2011 08:00

    Be sure to UPDATE your BIOS to ver. A07.

    See: http://www.atbatt.com/product/7924/laptop/dell/inspiron-2200/battery#tabs

    **NOTE** If your original battery is NiMH you will need a Bios update to run Li-ion batteries. Click Here for Latest update.

    Battery does not ship with door cover. Requires door cover off original battery

    I am using a 14.4v Li-ion battery  just fine on my (now ancient) Inspiron 2200 after my 9.6v NiMH battery began showing its age (down to 47 minutes per charge).

     

     

  • khmiller

    8 Posts

    1347

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2016 13:00

    yes, this is an ancient thread, but my 2200 still runs well.  i can confirm it has BIOS A03 and the Li-Ion 14.8 M5701 battery (original) and has had no problems except it has min charge life now.  need new one as i'm considering dabbling w installing Linux and the laptop still works - might as well experiment.

    out of curiosity - my clock keeps resetting to 2005 - is that the bad Li battery life or is it the system coin battery somewhere inside?

    kyle

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1347

    0

    Posted February 23rd, 2016 09:00

    It's likely a bad CMOS battery.  It's a CR-2032 lithium button cell - very common battery.  The palmrest needs to be removed to replace the battery (it's located atop the mainboard).