UNSOLVED

rjdean

updated

22 years ago

R

rjdean

6 Posts

0

2140

April 3rd, 2005 23:00

Virtual Memory - Inspiron 9200

I have a Inspiron 9200 with Windows XP sp2 and I have 2GB of ram installed. I can't seem to adjust the virtual memory above 2046mb. In the Virtual Memory dialog window I have tried to set the custom settings to 3070 intial and 4096 max, but after a reboot in it still is set at 2046mb. I have tried to have the system manage the memory but that still is set to 2046. after a reboot.  I have set it to be no pagefile and have deleted the pagefile and then tried to reset to something higher than 2046. Nothing seems to work. If I take out one memory chip to have only 1GB memory, I'm able to set virtual memory up to 4096mb.
 
I've posted this problem on a number of Microsoft NG but no one seems to understand this problem. I also have a Dimension 8400 with 2GB memory installed and it has the same problem.
I have 10 or so other Dell systems that I manage that have 1GB of ram and I don't have any problems setting their virtual memory.
 
Does anyone have a solution?
  • WayWalker

    5 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 4th, 2005 20:00

    I have a Dimension 8400 that I purchased about 6 weeks ago and I can't change the virtual memory setting either. I did contact Dell tech support about this and the tech told me that Dell deliberately sets the virtual memory based on the formula of a minimum of 1.5 times the amount of your physical RAM and a maximum of 3 times the physical RAM. The tech told me that Dell did this to keep users from getting out of memory messages due to tinkering with the virtual memory.

    I suppose the idea is to reduce the number of calls to tech support due to out of memory messages. I'm a little indignant about this because I feel I'm "up to the task" of setting the virtual memory size. Anyway, the tech told me it can't be changed. I suppose there is a way to change it besides reinstalling Windows XP from a retail upgrade package. Surely, there is some other way to change it but I don't know if it is worth the trouble as long as everything is functioning properly.

    Hope this helps clear the matter up a bit for you.

    WayWalker

  • rjdean

    6 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 4th, 2005 22:00

    Thanks for the input. I checked another system that my boss has and it is doing the same thing. So three out of three with 2GB of memory seem fixed at 2046 mb virtual memory.
  • msgale

    2 Intern

    •

    2507 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2005 02:00

    I have not been able to verify this statement directly, but I believe from what I remember from a book I can't find the total memory virtual + real on desktop PCs is limited to four gigabytes.  In your case two gigabytes of real memory plus two gigabytes of virtual memory.  The limination is their because on thirty-two address lines are provided and there is no code to support segment address changing.  Even with the EM64T processors which brings out thirty-six address lines, Windows XP will not be able to exceed four gigabytes until operating system support is enabled/included.  Linux can, Windows server can also but they do it in a slightly different way.  I do not believe Dell inhibits in any way the ability to change page file size.  Here is a test - try to set you page file to fixed 512 megabytes.  See if that works.   
  • rjdean

    6 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2005 05:00

    If I set virtual memory to no page file and then reboot I'm able to set the virtual memory to say 4095 or even 512 as you suggested, but after the next reboot it will return to 2046. I assume what you say is correct. That there is a limit of 4096 for the sum of ram & virtual memory. Even though the three systems with 2GB of memory that I have access to are all Dell computers I can't see why they would hinder XP. It must be Bill and his guys not getting it right.
  • msgale

    2 Intern

    •

    2507 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2005 12:00

    I have no idea why Microsoft gets the blame for everything under the sun, they got it right.  Remember for most desktop PCs there is only thirty two adddress lines, therefore the practical address limit becomes 2^32 which is about four-gigabytes.  Now with the EM64T processors there will initially be thirty-six address lines hence an address space of 2^36 sixteen gigabytes.  
  • rjdean

    6 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2005 16:00

    Please don't get upset about the Mircosoft comment. The only thing they haven't done is make finding an answer easier. Even their dialog box for virtual memory assumes at least 3070 will work since it suggests that as a starting point. I assumed from the start that there was a limit of 4GB and was mainly trying to confirm that I wasn't mistaken. I have posted this same question now in 5 different newsgroups and you are the only one who claims yoou need to count ram & virtual memory. Everyone else claims that I don't know what I'm doing or the the amount of ram is not part of the equation.
    Thanks for your input.
  • msgale

    2 Intern

    •

    2507 Posts

    332

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2005 18:00

    Please remember thaty I only said that I kinda remeber what I said, I am not absolutely sure.  Also I vaguely remember that with more that on disk the rule change.  I have a PC with only 384 RAM but two SCSI disks I thing I will experiment.  Any interesting results I will post back