UNSOLVED

Daroga

updated

23 years ago

Closed

D

Daroga

51 Posts

0

6792

January 20th, 2004 14:00

8600 Impressions

Initial impressions of the Dell Inspiron 8600

Yesterday (1/19/04) I received my shiny new Inspiron 8600 from Dell.  After what seemed to be an intolerable wait to let the poor machine recover from its frozen trip through Minnesota, I powered it on and got it set up.

I thought with this I’d cover some of the problems/complaints that others have expressed on these and other forums.  If you have any other questions for me, do ask here and I’ll answer as best as I can.

Screen:
The biggest issue plaging the 8600 model currently seems to be the WSXGA screen problems with ghosting, bleeding light, etc.  Well, I opted to take the easy (yet more expensive) way out and went for the WUXGA screen.  I can’t say that I regret a dime spent on it.  The screen is small (especially when I set the fonts back to 96dpi), but in just a day I’ve gotten totally used to it.  Of course, my still-young eyes may complain when I’m 40 that I stared at tiny text in graduate school, but that’s an issue to deal with later ;)  The wide screen format is just great.  As I type this in Word (to alleviate spelling issues), I can be browsing the forums right next to it.  Word set to 150% zoom makes it more than readable.  I also set IM fonts to be a bit bigger, since I seem to have more issues with small things that I am typing and reading, but that’s just my personal preference.  The screen has none of the issues of 1/5th being dimmed or anything goofy like that.  There’s not a dead pixel on the thing.  It is, simply put, the most amazing computer screen I’ve ever seen.  Also, the screen doesn’t bounce at all when I type.

Keyboard:
Some people have complained about the keyboard on the 8600, flexing to too clicky (or, ironically enough, not clicky enough).  I think it’s just about right.  I don’t notice any of the flexing I’ve heard talked about and I can type just about as fast on it as I can on a normal desktop keyboard (only slower as I’m still getting used to it a bit).  The only thing is perhaps I’d like to see the depth of the keys increased just a very small amount.  Sometimes, with my sloppy typing I catch my finger on the bottom of a key next to the one I’m pressing.  Other than that, it’s very nice.

Pointing Devices:
I’ve used an IBM Thinkpad quite a bit in the past so the TrackPoint-style pointer device is something I’ve grown used to.  I have very little experience with the TouchPad, but I’m getting used to it.  It’s nice to have the scroll features setup in the edges of the TouchPad.  The buttons for the TrackPoint are mushy and generally not nice to use as others have reported.  I usually use a two-handed method—right on the stick left on the buttons under the touchpad.  All-in-all, they’re both adequate pointing devices, thought nothing beats my wireless Logitech mouse sitting next to me on my desk.

Graphics:
I did get the 128 MB Radeon 9600 Pro Turbo and I really, really like it.  I haven’t thrown much at it yet in terms of games, but it played UT2003 at max settings at the 1280xsomething resolution flawlessly.  Just to entertain myself, I did set it at 1920x1200 in UT2003. It looked beautiful and probably would’ve been more than playable, but it was a little chunky for me.  It’s nice to see game makers using these wide-screen resolutions.  I have yet to play around with different drivers and such, but that will come when I have time.  I haven’t had any heat issues, though, as I said, I’ve not done much gaming (at the time of writing I’ve only had the machine for about 16 hours) yet.  I’ll be messing with that in the days and weeks to come.

In the end, thus far, I’m very happy with my purchase.  If you’re considering getting this machine, don’t let horror stories in the forums convince you otherwise.  It’s a great machine and, for the price, a great value.  Do get an extended warranty and the Complete Care.  The laptop will fall, and you will not want to replace the screen if/when it breaks.

Like I said, let me know if you have any questions for me about the machine!

Tim

  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2004 23:00

    OH BOY , oops.

    Sorry about that.  I mistakenly hit enter, but becuase I'm not completely used to working on a notebook yet, I wasn't quick enough to hit stop on the browser.

    But I'm still not sure how it repeated twice! anyway.

     

    Keyboard cont'd:  Ok, I can now confirm to you that virtually the right half of the whole keyboard is tighter, seemingly better put together (whatever might even constitute that.. .go figure), than the left half of the keyboard.  Strange... I suppose this is component specific to the way these things happen to be assembled inside... Well, dunno..

    I assume some of you might think I'm too picky, but these things are obvious to me... I'm not the only one with the screen problem, either.

    Thanks for lisening.  I'm still not positively sure whether I will exchange, keep, or return this notebook.

    I mean this stuff ain't cheap, and I just want good build quality after paying this much dough.

    What do you guys think here?

    Also, please somebody help me on this as I've asked 3 times, and haven't gotten a response.  I've read about the WSXGA problems, and how they're possibly linked directly to the supplier, as the culprit... ? 

    Now, how do I know which screen I have?  Sharp, Hitachi??

    Is there a sure-fire indicator?

    Thank You

     

    i8600 wuxga 32mb video card

     

  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2004 23:00

    Hi there.  You have a really nice setup

    I've had mine now for a week, and I'm not very happy with it, although maybe I was just expecting too much.  But also, I've barely used it during this past 1.5 weeks to be exact. I have the WUXGA screen, but it's not as bright as I expected to be, overall.  Other than that, it's beautiful and the clarity and crispness is gaga!

    At 1st glance, right after delivery, and setup of course, etc... I did notice almost immediately at the inconsistent light intensity (or maybe temperature, as in the left side, at least to my eyes, WAIT A SECOND.. hahaha, as I was just typing this.. right now... basically, ok... since it's a wide screen, naturally you can't see it square on, like an ordinary screen, so it's really an optical illusion.  once I shift my head rather to the right or left, as opposed to dead center, the intensity does change.  Ok, that's cleared up.  But really though, in the beginning, I did nonetheless notice one thing immediately (still not positively sure here), and that is the right side of the screen being slightly darker than the left side, but as I look at it now, it might be the continuance of the wide-screen woes, generalities, etc.

    Keyboard: testing now, as I did notice this at other times.   ok, just tested a whole bunch of random typing.  VERDICT!>> left side of the keyboard, namely, the asdxc area, it's more noisy here, uhh, hmmmm not sure, becuase i just typed on that area lightly, and it just clicks differently as opposed to the more quiet

  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2004 23:00

    Hi there.  You have a really nice setup

    I've had mine now for a week, and I'm not very happy with it, although maybe I was just expecting too much.  But also, I've barely used it during this past 1.5 weeks to be exact. I have the WUXGA screen, but it's not as bright as I expected to be, overall.  Other than that, it's beautiful and the clarity and crispness is gaga!

    At 1st glance, right after delivery, and setup of course, etc... I did notice almost immediately at the inconsistent light intensity (or maybe temperature, as in the left side, at least to my eyes, WAIT A SECOND.. hahaha, as I was just typing this.. right now... basically, ok... since it's a wide screen, naturally you can't see it square on, like an ordinary screen, so it's really an optical illusion.  once I shift my head rather to the right or left, as opposed to dead center, the intensity does change.  Ok, that's cleared up.  But really though, in the beginning, I did nonetheless notice one thing immediately (still not positively sure here), and that is the right side of the screen being slightly darker than the left side, but as I look at it now, it might be the continuance of the wide-screen woes, generalities, etc.

    Keyboard: testing now, as I did notice this at other times.   ok, just tested a whole bunch of random typing.  VERDICT!>> left side of the keyboard, namely, the asdxc area, it's more noisy here, uhh, hmmmm not sure, becuase i just typed on that area lightly, and it just clicks differently as opposed to the more quiet right

  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2004 23:00

    Hi there.  You have a really nice setup

    I've had mine now for a week, and I'm not very happy with it, although maybe I was just expecting too much.  But also, I've barely used it during this past 1.5 weeks to be exact. I have the WUXGA screen, but it's not as bright as I expected to be, overall.  Other than that, it's beautiful and the clarity and crispness is gaga!

    At 1st glance, right after delivery, and setup of course, etc... I did notice almost immediately at the inconsistent light intensity (or maybe temperature, as in the left side, at least to my eyes, WAIT A SECOND.. hahaha, as I was just typing this.. right now... basically, ok... since it's a wide screen, naturally you can't see it square on, like an ordinary screen, so it's really an optical illusion.  once I shift my head rather to the right or left, as opposed to dead center, the intensity does change.  Ok, that's cleared up.  But really though, in the beginning, I did nonetheless notice one thing immediately (still not positively sure here), and that is the right side of the screen being slightly darker than the left side, but as I look at it now, it might be the continuance of the wide-screen woes, generalities, etc.

    Keyboard: testing now, as I did notice this at other times.   ok, just tested a whole bunch of random typing.  VERDICT!>> left side of the keyboard, namely, the asdxc area, it's more noisy here, uhh, hmmmm not sure, becuase i just typed on that area lightly, and it just clicks differently as opposed to the more quiet right side.

  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2004 23:00

    Hi there.  You have a really nice setup

    I've had mine now for a week, and I'm not very happy with it, although maybe I was just expecting too much.  But also, I've barely used it during this past 1.5 weeks to be exact. I have the WUXGA screen, but it's not as bright as I expected to be, overall.  Other than that, it's beautiful and the clarity and crispness is gaga!

    At 1st glance, right after delivery, and setup of course, etc... I did notice almost immediately at the inconsistent light intensity (or maybe temperature, as in the left side, at least to my eyes, WAIT A SECOND.. hahaha, as I was just typing this.. right now... basically, ok... since it's a wide screen, naturally you can't see it square on, like an ordinary screen, so it's really an optical illusion.  once I shift my head rather to the right or left, as opposed to dead center, the intensity does change.  Ok, that's cleared up.  But really though, in the beginning, I did nonetheless notice one thing immediately (still not positively sure here), and that is the right side of the screen being slightly darker than the left side, but as I look at it now, it might be the continuance of the wide-screen woes, generalities, etc.

    Keyboard: testing now, as I did notice this at other times.   ok, just tested a whole bunch of random typing.  VERDICT!>> left side of the keyboard, namely, the asdxc area, it's more noisy here, uhh, hmmmm not sure, becuase i just typed on that area lightly, and it just clicks differently as opposed to the more quiet right side. 

  • Daroga

    51 Posts

    468

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2004 00:00

    As I said above, I hadn't noticed these keyboard problems.  In fact, even now, looking for this problem I don't notice it.  "A" feels the same as "L" and everything inbetween is good.  If there's a real problem with your keyboard, you may want to see if Dell wil swap you out one.

    Tim

  • viper11885

    791 Posts

    461

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2004 00:00

    About the keyboard on the 8600. I tried out one of my friend's 8600 that he ordered during the christmas holidays. He got it a bit over a week ago. I have the 8500 that had the keyboard issue, but I fixed it myself.

    Anyways, on his machine, I found that the keyboard was much better. Actually, the left side was very solid and I didn't have any problems typing on it at all. No flex or anything compared to mine before I fixed it.

    Btw, it was ordered from Dell Canada in case anyone was wondering.
  • FearNo1

    83 Posts

    468

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2004 02:00

    My main gripe with 8600 is the cheap feeling eraserhead and mouse buttons. 8100's eraserhead/mouse are much better.
  • Varsev

    45 Posts

    468

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2004 04:00

    Thanks guys, for the input.

    I'll call Dell tomorrow and ask about the keyboard.  The left side axsdf area is definitely different, but mainly from the pressing of those buttons.  Other than that, I can't really say it has more flex than the right side.  It's annoying for sure, though.

    I don't use the mouse buttons much, but on mine, nonetheless, the mouse buttons are ok.

    It seems laptops are just this way... as in, the manufacturing is inconsistent.. ?

    I'll keep you all posted.

    Thanks.

  • Papa Smurf

    37 Posts

    394

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2004 09:00

    hi everyone

    just my two cents on my i8600's keyboard... my left hand side is rock-solid, but it's the right hand side that's a bit flimsy (but luckily, i don't notice the flexing at all while typing, or playing games...) just a question, though. has anyone tried pressing just above the right arrow, where there is no key, just blank space? i think this is the part where the keyboard seems to flex the most, and wondering anyone has similar issue, since no one seems to mentions this...

    thanks in advance

    ??-----Inspiron 8600-----??
    Pentium-M 1.6Ghz
    1Gb RAM
    60Gb 7200rpm HDD
    DVD+RW (NEC)
    ATI Radeon 9600 PRO TURBO
    15.4" WUXGA+
    Win XP Pro
    Dell TrueMobile 1300 WLAN
    etc etc etc