UNSOLVED

HM Kim

updated

26 years ago

HK

HM Kim

3 Posts

0

13038

March 13th, 2001 00:00

Is he dimension 4100 quiet?

I'm thinking about ordering a Dimension 4100 system. My question is, "How noisy is the 4100?" I don't mind hearing HD noises, but what drives me is excessive noise from cooling fan. My current system is a P3 700 system that I built. It has 2 cooling fans and the noise is driving crazy. I bought a possibly quietest power supply and a case cooling fan for my system, yet the noise level is simply too much especially at night. I understand PCs cannot be dead quiet, but when I can hear my system's roaring noise in another room which is 15 feet away from where the PC is located, I just can't take it any more. I have a Dell Optiflex at my office and it's very quiet. So, I'm hoping to hear from 4100 users saying that their 4100 is quiet.
  • snowblind

    27 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2001 00:00

    The first thought in my mind when I powered up my 4100 for the first time was - "This thing is noisy!"
  • cayuga5

    125 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2001 00:00

    this has nothing to do w/ the 4100 but i think the culprit could be the cpu fan, especailly if it's from a 3rd-party vendor-some of them are quite noisy. one way to find out is stick a pen thru the case cooling fan while the power's off, when u power on, it can't spin. then listen to the cpu fan go to work.
  • vetriguy

    2 Intern

    •

    647 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2001 08:00

    While I'm rapidly learning to hate Dell (as a corporation) I must admit that my six-week-old 4100 is extremely quiet, and I have it sitting right next to the monitor. In my case this is one thing, at least, they got right.
  • lbd20

    30 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2001 12:00

    My Dimension 4100 933 Mhz is extremely quiet. I had a HP before and I never realized how noisy it was until I got this one. I haven't had any problems with my 4100. I am very satisfied.
  • Greenwood

    259 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2001 17:00

    I have a Dimension 4100 and a Dimension 8100, neither of which are noisy and both of which I am very happy with to date.

    Earlier posts from the begining rollout of each system included complaints of fan noise, but I have not read similar complaints lately. They may have fixed the problem prior to my purchase of the two systems.
  • quasar1999

    26 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2001 01:00

    I just purchased an 8100, and my power supply is noisy as hell, WHEN THE MACHINE IS TURNED OFF!!! Figure that one out... The machine is constantly under power, unless you physically unplug it from the wall. WHY??? Why design a computer that needs a power supply to have all of its capacitors charged at all times???

    I don't know about the 4100, but I know for sure that the 8100 is quite loud and annoying, even when it is turned off. (you can hear the transformer whining)
  • G Lang

    2 Intern

    •

    219 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2001 04:00

    I have 2 4100's. One I would describe as quiet. The other moderately quiet. Neither seems excessive to me. Both are noisier than the P166 and R350's I had and Shhh! (the Quantex 266). Most of the noise is just the fan and not the hard drives or fan cage, because both have 2 hard drives and when I unplug any of the hard drives the noise is the same. One has IBM and Western Digital, the other has IBM and Maxtor.
    If they made less noise I would be wondering if the fan was powerful enough to keep the processor cool.

    Hi quasar,
    After shutting down, keep the power button pushed in a few (6 or so) seconds. If you continue hearing it run I would call Dell. Not familiar with the 8100 so I may be wrong, but to me that doesn't sound right.

    Glen
    4100 933Mhz
    19VH001
    FFD4001
    Win98SE
  • quasar1999

    26 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2001 13:00

    G E Lang,

    I am on my 4th replacement power supply from Dell, and they all exhibit the same problem. (And no, my machine is actually OFF, and not in standby or any other power saving state so the holding down of the power button, doesn't solve the problem). It's the fact that they keep the power supply charging its capacitors even when the machine is totally off. Add to that the fact that their transformer is 'noisy', and you get a very irritating high pitched tone coming from the machine. The tech's I talked to blame it on the fact that the power supply is voltage auto-sensing. Hopefully the 4100 isn't, otherwise you all might end up with the same problem us 8100 users have.

    Thanks for your help though,

    -Quasar.
  • bob63304

    17 Posts

    285

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2001 14:00

    Have a 4100 and it is very quiet. I am very satisfied.