UNSOLVED

windag

updated

23 years ago

W

windag

5 Posts

0

21648

November 28th, 2003 23:00

137 GB Barrier? I bought 200GB drive. Can I use it?

I just bought a 200GB Western Digital EIDE ATA/100 Hard Drive for my Dell Dimension 8200 series computer (that I purchased in September of 2002).

Will I have a problem installing the drive directly onto my MoBo, or will I have to use a controller card? I recently updated my BIOS to A09 and I have Windows XP Home SP1.

 

  • haiweigh

    8 Posts

    499

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 04:00

    I will be receiving the Dimension 2400 in a week or so and have already purchased a 200GB Maxtor hard drive.

    I'm trying to see what my best options are for handling the addition of this 2nd hard drive with the least amount of issues. 

    I would like to know how the Dell hard drive is set up...NTFS or FAT32... I'm thinking because of the size (mine will be 80GB) it would probably be NTFS.  That means I have to (or should) configure the 200MB drive to be NTFS also.

    Anyone who has done this before please chime in with suggestions and do's/dont's...

    Thanks.

  • ronss

    2 Intern

    •

    2060 Posts

    •

    3 Points

    499

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 05:00

    windag

    http://www.westerndigital.com

    can find a lot of help at western digital site

    but i am thinking that the 8200 bios will detect the large drive, one thing you will have to update if already haven,t , is the service pack 1 for windows xp. this must be done if using large drive.

    a controller card has extensions for the bios that would ensure the drive would work if all eles fails

    Message Edited by ronss on 11-29-2003 02:01 AM

  • Volute

    27 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 14:00

    I've installed a Maxtor 200GB as an external.  It was inside an ADS Tech external enclosure with a dual USB 2/Firewire interface. My Dimension 8200 (Bios A01, WinXP Home SP1) saw the drive with close to 200GB of space through the USB 2 interface.  I guess the 137 GB barrier wasn't there.

    I've considered installing the 200 GB HDD as an internal but I have an internal Zip250 and all slots are full.  The drive was easy to install in the ADS enclosures.

     

  • windag

    5 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 15:00

    I do have Windows XP Home SP1. I am right up to date with all windows "updates." I also recently updated by BIOS from A07 to A09.

    I also just downloaded a hotfix from Windows (http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;EN-US;331958) that specifically deals with this issue (hard drives larger than 137 GB).

    There's also a small file from Intel that I'm wondering whether or not I should download. It's called the Intel Application Accelerator (http://www.intel.com/support/chipsets/iaa/).

    I found this information from this forum: http://maxtor.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/maxtor.cfg/php/enduser/std_adp.php?p_faqid=960

    I'm hoping that now when I install the 200 GB drive, it will be fully recognized without using a controller card. There are a couple reasons that I don't want to use a controller card. The first reason is that it will take up the last available PCI slot in my computer. I was hoping to install a Combo USB 2.0/Firewire card in that slot. Also, from what I would assume, anything you connect to your computer would be faster if you connected it directly to your motherboard rather than to a controller card. I might be talking about milliseconds here, I really don't know. Does anyone know about this?

     

     

  • 501

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 17:00

    It's best to connect the HD directly to the onboard IDE controller.  The use of a PCI controller card will generally yield a slightly lower transfer speed.

    F.

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted November 29th, 2003 17:00

    haiweigh.

    The first thing required to install a second hard drive in the D/2400, is the bracket for it, see the following for more information about this.

    Dell Dimension 2400 Hard Drive Bracket Kit from  http://www.issue-resolved.com/

    If you require a floppy drive, have you included this option in the D/2400 when you purchased it?

    Bev.

     

  • danceguy

    28 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted December 1st, 2003 01:00

    You should have no problem at all.  I'm running a DELL 8200 purchased in Dec 2001 with original A01 BIOS, and XP SP1.

    My main (master disk on primary IDE cable) drive: is a WD160GB, partitioned as as 137GB C: and a 23GB Q: partition.

    I recently bought a brand new WD200GB on sale for $100. It was very easy to install it and use it as a new secondary disk drive, connected to the ribbon cable that attaches to the motherboard.

    Basic steps were these:

    1. open PC and connect new 200GB drive as slave on primary IDE ribbon cable.

    2. configure the new drive to use CSEL (cable select mode), since DELL 8200 supports it.  In CSEL mode, the master disk is at the end of the cable, and the slave disk is in the middle of the cable.

    3. Turn on PC, and Start->run->diskmgmt.msc -> OK

      This runs the diskmgmt  program to initialize and format the new drive as a single 200GB E: partition

     

    PS: My A01 BIOS has the 137GB limitation, which is why I'm reluctant to try making the main drive a single 160 partition.  Once XP SP1 boots, it can bypass the 137GB limit.  The reason I am cautious is in case any of the "boot startup" files were to somehow get relocated above 137GB ... I would THEORETICALLY not be able to boot. 

    PPS: you did not say if you were adding a secondary disk or replacing the existing disk with the new disk.

    Message Edited by danceguy on 11-30-2003 10:14 PM

    Message Edited by danceguy on 11-30-2003 10:16 PM

  • windag

    5 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted December 1st, 2003 22:00

    Everything is working fine. I installed it a few days ago and it is working fine so far. I also bought the WD2000JBRTL 200GB Special Edition for $99.00 (after rebate, of course) from Circuit City. I thought that was a pretty good deal. Originally, I was going to buy a 120GB Maxtor from Best Buy on Black Friday for $49.95 after rebate (which I thought was an awesome deal), but they had a line from here to China waiting to get in at 6am when they opened. I got there at 5:30am. Guess I shoulda got there at 3am, but I'm not crazy enough to do that (plus it was very cold and raining here in the Detroit Metro area that day).

    Anyway... I installed it right on the motherboard using the existing IDE ribbon cable that was hooked up to my original hard drive (of course hooking up the new drive as the slave with the gray connector). It was already set to Cable Select (CSEL) as the default as all Western Digital drives are. I didn't know that my 8200 was a cable select machine until I saw the jumper setting on my original drive... then I knew to just leave the setting alone on the new drive.

    I did upgrade my bios to A09 like I said, but from what you said, I guess that wasn't exactly necessary. I've had Windows XP SP1 for a long time now, so I didn't have to upgrade to that (which from what I read is mandatory for large hard drives to work properly). I did, however, install Microsoft's Hotfix that deals with hard drives above 137GB. I'm not sure if I had to, but I did. I also installed Intel's Application Accelerator which also deals with this issue. Not sure if that was mandatory, either. Then, after I set my bios to auto-detect the drive, I rebooted and the bios recognized it. At first, it didn't. I had to set the auto-detect feature on Primary Drive 1. Then, or course, Windows Explorer doesn't recongnize the drive until it's been partitioned and formatted. I did this with the disk management tool and partitioned it basically in half and formatted it using NTFS. Windows Explorer now recognizes my new virtual F and G drives. Is there any reason I shouldn't have used the drive letters F and G? My CD-ROM and DVD+RW/CD+RW drives are D and E, respectively.

    At any rate, everything's fine so far. I didn't even use any of the software that came with the drive. Glad I didn't use the controller card, too. That way my last available slot is free for me to add my USB 2.0 / Firewire card that I want to add. I was one of the unlucky ones to buy my computer just before the 8250s came out with USB 2.0 standard.

     

     

     

  • danceguy

    28 Posts

    501

    0

    Posted December 2nd, 2003 15:00

    windag:

    Another reason to avoid using those pesky Promise IO controller cards (instead of connecting the hard disk to the motherboard) is that those PROMISE cards have a big IO bottleneck.  I tried it once (on my DELL 8200), and when I played MP3 files using WinAMP,  there was skips and static when reading the MP3 files stored on the HD that was connected to the PROMISE card....  This happened the very first time playing a song file.  If I replayed the file, the static/clicks were gone.. My theory was that the 2nd time that the file was cached in the kernel memory, so that it did not have to read from the disk drive again.  So, in my opinion, these PROMISE IO cards are not designed to work properly with DELL 8200's...  I know some people are using those disk controller cards to crack the 137GB barrier .. but they don't have a DELL PC, so maybe it works better on other brands of PC's.

    Western Digital sometimes sells big hard disks with those PROMISE IO cards ...

    PS: I also bought the WD200GB HD for $99 from Circuit City at the "black friday sale".. I got there at NOON, and managed to get the very last one in the store ... just one minute before someone else was asking about them ...

    -enjoy the new disk space!

     

  • ronss

    2 Intern

    •

    2060 Posts

    •

    3 Points

    117

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2003 10:00

    some of you guys sure run big drives, i can,t imagine what i would do with all that space. currently running 2 maxtors 40gb on raid 0 giving me a total of 80gb space. at the moment i am using 7gb, with 73 gb free.  running 2 -200gb drives on raid 0- WOW.,,hmm , maybe i need some more space.