UNSOLVED

snr666

updated

18 years ago

S

snr666

85 Posts

0

14223

June 15th, 2008 19:00

Norton Ghost 14 backup on a XPS 730

there is a little known problem with norton Ghost 14 on any machine with memory greater than 2 Gb. if you try to restore using the SRD, it crashes. Norton have known about this and a fix will come sometime. they wanted me to strip down my 730, taking out the 2 Gb of my 4Gb. laugh, no way.

 

i find it hard to believe a piece of software crashes due to much memory, it usually too little.

 

so i bought Acronis. much better as it used a simplified version of linux for its recovery process. the only downside is that its compression is not quite as good as Norton, but its functionality is far better.

 

has any-one any thoughts or experience with these.

  • snr666

    85 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 19:00

    right. good to hear.

     

    when trying to restore from the SRD, custom created using Norton Ghost 14, it crashes when booing from that CD. on every other machine i own, Ghost workds fine. but on this 730, about 95% of the time it will crash. i like Ghost, but even Norton know of this problem.

     

    do you have 4Gb or more ram. this seems to be the problem. a fix is due but when. they can not say, but have know of the problem to some time.

     

    acronis 11 seems ok, not perfect, a little slower, but far more options.

  • Boyd B

    552 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 19:00

    First let let mention I am using an XPS 420 so there may be a difference than with your system.

     

    This is not meant to be critical of Acronis or supportive Of Ghost, but I have used both, and Acronis did not work as it should for me. 

     

    I tried several times to recover from a backup with Acronis and never was successful.

    I used Norton Ghost 14, created a 168 GB backup image of the entire Raid0 array and saved it to my D: drive.

     

    I then installed Vista Ultimate x64 on my Raid0 array and used it for a few days. Did not see any performance increases and some programs would not work. IE7 is not supported for x64.

     

    Long story short. I then booted from the Ghost Recovery CD and reinstalled the C: image from the D: drive and everything was back without one issue.

  • BobT36

    206 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 19:00

    Not tried Norton Ghost as I'd heard some bad reviews and I've used Acronis True Image 11 and Shadow Protect Desktop which both look good, but the backups I do with them fail to verify each time.

     

    The backups actually backup fine, no matter whether I'm saving the backup files to my external USB 500gb Harddrive or my Internal hard drive of me comp, however they just won't verify, theres always some error due to data mismatch or whatever.

     

    This seems to be some fault in my machine though I assume, not the products. Thing is I've not done anything to the hard drive or whatever so no idea whats wrong, I've ran Chkdsk and that finds no problems, meh. 200gb o data is a lot to backup and a lot I don't want to lose. :(

  • BobT36

    206 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 20:00

    What happened with Acronis on pro?

  • BobT36

    206 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 20:00

    Sorry I've just realised this thread was labeled for 730s (mines a 720 H2C) but ah well. :P

     

    Also yeah I've 4gb o ram and running on 32x XP Pro. Did they say its a problem with all backup programs or just theirs? As I've not used Ghost, just the other two I mentioned.

  • Boyd B

    552 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 20:00

    I used both programs on Windows XP Pro and now on the XPS 420 with Vista Home Premium.

     

    I had the issues on Acronis with XP Pro but have not used it on the Vista system.

     

    The Vista machine work perfectly with Ghost.

    Message Edited by Boyd B on 06-15-2008 04:47 PM
  • snr666

    85 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 20:00

    so i believe any machine with 4Gb or greater. i am running XP32 on my machine.

     

    i have a problem with Paragon (a freebe version - failed to work), Norton Ghost 14 (crashed my machine), but Acronis worked.

     

    i think its just bad programming by Norton.

  • Boyd B

    552 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 21:00


    @BobT36 wrote:

    What happened with Acronis on pro?


     

    Acronis would make the backup image fine, or at least it seemed to.

     

    I then made a bootable recovery CD from within Acronis and that seemed to go well.

     

    But when I treid to boot to the Acronis recovery CD, it could never find the recovery image even though I would point it to it and made sure the image was where it should be.

     

    Acronis never could locate the image, so I stopped using it for backups.

     

    When Ghost 14 came out, I started using it and have recovered the image several times.

     

    I do quite a lot of experimenting with software, hince the need for a reliable image backup.

  • pags2

    4 Posts

    581

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 21:00

    I have used the backup in Vista and it works very well for backing up to dvds or an external hd, even with 4 gig of memory. Not sure how good XP is with backups.
  • xcator

    2 Intern

    •

    887 Posts

    181

    0

    Posted June 15th, 2008 21:00

    very strange, as others including myself are using Ghost 14 without problems on systems with more than 2gb ram.   

     

    Just so I understand what you are saying, the problem is that your 730 will not boot the SRD into the recovery environment?  Have you tried booting from the standard SRD (not custom)?  Did you post your problem at the norton community forum? 

     

    As far as ATI 11 being "better" than Ghost 14, you may want to read some posts over in the Wilders Acronis forum for a slightly different perspective.  Ultimately, the real test is to successfully restore the backup image and I have been happy with Ghost 2003 and Ghost 14.