UNSOLVED

ServiceTag

updated

18 years ago

0

57193

January 19th, 2009 16:00

new Dell Inspiron 530 Q6600 CPU fans issue - bad motherboard?

just got new machine out of box and noticed something goes wrong with CPU fan...

It goes randomly into high speed mode and it stays there till I shut machine off. I have a suspicion of bad MDB rather then CPU fan alone since the second fan (chassis) is spinning in high speed as well. When it happens it's very noisy (exactly same as start-up spin for a few second) and it stays. I checked CPU temps and they are all in range 20-30 Celsius which is way below HOT.

I did upgrade BIOS to latest 1.0.16 - no help

I reset BIOS to default (most likely BIOS updating took settings into default anyway) - no help

called Dell TS, they want to replace CPU fan with heat sink first. I was asking for MDB replacement, but they insist on CPU fan first.

I think is waste of time since chassis fan is spinning in high speed as well, so it must be motherboard fan controller or something...

Did anybody had this issue so I can elevate this problem and not loosing time?

Also, does anybody know utility to get fans RPM speed on this Inspiron 530 model? I found something which works on laptops only.

TIA

  • 1138

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2009 15:00

    just an update and if somebody from Dell is going to ever read this forum and starts wondering why they going down.

    here is one of the reason...

    I spent quite enough time to troubleshoot this problem, including complete reloading OS from Vista to XP before I pick up the phone and call Dell TS. As usual, I end up speaking to somebody in India.

    They tried to be very helpful, mostly by reading the script and no matter how much info I provided they keep insisting to replace the CPU fan with heatsink, then later on they added another fan for Chassis. This call took me another 1 1/2 hours of my time.

    Same day after I collected additional info about the fans speed and all temps I decided to chat with Dell TS for another 2 1/2 hours! What a mistake!

    I was politely asking to dispatch MDB just in case. After exhausting explanations to two Indians reps they guaranteed fans replacement are going to solve the issue!? Here is the scoop:

    01/19/2009 10:38:46PM Agent (113643): "We have been working on such issue on this from long time."
    01/19/2009 10:39:15PM Agent (113643): "We are positive that this kind of issue is taken care by replacing the fans on it."

    Today technician from BancTec (you can guess from where? yes, you are correct - from India) was here and he replaced both fans. First, he mounted Chassis fan opposite way - no big deal. After he finished fans exchange I showed him the same problem is still there. waiting he is going to declare defective MDB! To my disbelieve he quickly diagnosed my system - "it must be PS fan"!!??

    At that moment I had enough of Dell customer service/tech. support non-sense and I asked him politely to leave.

    Now, after all this mess it's going to take another 2 weeks to get me system replacement! It could be done in one shot if somebody listens and use their brain and logic! I also called agent above to just remind him his words.... he hang up on me!?

    And that's exactly why Dell is loosing money and reputation big time.

    I am seriously thinking to dump all my Dell business to somewhere else till they give us US support back!

     

  • mcaslan

    1 Message

    1138

    0

    Posted March 21st, 2009 17:00

    Did the motherboard replacement fix the issue?  I have the same system but with a Q8300 and the CPU fan runs so very loud.  Even a reboot does not fix the issue only a power off and power on makes it quiet for a while.

  • rmalvarez

    3 Posts

    1138

    0

    Posted April 10th, 2009 21:00

    I have the smae issue, i am interested in the response. Did it fix.

  • 1138

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2009 09:00

    I also am having loud clicking CPU fan on 530 purchased in 2008... I talked to Dell support several times and they told me to:

    1.Clean out fan area...which we did... 2. Upgrade bios which we did  3.  reseat the chassis fan....  which we did.... we finally left the computer open

    and noticed it was not the chassis fan but the CPU fan    ... and it doesn't click loud all the time.   when we tapped on the top of the computer it stopped.   We were doing an online chat session with Dell (from India) and they could not understand which fan we were talking about... So they are sending a tecnician to replace all fans...

    Right now the fan is not clicking loud and is very quiet.   DO YOU THINK IT'S THE MOTHER BOARD.

    tHANKS

    D.R.

  • Limirick

    10 Posts

    1138

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2009 15:00

    This Inspiron 530 has done this quite a few times, always for a second or two when starting, sometimes remaining loud and not reducing, also sometimes when it's revived from SLEEP,  it's SO LOUD- like a cross between a vacuum cleaner and a private Lear Jet warming up in the yard - maybe the neighbors are impressed- (Maybe I'll get a set of those noise ear muffs or ear plugs like the runway traffic directers wear at the airport.- what's up with that?  Is there any quick fix?  Is my unit about to take off?  Shouldn't it  first get runway clearance from the tower?   Maybe I can take the handle off my suitcase, attach it to the computer's box, and use it to clean the floors. 

     

     

     

  • elid5

    5 Posts

    1138

    0

    Posted May 24th, 2009 07:00

    This Inspiron 530 has done this quite a few times, always for a second or two when starting, sometimes remaining loud and not reducing, also sometimes when it's revived from SLEEP,  it's SO LOUD- like a cross between a vacuum cleaner and a private Lear Jet warming up in the yard - maybe the neighbors are impressed- (Maybe I'll get a set of those noise ear muffs or ear plugs like the runway traffic directers wear at the airport.- what's up with that?  Is there any quick fix?  Is my unit about to take off?  Shouldn't it  first get runway clearance from the tower?   Maybe I can take the handle off my suitcase, attach it to the computer's box, and use it to clean the floors. 

     

     well it is May 2009, and the same problem is happening to my NEW Inspiron 530...was your problem ever solved

     

  • 1138

    0

    Posted May 24th, 2009 07:00

    Dell sent a technician to our house to replace two fans... after changing the fans,,, he immediately realized that the noise was still loud and right away he said the Power Supply needed to be changed....

    Ordered a new power supply and installed the following week....

    Computer is running very quiet again...

     

    Thanks Dell Technician

     

     

  • elid5

    5 Posts

    1138

    0

    Posted May 24th, 2009 07:00

    tried to email you...but would not let me email anyone on this list with the fan problems

     

    have you gotten any solution????

  • elid5

    5 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted May 24th, 2009 08:00

    just an update and if somebody from Dell is going to ever read this forum and starts wondering why they going down.

    here is one of the reason...

    I spent quite enough time to troubleshoot this problem, including complete reloading OS from Vista to XP before I pick up the phone and call Dell TS. As usual, I end up speaking to somebody in India.

    They tried to be very helpful, mostly by reading the script and no matter how much info I provided they keep insisting to replace the CPU fan with heatsink, then later on they added another fan for Chassis. This call took me another 1 1/2 hours of my time.

    Same day after I collected additional info about the fans speed and all temps I decided to chat with Dell TS for another 2 1/2 hours! What a mistake!

    I was politely asking to dispatch MDB just in case. After exhausting explanations to two Indians reps they guaranteed fans replacement are going to solve the issue!? Here is the scoop:

    01/19/2009 10:38:46PM Agent (113643): "We have been working on such issue on this from long time."
    01/19/2009 10:39:15PM Agent (113643): "We are positive that this kind of issue is taken care by replacing the fans on it."

    Today technician from BancTec (you can guess from where? yes, you are correct - from India) was here and he replaced both fans. First, he mounted Chassis fan opposite way - no big deal. After he finished fans exchange I showed him the same problem is still there. waiting he is going to declare defective MDB! To my disbelieve he quickly diagnosed my system - "it must be PS fan"!!??

    At that moment I had enough of Dell customer service/tech. support non-sense and I asked him politely to leave.

    Now, after all this mess it's going to take another 2 weeks to get me system replacement! It could be done in one shot if somebody listens and use their brain and logic! I also called agent above to just remind him his words.... he hang up on me!?

    And that's exactly why Dell is loosing money and reputation big time.

    I am seriously thinking to dump all my Dell business to somewhere else till they give us US support back!

     

     

    was this issue resolved for you?? having same problem

     

     

  • elid5

    5 Posts

    1138

    0

    Posted May 24th, 2009 08:00

    I have the smae issue, i am interested in the response. Did it fix.

     

     

    was your issue resolved...having same problem...