My new Dell came with Vista. After a month or so of casual use, these are my impressions: 1) Vista is classic Betaware. There is NO WAY in the world that Dell should have started shipping Vista on their boxes yet. It's got lots of problems and is really not significantly better than XP. I'm not singling out Dell here as all the other vendors went to Vista the same week. People who actually rely on their computer for real stuff are suffering big time. I already know people who have bought XP to replace the Vista that came on the box. I told them they should send the bill to Dell or Gateway or whatever. Since Microsoft just extended XP support until 2014. I expect to take the same path soon. 2) Having said that, Vista is not Horrible. I've done Horible OS releses so I know. Most issues you can work around and if you just want something new to play around with and have the time to play Mr Fixit then you should go for it. Just do NOT plan on relying on it if you DEPEND on your computer for business or intensive home use. And if you decide to "upgrade" to Vista, make very sure you've left a tral of breadcrumbs so you can drop back to XP. So, I guess what I'm saying is unless you are the Early Adopter type, or have an extra computer to try is on, I would hold off on Vista until at least SP1. -T
I received my new Dell with Vista installed on Feb23/07 ------- on a scale of 1 to 10 my frustration level is somewhere near 35. What a mess --- I am remined of Windows ME.
I know I am in the minority, but I like Vista and have had no problems so far. I received the express upgrade CD last week...I performed a clean install and had no issues. I loaded most of the software that I normally use without issue. I have a Samsung multi-function laser printer (a couple years old) and they had both scanner and printer drivers that work fine with Vista. I haven't had a single crash or error yet, knock on wood.
I will say that Vista is a CPU/memory hog. I would never run it on anything but a new machine with good specs. Yes, you could run it w/out Aero, but then you might as well stick w/ XP!
The release hype for Vista was just like for ME. Windows ME stopped me from up-grading operating systems. To go from something that is operational and functional to one of WHAT???, is very-very frustrating. Spending time trying to find a solution for a problem in a new operating system is not something a business wants to do, or pay for.
1) No problems with my clean install last week on main partition. In fact, I moved Vista from the test partition to my main partition because it ran without major problems. Very much surprised too. I did have to figure out on test partition why it was using high CPU utilization. I have since reinstalled on the main partition with no quirks at all. High CPU utilization did not show itself this time.
2) Vista uses 29% of my 2 GB ram. CPU utilization is between 0-3% at idle.
3) Defrag with UlimateDefrag (requires right-click and "run as administrator")
4) Office 2003 runs fine.
5) Games run fine: Supreme Commander, C&C 3 demo.
6) AVG antivirus running fine.
7) Audigy 2 sound card driver running fine.
8) Used VistaBootPRO 3.1 to eliminate my OS entries on other partitions with no problem. No longer dual boot using that partition of games now.
I really wanted to like Vista but after a month, I just couldn't tolerate the problems any longer. I am fortunate in the sense that my XP Pro notebook is my daily machine and the Vista machine was my toy used for TV, web surfing, and photo viewing.
I had many issues with Vista on a brand new Dell Dimension E520. MCE would fail to play MPEGs without locking up and needing to close, would not play MP3s without audio dropouts near the end of each song, would not open new IE7 windows or display hyperlinks after a given period of time, would not allow me to open certain folders after a period of time without rebooting, and would not record television programs reliably. Because of all these issues, I never did load any additional software on the machine.
Things came to a head last Friday and I gave Vista HP the heave ho and installed XP MCE2005 on it. The difference was truly startling. Immediately, I noticed a 15 percent increase in performance. Additionally, all my problems went away and I was able to being loading software that works flawlessly.
It was never my intention to order a new machine with Vista on it right away. I got by waiting a day from the time I got my quote from my Dell rep to actually placing the order. THe result was that I was stuck with Vista. Fortunately, I had a license of XP MCE2005 kicking around and installed it.
Dell does a grave disservice to its customers by removing the ability to choose from one day to the next a relatively proven OS like XP. I can understand at some point no longer supporting an older technology but forcing this on people from one day to the next with no transitional period is exceptionally poor. There is absolutely no reason why they could not offer a choice between XP and Vista for say a year.
I guess I am one of the rare fortunate owners who really has not had that many bad experiences with Vista yet. While I dislike the fact that all of the settings and customizations have been separated from each other (causing you to have to "hunt" for everything), once you finally get everything setup the way you like it, and you become a little more familiar with this OS, Vista is alright. No crashes or lock ups, and the performance is smooth for me.
My last computer was 6 years old and just wasn't cutting it anymore. I needed a new machine regardless of Vista, and this OS just so happens to be installed on all new computers now, so there was no avoiding it. I personally do not see what makes it "so bad" that people are actually uninstalling it and going back to XP. Perhaps they are trying to run it on systems with less than 2GB of RAM?
I believe the problem is that after 5 - 6 years of using XP, everyone got too comfortable with that OS and aren't too enthusiastic about having to make changes all of a sudden. Developers were also very reluctant and unaccepting of change in my opinion, which explains why there are still so many drivers and applications that aren't functioning with Vista yet.
If there are applications that you simply cannot use a computer without, then you shouldn't use Vista yet because it's still brand new and everyone is still in the adapting phase. This was the same problem when XP came out.
Bottom line is that I will admit that Vista alone doesn't add enough useful features or incentives for users - at this point in time - to make it worth the cost of upgrading to a new machine. So no...going out and buying a new machine just to be able to use Vista is not really worth the cost. However, being able to purchase new systems that are powerful as the ones available today for such inexpensive prices, is definitely worth every penny. And the only reason why they have become so affordable is THANKS to Vista's release. Don't forget that. In spite of all of this, you've got to give Vista credit for one thing though: it is eye candy heaven.
Dell has stuffed up with Vista and I can't forgive them - so I won't be their customer again. I rely on my laptop for work and Vista causing so many problems that I will have to remove it. It is slow, explorer hangs often, CD don't burn well, file copies indicate they will take a day to do and then suddenly finish, IE hangs, a driver on the OEM constantly gives an error.
How did MS sign off on the user testing? How did Dell sign off? Why would they risk jepordising their customer base with beta product? I would never rollout such a unreliable product to my staff - they would crucify me.
I wish I had bought a Mac or another product that offered XP.
chiefeyes
26 Posts
513
0
Posted March 5th, 2007 15:00