UNSOLVED

Phoenix40

updated

4 years ago

P

Phoenix40

1 Rookie

•

9 Posts

0

504

January 19th, 2023 05:00

SSD or Classic Rotating disk ???

Hi Community.

I actually have 2 dell servers (others are HPE)

1 - PE640 / Perc H730P Mini (mini ???) / 6 DELL SSD SAS 12g 480 Gb disk

2 - PE440 / Perc H730P / 9 DELL HDD SAS 12g 15K 600 Gb disk

My question is simple. I have same read/write performance on both server and i need to upgrade capacity on server 1. The price difference between HDD and SSD is 3 (hdd 119 euros) SSD (470 euros).

So what is the goal to use SSD ??????

P.S : We have buy server 1 for SQL Performance needs, but due to change in company, we need more space rather than performance.

  • DELL-Young E

    Moderator

    •

    5421 Posts

    •

    37 Points

    213

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2023 20:00

    Hello,
    "I have same read/write performance on both server and i need to upgrade capacity on server 1. -> In my humble opinion I don't think this makes sense or possible.  SSDs and SAS' are worlds different and they can't be compatible. I don't know what the other community users would think and we can wait around to see.

    Social Media and Communities Professional

    Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services

    #IWork4Dell

    Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!

  • Phoenix40

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    209

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2023 22:00

    Hello.

    I'm sorry DELL-Young E ,perhaps your are too YOUNG to make a good response, but this is a snapshot of my hard drive. I'm not drunk when i write. My question was What is the advantage of use SSD if i have same perf on both server. Classical HDD are 3 time cheaper than ssd

    server 1 diskserver 1 diskserver 1 perfserver 1 perfserver 2 diskserver 2 diskserver 2 perfserver 2 perf

  • Dell-Dheeraj

    1 Rookie

    •

    143 Posts

    188

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2023 01:00

    Hi @Phoenix40,

     

    YoungAh is right in stating that it's not possible to achieve the same read/write performance on HDD and SSD.

     

    The difference here might be the test done on the number of disks between the SSD and HDD.

     

    While the SSDs are 6 and the HDDs are 9, the controller writes/reads to all the disks simultaneously.

     

    We might see a difference when you measure against an equal number of SSD and HDDs.

     

    If your goal is to have more storage than performance, I would suggest you go with the HDD disks as offer more storage capacity.

  • Phoenix40

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    187

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2023 01:00

    Thanks for this technical response. Effectively with 2 more SSD (8) i can achieve more speed, but HDD is 3 or 4 time cheaper, for more space. But i'm surprised that i cant have a significant difference between HDD and SSD.

    Thanks for your help

  • Phoenix40

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    131

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2023 04:00

    That's the pure truth.

    Server 1: 9 disk (600gb/15k/12g sas) 

    Server 2 : 4 disk (480g/12g/ssd sas)

    Server 2 : 4 disk (900g/6g/sata dell)

     

    All the same perf. I think H730 is in cause. H730 mini on server 2. H730 on server 1.

    All cache activated. Horrible perf without.

  • Phoenix40

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    91

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2023 01:00

    Hi. After my questions i see that here there is no Server expert, so you can close and delete this post.

  • Praveen.Singh

    4 Apprentice

    •

    489 Posts

    •

    17 Points

    86

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2023 06:00

  • Phoenix40

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    84

    1

    Posted February 21st, 2023 06:00

    No problem. But just review my photos and just tell DELL to change their markup on disk case. All that was described in this article, i know it from long time. What i dont undestand is why i cant have significant perf on my SSD.

    I clear and simple reponse can be "Perc H730 cant make you have more than xxxxMb/sec read or write". That a clear and technical response. Nevermind article that tell me things i know from 10 or 15 years.