
UNSOLVED
Closed
J
JonathanShefftz
1 Message
0
49978
March 18th, 2008 01:00
Dell Laptop Lemon Policy?
I suppose this could alternatively be titled, how to get Dell to take me seriously?
I bought a D630 with Vista (maybe that’s the problem in the first place?) back in September.
At first its performance was stunningly sluggish, but turning off the apparently pointless Aero effect made it normal.
After a mere few weeks, in November, it became increasingly dysfunctional:
Frequent freezes (numbering in the hundreds), sometimes not until after hours of use, but sometimes after only minutes, and sometimes even at the Windows login screen, or before that, or at the Windows Error Recovery screen, or at the Windows progress meter bar, or even at the Dell screen.
Many incidents (numbering in the dozens) of no display (either to the laptop’s LCD or an external CRT), for which the Fn+F8 toggle has no effect.
A few incidents during which the laptop’s LCD display became jagged, almost like a shattered plane of glass.
About three blue screens, after which the computer restarted within several seconds, so I couldn't write it down, but the top of the screen said something like, "page fault in non-page area" and toward the bottom was something like, "commencing physical memory dump" with various text items in between (which I didn’t have time to read).
A recent pre-boot assessment turned up "Memory - March B Test *** Testing 7F280000h bytes with 02h CPU(s) – Test Results : Fail – Error Code 2000-0123" but the computer then froze, as it did during a subsequent pre-boot test, and with the frequent freezes and display shut-offs I didn’t have time to keep trying to complete the entire assessment.
Almost as dysfunctional as the laptop were the technicians over the phone and via email, who wasted my time with one suggestion and instruction after another that even with my level of computer knowledge was obviously incapable of fixing whatever problem was causing all these symptoms.
Finally Dell agreed to have the laptop shipped back to them. In response to a two-page letter enclosed with the laptop, I received back a three-word hand scribble of "reseat LCD cable" with the laptop still just as dysfunctional as before.
Dell then sent an on-site technician, with instructions to run the SRCD after that. The technician replaced the motherboard (and ran some tests, which all came out ok), and the laptop finally worked for a couple days straight, but then reverted to its old ways (specifically the first two problems above). I ran the SRCD, but part way into the second disk, at about the 70% mark a CRC error cropped up and the laptop froze.
So now back to the same depot that responded to all of this with a three-word scribble and obviously no testing after some quick and entirely ineffectual fix.
All of this would be pretty funny were the joke not on me. I also can’t believe a company would continued to string along a costumer this way who has ensured one of their products that has worked for only a few weeks and then been unusable for a few months after that despite repeated contacts with them - always initiated by me of course, since nobody ever contacts me to follow up on prior efforts.
Is the goal that I’ll give up eventually? At what point do I just call it quits, sell the docking station + power cable + battery on eBay, throw the rest in the garbage, and buy a competitor’s laptop. All the time I’ve put into this is far more valuable to me than the cost of a competitor’s laptop, but I keep thinking that maybe the next time Dell will actually do something to fix this or replace it.
1 person also has this problem
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
laurie_0111
1 Message
1380
0
Posted March 21st, 2008 18:00
I want you to know have an Inspiron 1501 and have been dealing with the same ____ since August, not even a month after I got the computer!!! This is absolutely ridiculous!tempdynamic_duo
2 Posts
1380
0
Posted November 11th, 2012 13:00
I bought my first Dell Laptop brand new 12 months ago and within the past 12 months; the hard-drive has gone out 3 times. I am now 3 months passed my warranty coverage and the hard-drive went out AGAIN!
I called Dell and I was told I need to pay $300 before they will fix it!! I even took it to a Best Buy (where I did not buy it) and their Tech informed me it is a lemon. I now have a new HP and will NEVER buy a Dell ever again! Dell computers are very expensive paper weights and I see I am not the only one dealing with garbage

Todd D.
1 Rookie
•
13 Posts
1380
0
Posted March 21st, 2008 15:00
Jonathan,
thanks for letting us know what is going on. I'm moving your post to a more technical board so that you'll be more likely to get the responses you need to get this resolved.
Thanks,
Todd