
UNSOLVED
New DDR 133 MHz Memory and coments on the RDRAM
When will dell be implementing the new 133 MHz DDR (Double Data Rate) Memory into the systems? And another thing is RDRAM dead, and who can afford to buy more ram after you buy the system? If you notice NO stores carry the RDRAM in any form because one 128 MB stick is $1,000. Thats way to much dough to blow on memory that has not completed testing in the systems. Heres something to think about, why dont the motherboards have more than TWO RIMM's??? This is a extreme draw back! But these are my two cents on this matter...
B. L.
B. L.
Responses (5)
Solutions (0)
David Hendricks
131 Posts
176
0
Posted February 12th, 2000 22:00
brianlan wrote:
- When will dell be implementing the new 133 MHz DDR
- (Double Data Rate) Memory into the systems?
When Intel produces a chipset that uses DDR SDRAM, most likely. DDR SDRAM is different than PC 133. Intel is supposedly sampling the i815 chipset, which uses PC 133. I am unaware of where Intel is with regard to a DDR chipset. Micron has produced a DDR chipset, Samurai. Micron is obviously not Intel and Dell remains an exclusively Intel shop, at least so far.
And
- another thing is RDRAM dead, and who can afford to
- buy more ram after you buy the system? If you
- notice NO stores carry the RDRAM in any form because
- one 128 MB stick is $1,000. Thats way to much dough
- to blow on memory that has not completed testing in
- the systems.
I think the price has come down a bit. Only $600 for 128 MB.
-Heres something to think about, why
- dont the motherboards have more than TWO RIMM's???
Because when Intel shipped motherboards with 3 RIMM slots, the motherboards were not stable.
The reason for the lack of stability is much debated; however, it is clear that because of this problem, i820 was pulled 3 days before its launch, leaving many OEM's, such as Dell, in the lurch.
I don't think that skjohnston's thinking that one only needs 128 MB with RAMBUS is anymore correct than saying that one only needs 128 MB of any type of memory. While this is sufficient for most users, people who do CAD/CAM, Photoshop, etc., will always see a performance boost by having more than 128 MB system memory.
However, I agree that waiting 6 months isn't a bad idea, if one can wait...
I remain unconvinced that RAMBUS will ever really fly. With reports that yields are hovering around 10% (!!!!), I don't see how the price can drop enough to justify the very minor overall performance boost.
Adios!
LOOP="true" QUALITY="autohigh"
PLUGINSPAGE="http://www.macromedia.com/shockwave/download/index.cgi?P1_Prod_Version=ShockwaveFlash">
- I'm building a new rig in the next month and probably the most important items right now are the RAM, mobo (motherboard), and a processor.
That's only because of high-end products and price wars, but eventually I'll have to get something.
As for RAM, for me it's kind of depended on the mobo and the slots. I dont' want RIMMS because Rambus is kinda crappy.
>>Only $600
yeah, ONLY $600.
For now though SDRAM, either DDR or not is still good. Personally, I'll be gunnin' for the PC 133 SDRAM (possibly DDR) later in the month.
I guess I'm not a tech junkie, I'll be honest with you all. but I just thought I'd let ya see it my way.
Travis
David Hendricks
131 Posts
176
0
Posted February 13th, 2000 16:00
In case you didn't know, DDR SDRAM is not backwards compatible with current motherboards. They pin out differently and require a different chipset.
I recently built a box for my Dad and used the Tyan Trinity 400. It uses the VIA 133A chipset and has both a ppga/FC-PGA socket and slot one cpu interface and supports PC133, ATA-66, and AGP4x. If you can find it, I also believe that the Trinity can use VC-SDRAM. The Trinity 400's main claim to fame is that it is used by Micron in their top of the line machines.
Since my Dad doesn't use the computer for much more than tracking his finances, surfing the web and email, I didn't need to use a very powerful cpu; I ended up using a Celeron 500. However, there are a number of reports that, with the Trinity 400 and a FC-PGA slotket card, one can easily pump a FC-PGA 550E to 733; in fact, Anand of AnandTech ran a 550E at 825 without any problems.
On the down side to the board, I was unhappy that I had to set the cpu multipler via jumpers on the board (especially when the setting for 7.5 wasn't documented and I had to experiment) and that there are no thermal headers to monitor cpu temp.
It would be nice if a company like Asus or Abit made a board with the VIA 133a chipset (the Abit VA6 uses the old VIA 133 chipset, which is really not what you want; might as well get a BX board). Keep looking.
As for the price of RIMMs, $400 is a significant reduction in price. Of course, $600 is way too much for 128 MB when one can get high quality PC 133 memory for a quarter of the cost.
Adios!
- David Hendricks wrote:
- Because when Intel shipped motherboards with 3 RIMM
- slots, the motherboards were not stable.
-
- The reason for the lack of stability is much
- debated; however, it is clear that because of this
- problem, i820 was pulled 3 days before its launch,
- leaving many OEM's, such as Dell, in the lurch.
The primary one I'm aware of, from a support standpoint (and remember, support is what I'm all about!) has to do with how RDRAM actually works, and specifically what the MCH (Memory Controller Hub) in Intel's chipset would support.
Unlike SDRAM, which uses a parallel data path, RDRAM uses a serial data path. This is a channel. Along the an RDRAM channel, a maximum of 32 "devices" are allowed. A device is considered to be an individual RDRAM chip on the RIMM itself. With current RDRAM device capacities, typically a 64 MB RIMM will contain 4 devices, a 128 MB RIMM 8 devices, and so on.
During validation, it dawned upon someone that with 3 RIMM slots and the availability of 256 MB RIMMs (16 devices each), that inevitably someone would attempt to install three 256 MB RIMMs, 16 devices over the maximum 32 devices that could be on any one channel. This caused problems, and was expected to cause confusion to customers (as it's non-intuitive when compared to how SDRAM works). Three 128 MB RIMMs work fine, and two 128 MB RIMMs and one 256 MB RIMM also work fine, as these each utilize a supported number of devices.
However, RDRAM device capacities continue to increase, and 512 MB RIMMs are expected to also have 16 devices each (the same as 256 MB RIMMs). This allows for an increase in allowed memory without going over the device limit.

skjohnston
49 Posts
179
0
Posted February 12th, 2000 19:00
As for local stores they dont carry RDRAM because it is damn hard to find. It is a very rare item.
As for the price, right now it is expensive but some sources say that in 6 months it will actually be cheaper the 133 sdram. My solution:
Wait 6 months