UNSOLVED

BP98

updated

23 years ago

B

BP98

36 Posts

0

22515

November 18th, 2003 01:00

Dimension 4100

I have a Dimension 4100 (P3 1 GHz) and am thinking about upgrading my current video card.  I have a ATI Radeon 7500 64MB AGP right now, and I have been doing some reading on the Radeon 9800 Pro (128MB).  For the system requirements, it did say P3, but they recommend a 300W power supply to ensure normal system operation.  After doing a search on these boards, it sounds like I have a 200W in my 4100.  Is that true?  If so, would this 128MB video card still work or is it incompatible with my current system configuration?  Thanks.
  • Dale Nihiser

    2 Intern

    •

    2030 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 02:00

    BP

    Please don't take this the wrong way, but why put a $350.00 graphics card in a $100.00 computer?  Your whole computer would be the bottleneck for the 9800pro.  Why not read over in the upgrade section nd look into buying a case, mobo, an inexpensive cpu, canniblize what you can from the 4100, sound card and hard drive & network cards and build a bare bones system around your 9800pro.  That's the only way you'll ever see the real benefit from owning a 9800pro. 

    Your Ati Radeon is a more than ample video card for your Dim 4100.

    Good Luck

    Dale

    Dimension 4100 (Old Paint)
    866MHz Pentium III----->1.2GHz Tualatin Cele--->1.6GHz
    LinLin 370 socket adapter (geekverter)
    Intel A10 Bios
    256Mb Sdram 133Mhz fsb
    Ati Radeon 7500 64Mb DDR Ram
    Sound Blaster Live Value!
    Ctx 19" monitor
    genericcdrom
    generic cdrw
    30Gb Seagate 7200rpm HD
    WinME (all updates)

     

  • BP98

    36 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 05:00

    Dale,

    Thanks for the suggestion, but I'm not going to build my own system and take everything I can out of the 4100. I've done a lot of upgrades within the past couple of years and I'm happy with it the way it is, aside from today's "newer" games. The past couple of games I played on it (Need For Speed Hot Pursuit 2, Need For Speed Underground Demo) did not work all that well. Both games were quite jerky when I set the graphics to the maximum and had the display set to 1280 X 1024 resolution. Even when I lowered the graphics some, I hardly noticed a difference. Things were still a little jerky. Why would that problem not be the video card? I would think that if it's jerky in any way, I don't have enough video memory. Don't get me wrong, 64MB is a lot, but in five years from now, people will be looking at a 64MB card the same way we look at a 1MB or 2MB card today. For all I know, the problem I'm having with the performance of these games could be the lack of processor speed in my 4100. If that's the case, then I'll have to think about what I'm going to do. I do know that I'm set for ram (512 PC133). So if these two newer games aren't working as well as they should, then any game made from this day forward won't work all that well either. In my opinion, my 4100 can still be upgraded in many ways. That means I'd like to try to rule out buying a new computer or building my own, if possible. I've got enough outdated computers around here as it is!!

    BP
  • Dale Nihiser

    2 Intern

    •

    2030 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 05:00

    There are a lot of factors that affect fps.  Apps running in the background that consume cpu cycles, anti virus software, outdated video/sound drivers, unpatched games, and beta versions, but those are things you already know.

    A Geforce 4 Ti 4200 as I have read on this forum is a good match for your machine and a Geforce 4 Ti 4600 is faster than Nvdia's newer FX5200.  I think any of the Radeon 9000pro, 9100pro with 128mb of ram or  a Radeon 8500LE w/128mb of ram are good cards for your system from ATi and are $100.00 or less online.  Finally I'm not sure your AGP slot will support a 9800pro card let alone your powersupply unit.  More research would need to be done to confirm that.   

    As for cpus, if you're willing to accept risk to attain greater reward, you can buy a cheap $8 ~ $12.00 370 pin socket adapter along with a cheap ($42.00) 1.2GHz Tualatin Celeron and upclock that Celeron to 1.6GHz w/ a 133MHz fsb that will provide you a speed gain equivalent to a 1.8 ~ 2.0GHz P4.  To read up on the subject you can visit www.kilowattalley.com/easy.htm that will provide some background.  Next visit the upgrade forum and run a search using upclock as the keyword.  There you'll find a plethora of information, and you'll also discover the trail is littered with successes, frustration, and some failures.  I said there was risk involved!  But my own Dimension 4100 has been cruising along @ 1.6GHz ever since last spring.  Nothing else in the case is overclocked or being run out of spec.

    So there are some ideas to try and sqeeze a little more life out of the ol 4100.

    Good Luck

    Dale

    Dimension 4100 (Old Paint)
    866MHz Pentium III----->1.2GHz Tualatin Cele--->1.6GHz
    LinLin 370 socket adapter (geekverter)
    Intel A10 Bios
    256Mb Sdram 133Mhz fsb
    Ati Radeon 7500 64Mb DDR Ram
    Sound Blaster Live Value!
    Ctx 19" monitor
    genericcdrom
    generic cdrw
    30Gb Seagate 7200rpm HD
    WinME (all updates)

    Dimension 4550
    P4 2.53GHz------>3.06Ghz w/HT (Dec 03)
    512Mb DDR 333MHz Ram
    533Mhz fsb
    Sapphire Oem Radeon 9800Pro 128Mb w/Catalyst 3.7drivers
    Sound Blaster 5.1
    LITEON Dvd-Rom LTD163
    HL-DT-ST Cdrw Rom 848-1b
    Logitech Optical Mouse MX310
    Viewsonic G90fb-2 19"
    Windows XP Home Sp1 (all updates)
    A05 bios
    60Gb 7200rpm HD

  • BP98

    36 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 06:00

    Dale,

    Thanks for that advice. I do appreciate it. I'll do some research and go from there. I suppose basically what I was looking for from the beginning was simply better performance out of my newer games, whether there's things that I could do with my existing 7500 for better fps, or go to the next video card up if I have to.

    BP
  • sbring44

    217 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 09:00

    BP98,

    Yes Dale has great info on the 4100.  One could say he is a Jedi Knight of the 4100.  I'll bet his lovely wife is proud of him.  What an I saying??  His wife probably feels she has been a "Computer Widow" long enough.  I know my wife feels that way. 

    As for the TI 4200. Mine is back in my 4100.  It was the best upgrade I could do to my aging system without doing the "fast lane" processor upgrades. 

    Dimension 4600
    2.8 GHZ 800 FSB
    1.5 GB PC 3200 DDR Ram
    80 GB HD
    60 GB External Fire Wire HD
    ATI 9800 PRO 128meg
    P991 19" Monitor
    DVD/CD-RW
    CD-RW
    Floppy Drive(A must have for a old timer)
    5.1 SB Audio
    Added Firewire card
    A stoopid modem I didn't want 

     

    Message Edited by sbring44 on 11-18-2003 06:39 AM

  • fredha

    1078 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2003 19:00

    BP98, If you want a card that will match your processor and ram, the ti4200 or the radeon 9500 non pro will work great. You can get both in the 64mb version for less than $100. I have a ti4200 64MB in a computer with an overclocked 1.2 celeron(1704). The card still has more to give than the computer can handle. The bandwith of the p3 and celerons only allow so much performance, that is why higher performance cards are wasted moneywith these processors. AGP slots will start being phased out next year so buying a card for the future isn't a good investment.
  • BP98

    36 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2003 02:00

    Fredha,

    Thanks for that tip; makes sense. Is there a difference between the Radeon 7500 and the Radeon 9500? With both being 64MB, I'm not sure.

    What are the differences between the ti4200 & the Radeon 9500?

    BP
  • Dale Nihiser

    2 Intern

    •

    2030 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2003 04:00

    Bp

    Biggest difference is the 7500 was a true dx7 card in its day while the 9500 is a true dx9 card.   Actually I think the the 7500's gpu has a core clock speed of 290MHz and the 9500's gpu core clock speed is 275MHz.  The 9500 however pulls away due to its faster memory operating @ 540MHz vs the 7500's 460MHz.  The 9500 has four rendering pipelines. I don't know how many for the 7500. 

    I can't help you with the gforce to 9500 comparison but here is a link that compares these various cards. Go to

    http://www.tomshardware.com/graphic/20021218/index.html  

    Good luck

    Dale  

    Message Edited by Dale Nihiser on 11-19-2003 12:37 AM

    Message Edited by Dale Nihiser on 11-19-2003 12:39 AM

    Message Edited by Dale Nihiser on 11-19-2003 12:42 AM

  • fredha

    1078 Posts

    437

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2003 16:00

    Speedwise the cards are about equal, but the 9500 will support DX9 and will have better picture quality.
  • 72

    0

    Posted December 2nd, 2003 19:00

    Question.  The manual for the Dim 4100 says it should use 2x or 4x video cards.  The Radeon 9500 is 8x.  Judging from the other posts, this won't be a problem, right?