
UNSOLVED
Basic Dimension 8400 purchase question
Hello; we are considering a new 8400 for kiddo; homework & games. Please give me your opinion of the three video cards now available
128MB PCI Express™ x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI Radeon™ X300 SE or
128MB PCI Express™ x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI Radeon™ X800 SE or
256MB PCI Express™ x16 Nvidia® GeForce 6800 GTO Graphics Card
Are these all PCI express?
Does the computer even have an AGP slot if one wanted to use an AGP card?
My son has his heart set on the Nvidia 6800 GT (not GTO, i appreciate the earlier message thread on this topic concerning unlocking the extra 4 "pipes"). He is concerned the power supply listed on the 8400, 460 watts, is not "enough", and/or that the physical place in the computer case would not be big enough for the 6800GT. If you don't overclock it, do folks think that 460 is enough for the 6800GT.
Which if these options might sound better to you experience gamer types: go with the current top of the line offering from Dell (the Nvidia 6800 GTO), or, go with their base card X300 and buy an upgrade; if so, what's a good upgrade...6800GT, etc.
Thanks
128MB PCI Express™ x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI Radeon™ X300 SE or
128MB PCI Express™ x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI Radeon™ X800 SE or
256MB PCI Express™ x16 Nvidia® GeForce 6800 GTO Graphics Card
Are these all PCI express?
Does the computer even have an AGP slot if one wanted to use an AGP card?
My son has his heart set on the Nvidia 6800 GT (not GTO, i appreciate the earlier message thread on this topic concerning unlocking the extra 4 "pipes"). He is concerned the power supply listed on the 8400, 460 watts, is not "enough", and/or that the physical place in the computer case would not be big enough for the 6800GT. If you don't overclock it, do folks think that 460 is enough for the 6800GT.
Which if these options might sound better to you experience gamer types: go with the current top of the line offering from Dell (the Nvidia 6800 GTO), or, go with their base card X300 and buy an upgrade; if so, what's a good upgrade...6800GT, etc.
Thanks
Responses (9)
Solutions (0)
- The GeForce 6800GT has 16 pixel pipelines. The GeForce 6800 has 12 pixel pipelines. Draw your own conclusion as to what the 6800GTO really is. If you do a search in this forum on the X300SE, I think you will find most people are not happy with it.
The GTO has 12 pixel pipelines, but some have unlocked the other four, making it a 6800 GT....
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=832739 Here is a link to a forum that discussed the unlocking of the 12 pixel pipeline to 16 pixels...Dim 4400 ( June 2002 )
2.6 ghz (upgrade from 1.7 ghz)
768 MB 2100 DDR Memory
Gainward Ti 4200 128 MB Nvidia
XP Home plus SP-2
17 inch Dell LCD monitor (1703 FP)
48 X CDRWMessage Edited by SR45 on 11-21-2004 05:59 PM
ctalia4000
2 Intern
•
1325 Posts
671
0
Posted November 21st, 2004 22:00
Here are a few coupon sites to save money on your next system.
- how old is your kid? and what games does he plan on playing? 460 is a large enough psu even for o/cing, nvidia lowered the power requirement. if he really wants the 6800gt, buy the x300se and buy the nvidia card aftermarket for a bit under 400. then try and ebay the old card, might find someone gulliable.
- Thank you all for your expert advice. It sounds the power supply would be adequate for the 6800GT.
May I ask a follow-up question, prompted by the extensive "fan" threads at the top of this forum:
IF one was to buy the base X300 card, with a plan to replace it with the 6800 GT (not the GTO), would one be advised to, or required to, install an additional fan...or....to upgrade the existing fanJ Likewise, if one bought the 6800GTO stock from Dell, does it already come with an adequate and/or upgraded fan of some sort? Not sure if the fan comes with the system if you get the stock 6800 GTO, but you won't have any error messages even if it doesn't. Only certain early PCIe non-OEM cards are resulting in the error message. The fan is only really needed (according to Dell and subject to debate) if you have a card drawing more than 75 watts--the 5900 and 5700 cards that are getting the error message aren't over 75 watts so it's a problem with the BIOS recognizing the cards correctly.
I think the 6800GT is over 75 watts (maybe it's only the Ultra?) so if you upgrade to that you'll likely need to order the fan from Dell later.
the fan is pointless to use, all the cooling you need is on the card already, if you really want the fan all it will do is circulate hot air and cool your card a couple degrees more, no more, it's a pointless cooling solution, if you really wanted a good cooling solution you should try install an NV approved VGA silencer or heatpipe solution, but don't worry about those, you won't need em unless you do extreme OC'ing like me.
I would recommend the 800SE or GTO but as the others said the GTO is just a "Dell" branded version of the 6800 non ultra that is overclocked to higher speeds. They used "GTO" to possibly confuse people into thinking it was an acually Chip made by NV and it was the same at the GT.
If you are not into tinkering with your card or taking risks like voiding warranties and such, get the 6800GT PCIe from a different seller like newegg or some place. Getting a GTO and using Rivatuner to mod it doesn't work with every card as every card is different, and if you modded it you will void warranty, no biggie if you do everything right though, but I doubt you want to take that risk as it is for your kid.
so if you want, I recommend in this order 1 - 6800GT from some other seller 2 - 6800GTO 3 - X800SE
also, I do have two codes that depending on your budget could get you the same custom 8400 config. as I have, but it's 3k, but it also comes with a 19" Ultrasharp LCD, RAID configs, P4 560, Audigy 2, and the real keeper is the X800XT with the system, this code and a slightly different code that bundles the 20" Ultrasharp is the only way to get an X800XT with the 8400, it is then effectively the same as the XPS but for about $2000 less. PM me if you are interested.

SR45
2 Intern
•
12138 Posts
671
0
Posted November 21st, 2004 18:00
Stay away from the X300 SE video card. Lower end, and you and the kids will not be happy when playing some of the better games. The 6800 GTO is a good card, above the 6800 and just below the performance of the 6800 GT card. You can always upgrade later with a better card after the price goes down. The 8400 system is pci-express all the way, and it does not have the older agp slot. The 8400 is newer and is more upgradable with the pci-express. Dell rates its power supply differently than other's. The 350 power supply (XPS system has the 460 watt p/s ) that the 8400 system comes with, is the mean power output, and not the peak. The peak is much higher. The 6800 GT card will fit and will run well with the power supply now installed. The 6800 Ultra card is a different story and needs about 480 watts if you plan of over clocking, which I would not do for just a few more frames per second. Not worth it. All three cards that you have listed are pci-express.
http://support.dell.com/support/edocs/systems/dim8400/SM/specs.htm#wp1052308 This link will take you to the spec's of the 8400 system. Look down to the area where it says Power. This will show you the power is 350 watts on the 8400 system
Dim 4400 ( June 2002 )
2.6 ghz (upgrade from 1.7 ghz)
768 MB 2100 DDR Memory
Gainward Ti 4200 128 MB Nvidia
XP Home plus SP-2
17 inch Dell LCD monitor (1703 FP)
48 X CDRW
Message Edited by SR45 on 11-21-2004 03:02 PM