UNSOLVED

Serpentor100

updated

24 years ago

0

1087

July 16th, 2002 02:00

8200 $130 cheaper than 4500? Why?

I configured an 8200 system and a 4500 system the exact same way and the "cutting edge" 8200 was 130 bucks cheaper than the 4500. The only thing the 4500 has that the 8200 doesn't is USB 2.0 support which can be added as a PCI card to the 8200 for 20 bucks. Also, the 4500 only uses SDRAM while the 8200 uses superior RDRAM.

Right now I own an 8200 which I am sending back because of an unresolvable sound problem (tried a new sound card.. didnt work.. maybe a bad motherboard). I'm now deciding what comp I should order (not neccesarily Dell). I remember the 8200 was slightly cheaper a month ago as well when I got my system. Is there something wrong with these 8200s and they are trying to get rid of them? Maybe their motherboards are older than the 4500? $130 is a significant difference. I don't understand what's going on. Can anyone shed some light?

Thx.
-John

  • Charger_R-T

    1 Rookie

    •

    116 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 02:00

    The 4500 hasn't been out long...
    The 8200 has been out for about a year now...
    That's probably the difference.

    Charger





    Helping people with their computer problems is a favorite hobby of mine. If you need some help, I'd be more than happy to help you!
    Click Here To Send Me An Email!!


    <><><><><><><><><><><><>
    Dell Dimension V350 Powered By:

    Intel Pentium II Processor @ 350MHZ
    128 Mb SDRAM
    17" Dell D1028L Monitor
    Mad Dog Performer 16 PCI Video Card
    IBM Active Responce Keyboard (Black)
    8.4Gig Maxtor Hard Drive
    Iomega ZIP 100Mb
    Backpack 4X Cd-Rw
    <><><><><><><><>

    I do not work for Dell Computer Corporation or Microsoft. Windows XP logo copyrighted by Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Microsoft Corporation is a trademark or registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries. All rights reserved. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
  • 256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 04:00

    So.. what in the 4500 is newer and better? The motherboard? Does it make it worth getting the 4500?

  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 13:00

    Congratulations! You've discovered the secret of Dell pricing. Bet you are using the Small Business site where the 8200 has cost less than the 4400/4500 since it's onset at the start of the year. The 8200 gets a premium on the Home site most of the time.

    There is very little difference between these systems -- the USB support and type of memory (which requires a different support chipset). Also the 8200 motherboard is physically a bit larger. On the open market, the RDRAM is more expensive, but if you buy the memory you need with the system (for instance by taking advantage of double memory deals) I can (and could) see no reason not to buy the 8200.



    Dimension 8200, 2.2GHz, 512MB, 80+60GB, Philips DVD+RW, 1702FP, SB Live! 1024, WinXP Pro (Home system)
    Dimension 4300S, 1.6GHz, 384MB, 40GB, 16x10x40x CDRW, 1702FP, motherboard sound, WinXP Home. (Wife's system)
    Homebrew, 866MHz, 512MB, 12GB, 2x1x16x CDRW, SB Value, Red Hat Linux (to be retired)
    Dimension 4100, 1GHz, 256MB, 40GB, 12x8x32x CDRW, motherboard sound, Win2K (Fathers system I maintain)
    Homebrew, 1GHz, 512MB, 30GB, 12x8x32x CDRW, 14/32x CDROM, motherboard sound, Win2K.(Work system)
    (other monitors 19-21" CRT, 100BaseT networking, mundane video cards
    and speakers, Microsoft&Logitech wheel mice, Northgate Omnikey and
    Dell keyboards)
    Toshiba Laptop I'd rather like to forget. (I hate laptops)
  • 256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 14:00

    any chance that since the 8200 is an older system it is made with cheaper parts? it would make sense wouldn't it? maybe cheaper motherboard, fan, power supply, etc. 130 bucks price difference is a little suspicious to me. They are trying to get rid of those 8200s for a reason.

  • qdemn7

    182 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 16:00

    If I had a choice to buya 4500 or 8200, I'd buy the 8200, as long as it had the 533 mhz FSB. The 8200 actually has a BETTER motherboard than the 4500. The 4400 / 4500 use a MicroATX motherboard, ( with DDR memory ) as opposed to the full size ATX of the 8200, ( with RDRAM ). The 4500 has native USB 2.0, the 8200 doesn't. There is no other difference between the 2 systems. Dell uses the same power supply, cpu, passive cooling system ( no fan on the heatsink ), case. They might be coming out with a newer model ( 8300 ?? ), but you won't know until it appears on the site. It may have to do with the rise in memory prices. Dell may have gotten a better deal on RDRAM versus DDR. I wish I had bought an 8200.

    Dimension 4400
    1.8 GHZ
    768MB DDR
    Western Digital WD1200JB / 120GB SE
    Maxtor D740X / 80GB
    NEC 5800 DVD ROM
    GE 8160B CDRW
    Geforce3 Ti200
    Soundblaster 5.1
    IBM P275 21" Monitor
    Epson C40UX
    APC LS 700VA
    XP Home
    Roxio Platinum
    Zone Alarm Pro
    AdSubtract Pro
    Sandra 2002 Pro
    Belarc Advisor
    Adaware
    Folding @ Home - Team 33 ardOCP
  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2002 19:00

    Business 101 -- pricing is set by perceived value and not by cost. Being a newer model, Dell can sell a 4400/4500 for more than an 8200. Customers expect it will stay around longer (and maintain its value). There is little difference in performance or in manufacturing cost. In the more image driven Home site, the 8200 sells for more because its model number is almost twice as large. :-)



    Dimension 8200, 2.2GHz, 512MB, 80+60GB, Philips DVD+RW, 1702FP, SB Live! 1024, WinXP Pro (Home system)
    Dimension 4300S, 1.6GHz, 384MB, 40GB, 16x10x40x CDRW, 1702FP, motherboard sound, WinXP Home. (Wife's system)
    Homebrew, 866MHz, 512MB, 12GB, 2x1x16x CDRW, SB Value, Red Hat Linux (to be retired)
    Dimension 4100, 1GHz, 256MB, 40GB, 12x8x32x CDRW, motherboard sound, Win2K (Fathers system I maintain)
    Homebrew, 1GHz, 512MB, 30GB, 12x8x32x CDRW, 14/32x CDROM, motherboard sound, Win2K.(Work system)
    (other monitors 19-21" CRT, 100BaseT networking, mundane video cards
    and speakers, Microsoft&Logitech wheel mice, Northgate Omnikey and
    Dell keyboards)
    Toshiba Laptop I'd rather like to forget. (I hate laptops)