Read through some stuff on the Sigmatel problems with Input monitoring and got wading through my registry trying to figure the Vista equivalent of all the instructions (which seemed XP based). Ended up finding this:
On the Inspiron 6400/E1505 I did the following to enable Input Monitoring (Hearing what you're inputting through line in/mic on your speakers at the same time):
In RegEdit went to: HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\ControlSet001\Control\Class\{4D36E96C-E325-11CE-BFC1-08002BE10318}\0000\Settings\filter\SpeakerHp\
Changed the Binary Value for
EnableIntSpkrMute to
00
Also added the Binary Value
EnableInputMonitor and set the value to
01 - Not sure this was necessary but I was getting tired of rebooting to test stuff.
Rebooted
Right Clicked the Volume Speaker Icon (Default Vista One) by the clock on the taskbar, Selected
Playback Devices, Double-clicked
Speakers/Headphones, Clicked the
Levels tab, then unmuted the
Input Monitor option.
Note: I noticed it was quite quiet so I turned up my recording volume level. I might have to go back into regedit and adjust some of the volumes under MuxedIn.
If this has already been posted in this or another forum please feel free to remove it moderators. I found out most of this by reading various FAQs and sites on the net and then simply having too much time on my hands and looking through various registry keys.
Thank you - thank you - thank you!!! You are the MAN!!!
I just got my E1705 with only the SigmaTel chipset.
I have spent my entire Saturday trying to research and solve the issue of not being able to monitor the line in while recording. I was about to give up when I tried your fix and it worked - just like that.
I am frustrated however that while researching, a lot of the people have had this same problem for quite some time (pre-Vista) and have complained to Dell. The worst thing is that Dell support was of no help, and honestly made me feel like a liar and idiot (20 years experience teaching computers here!) I am mostly happy with my new system, but no-one should have to go through these kind of hoops!!!!!
Support Chat excerpts:
Me: "so i searched for this problem and found it to be common, but am very confused on if their is a solution - one possibility would be to use sound blaster audigy"
Agent (Suhail_123608): "There is no internal MIC on E 1705 ."
Agent (Suhail_123608): "Are you using a external mic ?" 05/19/2007 10:31:42PM Me: "please go back and read the problem"
Me: "i am not having a problem actually recording using a mic or line in, but with hearing (monitoring) the audio while i am doing it"
Agent (Suhail_123608): "Have you reinstall the audio driver and check."
Me: "yes" 05/19/2007 10:33:43PM Me: "i can't believe that you are not aware of this problem - it is very clear on the dell support forums that this is an ongoing saga"
Agent (Suhail_123608): "May I know the link from the forums ?"
Me: "looking....."
Agent (Suhail_123608): "Thank you."
Me: "here is one, but not sure it's really what i'm looking for..."
Agent (Suhail_123608): "I am sorry the notebook will not support simultaneously recording you can confirm this with my manager."
Me: "that would be fine"
Agent (Suhail_123608): "I will be transferring to my manager." 05/19/2007 10:50:54PM Me: "thanks"
Agent (Suhail_123608): "Please give me two minutes while I check my resources." Me: "sur"
Me: "e" 05/19/2007
Session Transferred to Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578) 05/19/2007 10:53:23PM Session Started with Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578) 05/19/2007 10:53:39PM Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Hi , My name is Abraham , I am the supervisor on the floor ."
Me: "hi - thanks"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "I was consulted by my tech with this issue ."
Me: "i understand why i was given the answer that it just doesn't work on this laptop, but i am not believing it, as i have seen solutions and complaints in many forums on the web - just none that i have gotten to work"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Well , the information provided by my tech is correct ."
Me: "and to not have the ability to monitor or hear while recording just doesn't make sense - as well as the fact that this system has the ability for those that are running xp instead of vista"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Well , my tech forwarded me this link and I did check this ."
Me: "and is it true that this feature would be enabled if i purchased sound blaster audigy software edition?"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "No , its just an enhancement software and even with Sound blaster audigy , it will not work ."
Me: "that seems to be the solution for a few people - and it was offered as an upgrade during my system order"
Me: "can in dell forums, your own people are or at least were some time back, admitting that this was a known issue"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Well , this is not a known issue , Sound card doesn't support this feature ."
Me: "alright then"
Me: "sorry - it's just odd to me that others have solved the "problem" that you say doesn't exist"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Sir , these are not Dell forums and if you are sure that installing Sound blaster audigy will resolve this issue , you can contact our customer care to purchase it ."
Me: "dell2dell is a dell forum with dell employess"
Me: "the other was just an example of solutions your customers have found"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "As I suggest , if you are sure , you can go ahead and purchase it from customer care ."
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "This is referring to the SW download ."
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "Delbert , this is a paid version ."
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "It will not work if you just download it as you need the serial no to activate it ."
Me: "i know- i was going to purchase it, if it would solve the problem"
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "However , as I explained , as per the communication received to us , Sigmatel chipset present on this doesn't support the feature you referring to and upgrading the sound blaster will not work ."
Agent (Sup_Abraham_0141578): "However I have you email id ."
Me: "thanks"
My two cents -got the problem solved, but not happy with Dell at the moment!
in my case the subkey "
\Settings\filter\SpeakerHp\"does not exist and nor does the
EnableIntSpkrMuteEnableInputMonitor binary values. I created all that by hand and that did not fix the problem of line-in input monitoring.
some people refres these instruction were for the XP exition of the driver??? maybe people with this key have done a xin XP to vista upgrade which preserved these values.???
I am about to try to install SIGMATEL XP drivers on VISTA TO SEE if that helps...
Question: For those who have been lucky enough to to get line in monitroing working, could you indicate the drivers version for sigmatel you are using and the version of windows vista? and how you got ther whole thing going step by step. that would be muchly appreciated...
I am currently using the latest version of the sigmatel driver provided by dell
depending on the installtion the 0008 may be something else.. 001,002 and so on. once you are around there search for "SpeakerHp" that'll remove some ambiguity.
Expand "SpeakerHp" subkey and you should see a bunch a values configuring how speakers are meant to operate. as for XP on a default installation the needed "EnableInputMonitor" binary value has not been created yet. in other workds it's
missing. You can manually add it
"EnableInputMonitor"=hex:01
then reboot
after that you should be able to find on the playback devices properties's "Level" tab of the a new check box allowing to turn on and off input audio monitoring. by the way this control toogles the "RecMonitorMute" value in the same section of the registry mentioned before:
"RecMonitorMute"=hex:01 (on)
"RecMonitorMute"=hex:00 (off)
Now to adjust recording volumes and feedback use the "Recording Devices properties's "level" tab where horizontal sliders are available to tweak input and mic volumes.
Why does DELL says this does not work ??? far out!!!! By doing so they create a huge level of frustration and time wastage that nobody needs. That has to be detrimental to DELL reputation as well and funnnily enough they are making it harder for themselves for no appearant reason. All they have to do is know the products and softweare they sale.
So here is a bottle in the ocean: Hey Mister DELL why don't you fix that on your next release of the SIGMATEL driver" it's very simple to fix: Just add the magic value to the registry on install et voila.
For all those that can get this working now I say: Enjoy your music recording session on your DELL laptop.
Note( my Takamine Santa Fe with onboard Valve pre-amp sounds pretty good recorded through the DELL I6400 USING ACID pro 6.0).
Perhaps we can also discover how to get a "Stereo Mix" recording input function under Vista, and a control panel that has more than just one select box in it?
Hey, the EnableInputMonitor thing worked, but now when I connect something to the line-in, its extremely loud, even when the microphone volume is turned all the way down. Do you know of any way to fix this? I checked the MuxedIn in regedit but i'm not sure what to fix..
This does work, but for some reason it totally changes the sound on my computer. I reset my equalizers and everything to what I normally have them on but music and other sounds just don't sound the same. It sounds crummier and I can't adjust the graphic equalizers enough to make it sound right. BTW, I have SoundBlaster Audigy HD audio software if that has anything to do with it. Any ideas why it messes up the sound and how to fix it?
You know about a month ago mine just started working. I didn't do anything but one day I noticed my mic was blasting through my headset. Now if I could get the cracking and popping to stop.
Actually try unplugging the power pack from the laptop and have a listen with a headset; I bet you'd fine that most (if not all) of the clicking and sheeeing noise of the line input will be gone then.
It might be possible to filter this out but I normally simply unplug the laptop from the ac power when I need to record on the internal sound card. It works pretty good for me. :smileyhappy:
Otherwise if you are a really into digital music and got a few hundreds $$$ to spend I can only recommend this external sound card
Setting EnableInputMonitor to
01 (as suggested in the beginning of the thread) worked for my Inspiron 1720 with Vista Home Premium and Sigmatel v6.10.0.5609, A02.
The only problem is you cannot adjust level of that monitoring. You can mute it, but not change the level.
AspenVince
1 Message
404
0
Posted May 20th, 2007 06:00