I installed RH8 installed on a colocated 2650 last January. Back then it wasn't yet certified by Dell but was in progress. I was able to get a version of OpenManage for it and that enables me to get emails if a fan stops etc., which is useful.
Unfortunately RH are pulling errata updates for RH in January. I can't run a web server without security updates so I will be forced to install a new OS. It's a bit disappointing given we purchased RH8 professional only to find it only had a one year EOL. Also, the system is running very reliably now and I simply don't want to change it, but will be forced to.
I notice that the latest certified RH is RH9.
My requirements from Dell and RH are:-
1) A kernel that doesn't freeze,
2) Security updates for at least 3 years, preferably 5,
3) A version of OpenManage so I can keep an eye on the hardware, organise emails to be sent if there are problems, reboot the machine if the watchdog times out.
Questions...
What version of Linux do Dell recommend to install when RH8 expires? There is currently no support for RHEL.
Does OpenManage really _have_ to be tied to a particular version of RHL. Can it possibly be made to run independantly of the kernel and be less fussy about what distro it is running on? I am seriously considering switching to another distro after what Redhat just done & did but the inability to run OpenManage on it is hampering my choices.
In my workplace, we use OpenManage in conjunction with Mandrake Linux 9.1.
On PE 2300, 2400, 2550 & 1750 we have had no issues in 18 months (vers. 8.x & 9.x MDK).
ITA 6.44 picks up our servers and SAN ok.
Dell will not support us however, due to our choice of OS for host nodes. Instead, we get smiles and lots of *good luck* and *please keep us posted on your progress*.
For all 3 of your requirements, I would suggest moving to RHEL. Dell currently supports 2.1, and has plans to support 3.0 starting in January. Security updates are from the RHN which gives you 18 months to 3 years of life. Open Manage can be used and works great when using a DRAC for remote control of the server.
What we mean is when Red Hat stops providing security updates, the product is EOL. If you still have a warnanty on your server, Dell will provide best effort support even after the Red Hat EOL, but don't expect us to be proactive with security / bug fixes. If we find a bug / security problem while working with you on a case, it's possible the only resolution you will get is to upgrade to the newer distro.
We are aware of a subscription fee problem, but since most Major Linux distributions that are backed by a company, (i.e. SuSE, Mandrake, and Red Hat) have a subscription program for their product, there not much we can do about it. Be aware that having a subscription to the RHN, allows you to download the latest version of RHEL for free and upgrade your server to the new release.
I can neither confirm nor deny plans Dell may have with other Linux Distrubutions.
If cost is a factor for you, there are alternatives if you are willing to support yourself or obtain support through the Linux communitiy. I would recommed Fedora Core, or SuSE personal, but there is also Debian, Mandrake personal and thousands of others. Check out distrowatch.com for one that may suit your needs.
I'm a bit confused about the "3 years of life" bit. Do you mean that in 3 years we would need to install yet another OS? Or do you mean that with the intial purchase of RHEL we will get 3 years of security updates? What I saw on the RH site is that it would cost me $350/year for the Basic edition support and $800/year for Standard edition. At those rates it doesn't take long to exceed the cost of the server.
Is this where Dell is heading for future installations of Linux/Unix on their servers, the RHEL? Has anyone at Dell thought about using something else? At the yearly cost of just getting security updates, I may be forced, as a non-profit service to find another solution.
Just to let you know. RH9 will is planned to go to EOL in April aswell. Dell is supposed to start support on all 3.0 versions (which are all fee based) of RH soon but like was previously stated there is a best effort support given anyway.
I am looking at buying five new PowerEdge servers and I will be running Red Hat Enterprise on them.
When I buy a new PowerEdge server from Dell with a Red Hat Enterprise license, who provides support? Does Dell provide the support or does Red Hat? Who will I be contacting if I have problem with a driver, or configuring a RAID controller?
Dell should be the first place that you call. We have several RHCE and RHCT level technicians and engineers in our NOS, Gold and Silver support queues. If at that time there is a problem we can engage with Red Hat.
Also at any time you can engage Red Hat using your support contract that is purchased with your copy of Red Hat.
This is good news. I am really pleased that Dell has embraced Linux.
I have some additional questions related to Red Hat Enterprise on Dell PowerEdge servers and support. This info will help me decide if I should buy the PowerEdge servers.
1. Is the Red Hat Enterprise (RHE) sold with a PowerEdge server customized for the server, or is it the same software that Red Hat sells directly?
I have an existing relationship with Red Hat, and I can get the software at a significant discount if I buy direct from them. I want to know if the software is the same or is Dell using custom drivers for the PowerEdge servers.
2. I am considering purchasing the PowerEdge 2650 and use the PERC 3Di controller to set up two channels of RAID 1. One pair for the operating system and one pair for the database. Will RHE 2.1 support this controller and can I configure it for two channels of RAID 1?
3. If I buy the software from Red Hat directly, I was going to buy Bronze Support for the servers. If I go this route, will I have access to the RHCE and RHCT level technicians and engineers for hardware support?
4. If I don't have access to these engineers, will Dell be able to diagnose problems with the hardware when RHE is running on it?
5. Does Red Hat have engineers familiar with Dell servers?
6. I know that some of Dell support comes out of India or other non-US based locations. I have had mixed experiences with support provided by these folks. Some times its excellent and sometimes I have left the call swearing that I will never use Dell again. What location is the Dell servers supported from, especially the Bronze support?
7. When will Dell certify the PowerEdge 1750 and 2650 for RHE 3? The Red Hat web site says they have certified both systems.
I apologize for the long post. I am in the process of deciding if I should buy several PowerEdge servers or by the servers from a different vendor like Sun.
Thanks a bunch for your help. I really appreciate it. This forum and the posts from you and the other folks at Dell have increased my confidence in Dell commitment to Linux on their systems.
The DOSA CD comes with every Dell server. Its basically a CD that will performed the Dell recommended install of Windows, Red Hat, or Novell onto a Dell server.
U2 / U3 CD's are the Update 2 or Update 3 CD's from Red Hat. They are updated installation CD's that include all of the errata already built in.
If you buy Gold support, you can still get Linux support from Dell. You will also have a technical account manager to manage any technical issues you may experience.
1. The RHEL is exactly what Red Hat sells including the documention and access to RHN. We also offer a great price for RHEL over retail, but if you get a better deal directly from RH, go for it. You can buy your server w/o OS.
2. You can use the DOSA CD to install Red Hat and configure your RAID controller. Or you can do this manually. When installing, I would use U2 or U3 CD's from Red Hat. Other wise you will need to apply several hundred patches / updates.
3. Bronze if fine, but I would highly recommend Gold as it would get you faster access into the queue and allow for better hardware replacement. 4 hrs instead of NBD.
4. We are able to diagnose most problems on a server no matter what OS is installed on it. We have a diagnositic CD that we can boot that will give us information on what may be happening with the hardware. Also there is information on how Red Hat is operating to determine if there is a problem or not.
5. With our partnership with Red Hat, they are very familar with our servers. Dell also has internships with Red Hat were our employees work at Red Hat for a few weeks to get more in depth knowledge of the product as well as exposing Red Hat to Dell knowledge.
6. Currently all server support is in the US (Austin TX) area. India is a backup site for call overflow. I can not confirm if this will stay this way for Bronze support. Gold will always be US support.
7. Dell plans on selling servers with RHEL3 very soon. We had to work out some details on how best to support it, as well as actually use the product for a while, and make some marketing offerings.
scattamah
2 Posts
1064
0
Posted November 24th, 2003 12:00
On PE 2300, 2400, 2550 & 1750 we have had no issues in 18 months (vers. 8.x & 9.x MDK).
ITA 6.44 picks up our servers and SAN ok.
Dell will not support us however, due to our choice of OS for host nodes. Instead, we get smiles and lots of *good luck* and *please keep us posted on your progress*.
S :)