Investigation: Low CAS Latency (CAS 2) PC3200 on the 400sc (et al)
Objectives: 1) To prove once and for all what PC3200 CAS 2 memory runs at 400MHz or does not (333Mhz). 2) Determine if this is Dell's fault, Intel's fault, or the RAM manufacturer's fault.
Theory: There are CAS 2 (2-2-2-6) and CAS 2 (2-3-2-6) and even more CAS 2 (2-X-X-X) modules. Some of these work, others don't. I beleive that with the fastest speeds or timings (2-2-2-6), the 400sc motherboard has to back off and run the memory at 333MHz, but if you get slightly slower speeds, (2-3-2-6), the 400sc motherboard will run the memory properly at 400MHz DDR. I beleive this is Dell's fault (no proof). Hopefully they can come out with a BIOS update that will be able to handle these faster memory times.
Please share your experience with us so we can collect data and try to piece this puzzel together. You need to be as descriptive as possible. Include all the info listed here: Make: Model: Timings: Link: Description:
Additional Info: -To retrieve the timings that are programmed into your memory's SPD (serial presence detect) EEPROM, go to cpuid.com; download, unzip, and run "CPU-Z". Click the "About" tab; click "Memory SPD"; save the txt file and open it. Make sure you are looking at the proper module in the text file. -For a description of what memory timing are, see here: http://www.sysopt.com/articles/latency/ -If you mix CAS 2 and CAS 3 memory, you will not be able to run at 400MHz . . . infact 3-3-3-8 mixed with 3-4-3-8 may not run at 400MHz (not sure). To help understand this, see the SPD info on this PC133 module:
As I was messing around a little more with CPU-Z, I noticed that my PC3200 memory 2-2-2-6 is not only just running at 333MHz, but has timings 2-2-2-5. I'm not exactly sure what this means. Possibly, the Dell motherboard is interpreting the Kingston SPD 2-2-2-6 into 2-2-2-5 which the memory can't run at 400Mhz, so it backs off to 333Mhz.
I got a very helpful email from Kingston. They suggested that I use a different product (KTD-WS360A/512) than the one which I currently am using (KHX3200K2/512). I couldn't find out much information (CAS ?) about this product though. I did find a page listing all the memory recommended for the Dell PowerEdge 400sc: http://www.ec.kingston.com/ecom/configurator/modelsinfo.asp?SysID=+16077+&distributor=0&submit1=Search
Very Important! Kingston did explain what I believe to be the key to all these memory problems:
"You're system uses the Intel 875P chipset which cannot run faster than Cas Latency 2, Ras to Cas 3, Ras Precharge 2. The KHX3200K2/xxx is 2-2-2."
This means it must be Intel's fault for the problems some of us are having and that the fastest times on PC3200 memory is 2-3-2. 2-2-2 will run not run at PC3200 on the Intel 875P!
************************* Email from Kingston:
You're using the wrong type of memory for your system. Our HyperX memory is built for use by users that plan to manually set the memory settings in the BIOS of their motherboards for overclocking. The memory has been tested in sustained overclocked configurations. However, due to the possible damage overclocking can do, Kingston does not guarantee HyperX to be compatible in any particular motherboard. The recommended part number for your system is KTD-WS360A/512. It's been designed, tested, and verified to work with your system. If you'd like to purchase a working module for this system, you should take the HyperX kit back to where you purchased it to get a refund. Then you can go to www.shop.kingston.com or contact MemoSun at (800) 733-8204 to purchase the recommended part.
If you continue to use the HyperX, here are some reasons why it may be clocking the memory down to PC2700;. You're system uses the Intel 875P chipset which cannot run faster than Cas Latency 2, Ras to Cas 3, Ras Precharge 2. The KHX3200K2/xxx is 2-2-2. You're system in order to run PC3200 must be using ECC memory. We do not sell any Unbuffered ECC HyperX. You're system in order to run PC3200 must be using a CPU with FSB 800. You may already have this.
Best regards, Chris Bodda Technical Support Kingston Technology Company
************************* Email from me:
Kingston P/N: KHX3200K2/512 Request:
I bought KHX3200K2/512 from zipzoomfly.com. The package looked tampered with (the wrap sticker seemed like it had been pulled off then replaced. My Dell PowerEdge 400sc computer recognizes this memory as PC2700 instead of PC3200. All labeling (package and heat spreaders) show KHX3200k2/512. I have not pulled off the heat spreader for more information from the chips themselves.
Is it possible that I have received PC2700 memory in a PC3200 package? Is there a way for me to find out exactly what type of memory this is? Is this truely PC3200 memory that my system is incorrectly detecting as PC2700?
Any help would be appreciated. **************************************************
Some more information from Corsair. I am quoting a page that quotes an announcement from Corsair. It basically re-affirms that aggressive latency settings will cause the 875P to downclock PC3200 to PC2700. However, it does say that intel's bios release "P04" was supposed to fix this. I beleive this then throws it back into Dell's court. They should release an update that will allow these agressive timings (2 2 2).
"The results we have seen are as follows: Intel 875PBZ "Bonanza" board will recognize XMS3200LL modules as 333 MHz rather than 400 MHz, due to the agressive latency settings. Asus P4C800 will recognize 3200LL correctly, but 1GB maximum memory is recommended with the low latency settings.
Both boards are stable at latency settings of 2-3-2-6 rather than 2-2-2-6, as is programmed in the SPD of 'LL' parts. Therefore, Corsair recommend that users purchase the 3200C2 (or 3500C2, for maximum overclocking performance) and tweak the latency settings through the BIOS settings, to improve the settings."
[the page author continues]
Update April 28: Intel is ready to release a new BIOS version "P04", for the Canterwood-based "Bonanza", T875PBZ.
This BIOS change should allow the board to now read SPD memory settings of 2-2-2 and so use Corsair LowLatency memories, as originally intended.
We will keep you posted on further developments. Also make sure to check back for our upcoming MSI NEO-LSR(i875P) motherboard review.
I'm happy to see I'm not the only one having this problem. I recently purchased a 400SC and a gig of Corsair XMS3200LL. There's a BIOS update that can be found here
It's release date was 11/24, and since the messages seem to be posted after the release date, I guess the problem still stands as unresolved. I was worried I was sold some bogus RAM before I found this thread.
True, these posts were made with Dell BIOS firmware A04 for the 400sc. You'd think that this would have corresponded to the Intel P04 firmware BIOS realease and would have fixed the same thing that the Intel P04 release supposedly fixed (I haven't verified that any Intel 857P can handle 2-2-2 timings even with the latest firmware release). It'd be interesting to know. Hmm, we should check out www.intel.com and see what intel says the P04 firmware update fixed.
I still really really want my 2-2-2 Kingston to work, so I haven't sold it yet.
It seems that Dell's 1st point "Updated Prescott A0 microcode from patch level 02 to patch level 12" may correspond to Intel's P04 post on April 23rd "Updated memory reference code to revision 1.2" OR Dell's statement may mean that they have included all features from Intel's update from P02 to P12. I'm really not sure how to interpret all this. Maybe if someone wants to poke around a little more then they can draw some other conclusions.
Basically we'd like to determine if Dell has included the fixes that Intel put out that will allow the 875P BIOS to handle memory timings 2-2-2.
I am really surprised that we haven't heard from a Dell Support person (like Mark A.) about this BIOS update issue. If there is a support person that reads this, please respond. Mark, I've read a few of your posts on other topics and know that you offer relevant and helpful information. We'd appreciate a response to the following:
We know that the 875P motherboard initially had problems reading memory latency settings 2-2-2-6. We also understand that intel BIOS update P04 (April '03?) was supposed to fix this very issue. Do you know if Dell's latest BIOS release (A04, Nov. '03) is supposed to fix this problem also? Was the code included? If not, do you know if it will be included in a soon to come release? If so, how soon?
Even if a Dell Support person can chime in and say that they know of no such issue or fix, we'd at least know that you have read the topic but have no information for us at this time.
I have seen this post but have not responded as I do not have much to add. I have not been able to confirm if the latest BIOS fixes the issues you are seeing. What I can say with certainty is if the problems exist with Dell provided memory, we will replace the memory, motherboard or system (as applicable) to resolve the issue. The Dell provided memory has been tested to meet the specifications advertised.
eskimoquin
13 Posts
1169
0
Posted December 4th, 2003 22:00
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=pes_other&message.id=7263&view=by_date_ascending&page=1