Hey all, I recently purchased a 2005FPW. I love this monitor. My video card looks great on it, it runs games great, the whole bit.
One MAJOR issue though.
Whether it be through my computer (I tried nvdvd, media player, and windvd...I also tried with both the dvi and the d-sub connections) or through an actual dvd player (tried both composite AND s-video connections) dvd's look HORRID. I'm talking like VHS recorded in EP quality. Why is that? Anyone else have this problem? Anyone know how to fix it???
Again, i have tried both the d-sub and the dvi connections from the computer, and have tried both the composite and the s-video from a dvd player. Other than this one thing, the monitor looks AMAZING but is HORRID with dvd's.
its an x800xt like i said there is NO PROBLEM with ANYTHING else...
PLUS...it did the EXACT SAME THING with a regular dvd player, didnt matter if i used the s-video cable or the composite video cable, the EXACT same problem happend in the EXACT same amount
No problems with anything else doesn't mean no problems with DVD playback, they exercise totally different parts of the card. And the s-video or composite connections generate notoriously low quality visuals.
Not familiar with the Radeon family of video cards to help there. That X800xt is a nice high-end card, however, so should be able to drive the monitor just fine in all things, I would think. Perhaps someone who owns a comparable video card and that monitor can help out...
No problems with anything else doesn't mean no problems with DVD playback, they exercise totally different parts of the card. And the s-video or composite connections generate notoriously low quality visuals.
Not familiar with the Radeon family of video cards to help there. That X800xt is a nice high-end card, however, so should be able to drive the monitor just fine in all things, I would think. Perhaps someone who owns a comparable video card and that monitor can help out...
True, but on my crt monitor it looked FANTASTIC, on this its not just "oh its an lcd so its diff" like i said it looks like a VHS tape that was recorded in EP mode...its nearly unwatchable.
i've just purchased the 9300 laptop (1900x1200 screen) and i've come across the same thing. DVDs look almost frightening, although they're passable, if sometimes very good on a CRT screen. it's very disappointing.
i think it might just be down to the inherent limitations of DVD. these high res LCD screens are pretty unforgiving, whereas i think the CRT (with it's better black levels) and standard def tvs hide some of the flaws.
you should try high def material on your 2005. if that looks good, then it's likely just DVD being "not all that". that seems to be the case for me, although even these dell/lcd screens don't make high def look as good as i thought it would ... certainly better than DVD though.
Well folks, it stil the same thing, whether through my computer OR a dvd player, and through any of the inputs, it looks horrid.
Here is the key.
Like the poster above me said, try sitting farther back.
I moved not three feet from the screen further than I normally sit (THREE. FEET.) and it looks FANTASTIC. Who knows, maybe it has something to do with the interlacing going on inside the monitor (given that dvd's are not natively 1680X1050).
Whatever the reason, up close it looks like @ss. From 5 freet or more away, it looks amazing. Thanks for the attention and suggestions, good to see a community that actually is a community and not just a flame waiting to happen:-)
sitting further back definitely improves things, but it still bugged me that it looked so bad close up ...
one thing that has improved things a lot is ...
1. install windvd
2. use hardware acceleration (and hardware colouring)
i've have the geoforce 256Mb card - although presumably this would work fine on the ATI option.
and ...
picture is much, much better.
finding nemo (region 1) almost looked a bootleg, the compression was awful. but switching to hardware acceleration has turned the tables around. although dvd's limitations are still evident as ever, the picture looks far less compressed.
nb : finding nemo does have compression problems that are well documentated, but not as bad as the default setup for my 9300 laptop would suggest.
Pojut
6 Posts
272
0
Posted December 21st, 2005 02:00
PLUS...it did the EXACT SAME THING with a regular dvd player, didnt matter if i used the s-video cable or the composite video cable, the EXACT same problem happend in the EXACT same amount