
UNSOLVED
Closed
CJ
Clinton Jones
3 Posts
0
19645
February 28th, 2005 15:00
My Inspiron 5150 has a faulty connection between the power plug and the motherboard!
I too am having the infamous power plug/motherboard issue. I have spent the last 2 days trying to get someone to reason with. My 5150 is only 1 year and 4 months old, 4 months out of warranty. Never abused in any way. The power connection has become increasingly worse and now is to the point where my wife and I are afraid to touch it for fear of losing the power and never regaining it. I have spoke with tech support, Out-of-warranty dept, a Level 2 tech, and a supervisor. Each have told be basically tough luck. Sure I can get it fixed for 600-700 dollars. I would understand if I caused the problem, abused the notebook in some way, but I haven't. It seems like a case of shoddy manufacturing where the power connection to the motherboard can simply come loose. My last resort is to take it to a local PC shop and see if it came be fixed there. If not, I have a 1 year 4 month old, mint condition, non-working, $1,500, 10 lb. Dell brand paper weight. I am now resolute, I will never again buy anything from Dell. I'll sit here, working on my 4 year old desktop, which has never once given me any such hardware problems, and remember when customer satisfaction was important and quality craftsmanship was 1st among all else. By the way if anyone wants a beautiful 5150 Paperweight, it's only $1,000.
Responses (21)
Solutions (0)
- I too have the same type problem, over the last few weeks I have had to send our sons Inspiron 5150 back to dell for repair, fortunately his machine was still under warranty. After weeks of sending us batteries and power supplies the laptop was finally sent to dell for what appears to have been a new motherboard. My advise to him now will be to purchase the extended warranty because the units track record shows it will go down again after its first year of use.I was not so lucky, as my Inspiron 5100 stopped taking a charge a few weeks ago. We tried a new battery, no luck. The machine does not even recognize the ac power supply adapter when its plugged in, it did off and on for a while but now nothing. We could only get it to work off of battery, now that we can't charge it were looking at a machine we cannot use. The light for the power adapter comes on but nothing gets to the laptop. I don't understand why dell support cannot deal with this problem.If anyone has any other ideas on how to fix this I am listening.Thanks
- I tried that last night, It was not difficult getting the machine apart to take a look at it, but it did not look as if there was a obvious way to fix it. The connector on the motherboard side seemed solid. I am now down to less then 10% of the battery life. Some of the old time laptops use to come with a optional charger that would allow you to charge a battery in a cradle and have it available for replacement. It would be nice if such a tool was available as it would be a inexpensive fix since all I need is a hot battery for the machine to work. JK
Clinton Jones
3 Posts
502
0
Posted March 1st, 2005 15:00
I am thinking about opening the case and seeing if there is a visible problem where the power connetion meets the mother board. Perhaps there is a broken soder or something. I may just take it to a local PC guy I know and see if he can help. This one expereince has changed my outlook on Dell completely. Their lack of support for an obvious manufacting defect is appauling. I would send a letter to Micheal Dell if I thought it would ever reach him, but I highly doubt it. If anyone finds a solution such as fixing it yourself or having a repairman fix it, please post here so we too can use our $1,500 Dell paperweights once again.fenderguitarguy
328 Posts
502
0
Posted March 2nd, 2005 00:00
The problem that you are expiriencing is the same problem I had. The power port broke off of the motherboard. A temporary fix is to put pressure on top of the plug, pushing it down. The long term fix is to send it in to Dell to get the motherboard replaced. I suppose you could re-solder the connection. So, there is your answer, and it is an answer to a problem that many people are having. I hope that Dell can come up with a solution because after my warrenty runs out, I won't be able to afford the cost of a motherboard. I think that the 5150 would have less problems if the power port was on the side instead of the back.- ..And as my name screen name suggest I m left with a dead $1500 5150. Dell Support suggested the same motherboard replacement fix. I had posted earlier on this thread and seems many have similar issues... http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_power&message.id=31081&view=by_date_ascending&page=1
Any help welcome. - Phase I - Dell Support guy said - problem with power adapter, I replaced it, still no powerPhase II - Dell Support lady said - problem with palm rest, I replaced it, still no powerPhase II - Dell Support lady said - problem with mother board, I need to replace the mother board .. before this I post this forum note.Dell has not stood its quality. Seems many inspiron note books have power problem. Seems Dell is good marketing, but poor at design and quality. I had to have a paradigm shift on the image of Dell.So why I write, I some how missed to extend the warranty and now to buy the mother board, it will cost a fortune. I am thinking of building it on my own one. See it has the same risk as Dell.
- Well guys, I had the same problem as you. Luckilly mine is still under warrenty. A technitian came and replaced my motherboard, it worked fine for about 3 months then same problem. So I call again and get yet another motherboard, the next day (today) I find the exact SAME problem. Dell sends out refurbished mother boards by the way. So anyway, I'm making yet another request for a new mother board and the person I spoke to said if it fails a third time I may be able to get a refund or a replacement. Knowing my luck It will work until my warranty expires. Anyhow, what do you guys think is the problem? Is the power adaptor putting too much strain on the mother board since it's located directly in the back? What do you guys think. Also, keep me posted if anyone finds a fix.
PS: My advice for you is not to invest in another $600 motherboard if your warranty expired. Trust me, it will probably break again. Take the $1500 as a learning experience and never purchase a Dell product again. I know, it makes me feel sick too...
Thanks. Reminder to anyone who's purchased a warranty: under many state insurance commissions, a warranty is a policy of insurance and failure to live up to the obligation is a breach. An oft used sanction is a prohibition from selling futher warranty plans. How many Dell computers will be sold if Dell is prohibited from selling profitable extended warranties?
Therefore, you may have the right to file a complaint with your state insurance commission against Dell. You might also want to file an additional complaint with the Consumer Protection Division of your state Attorney General's office.
Ramblin Man
5 Posts
323
0
Posted March 16th, 2005 03:00
I thought I'd jump in here and vent.My new Dell Inspiron has been in my hands exactly 6 weeks when this problem started (last week). Long story short, after 1.5 hours on the phone with Indian techs, they tell me I can get it repaired at my home the next day. They connect me to (yet another) out-sourced tech support company. They laugh at my thought of getting repaired next day. They say they'll make an appointment for the following week (this week). They cancel yesterday's appointment b/c the part isn't in yet. They arrive today, replace the motherboard, and it still doesn't work. They said they want to order yet another motherboard b/c that "might" work and they'll try a new AC adapter b/c that "might" work too.I tried calling Dell today to speak to an (American) human with no luck. I won't bore you with the long details.I have been a big Dell fan having owned a few PC's, first laptop. I am not happy. I feel they are selling lemons after reading all the post on this board that have this problem. I'm trying to figure out a way to get a new replacement or a refund because I think this borders on a fraudulent transaction.Ramblin Man

thannon
1 Message
497
0
Posted February 28th, 2005 21:00
Recommends a motherboard replacement as I'm sure everyone is aware.
SIMILARLY I WILL NEVER BUY ANY DELL PRODUCT EVER AGAIN
(And will strongly advise everyone I know of the same)
Not my first experience with rubbish Dell support, laptop gave problems in the first two weeks, intermittent and random shut downs, and had to spend 3 more weeks convincing them there was a problem!!