UNSOLVED

demc7

updated

21 years ago

Closed

D

demc7

17 Posts

0

11336

September 4th, 2005 21:00

Inspiron 9300 screen options

I have been researching the screen options for the 9300, and have found very critical reviews of the WUXGA screen on cnet.com. Apparently there is leakage and a sparkle effrect of some sort. Reviews of the WXGA seem to be fine.
 
One possible source of this problem is the manufacturer. Samsung and Philips-LG monitors are used in the 9300, and the problems seem to lie with the LG. So I obviously want a Samsung panel. Is it possible to specify?
 
Maybe Samsung make the WXGA and LG make the WUXGA, that could explain it. Could somebodywith the WUXGA check which make screen they have? Thanks a lot as I really like the laptop.
 
 
If there is a risk with the screen I may just go for the Latitude X1 instead.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    895

    0

    Posted September 4th, 2005 21:00

    You cannot specify the internal components you get when you order the system.

    The X1 is an interesting mention with the 9300 - they're hardly competitive products. Do you need a large screen, with the compromise of a heavy bulky system, or a small ultraportable with less speed, video performance, etc?

    The X1 and 9300 are like apples and oranges feature-wise.
  • sanj76

    3 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 5th, 2005 03:00

    I have a Samsung WUXGA screen on mine, and have no problems with it.
  • DjSkeets

    25 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 5th, 2005 15:00

    some people only write those because they are peev'ed off because theirs accidently broke, they probably dropped it or something... dang complainers
  • DjSkeets

    25 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 5th, 2005 19:00

    If you have 200 dollars to waste on a screen with a bit higher of resolution, then go ahead, but its not necssary in my opinion. I forget what the res is for the cheaper monitor, but its WELL enough for me thats for sure.


    Chris
  • demc7

    17 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 5th, 2005 19:00

    Thanks for the replies. Thats a good point, that people are just complaining for the sake of it and it doesn't reflect the screen's quality.
     
    The X1 is completely different, yes, but I've now realised I'd prefer a large screen to portability.
     
    The only question that remains is WXGA or WUXGA.
  • 895

    0

    Posted September 6th, 2005 17:00

    WXGA vs. WUXGA.

    From my point of view there are two major considerations for choosing which one best meets your needs.

    1) How much information do you desire to display on the screen at same time.
    2) How good is your eye sight.

    If you want the ability to display more content on screen at once and your eye sight is good the WUXGA is my choice.  Otherwise WXGA.  Given same size screen a higher pixel count will mean smaller text.  So your eye sight needs to be good. 

    I have 8600 WUXGA (15.4 inch wide screen) and love it, but I have better than 20/20 vision.  The larger 17 inch screen of the 9300 would make it even better though.

    St. John 3:16 - More than just a sign at a sports event, read it, the book, and be cool.

    Dell® Inspiron® 8600
    Intel® Centrino® Mobile Technology

    Pentium® M Processor,1.4 GHz
    15.4 in WUXGA (Wide Aspect UltraSharp® Display)
    128MB nVidia® GeForce® FX Go 5650 4X AGP Graphics
    512MB,DDR,333MHz
    40GB Ultra ATA Hard Drive (replaced with 60GB 7200RPM)
    2x CD/DVD Burner (DVD+RW/+R)
    Intel® PRO/Wireless 2100 WLAN
    Dell® TrueMobile® 300 Bluetooth

    Message Edited by St. John 15.13 on 09-06-2005 11:44 AM

  • DjSkeets

    25 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 6th, 2005 19:00

    Hes basically saying the more expensive monitor has a higher resolution resulting in everything being crisper and SMALLER mainly. The higher the resolution, the smaller the objects are on the screen.


    Chris
  • demc7

    17 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 6th, 2005 19:00

    What exactly do you mean by perfect eyesight? I have perfect eyesight for nearby objects, but I cannot see distant objects 100% (I sometimes wear glasses just to view projectors). Is this sufficient to get a WUXGA? Also is it true that the TrueLife LCDs reduce glare/reflection?
  • spddemun

    92 Posts

    895

    0

    Posted September 9th, 2005 04:00

    I don't know if you've bought one yet, but I have the WXGA and I have slight light leak at bottom of screen (not sure if this is normal).  I've had mine about 30 days, and have not dropped it or abused it in any way.

    My eyesight is starting to fail, so I find the native res very hard to read; I had to lower it, so it's not as clear as "native", but easier to read.  Also, changed to large fonts (dpi) and that helped.

    On the downside, I feel there is a bright glare being so close to the screen (vs. my desktop flat panel).  Now knowing this, I might have opted for the WUXGA since it did appear to have less glare (XPS at mall kiosk).

    I read somewhere else on here that a person with not-perfect eyesight got the WUXGA and just switched to larger fonts and lower res and that seemed to work.

  • DjSkeets

    25 Posts

    154

    0

    Posted September 9th, 2005 11:00

    I dont think there is a light leak at all, I'll just have to see when I get mine in the mail.