UNSOLVED

Kev1972

updated

12 years ago

K

Kev1972

5 Posts

0

271868

December 29th, 2009 05:00

Inspiron 1525 Battery Not Charging

I bought a Inspiron 1525 in March 2008.  As of today the battery is not charging.  I called Dell and they told me that I needed a new battery.  After spending nearly $135 for a new battery, I am still having the same issue.  Unfortunately my laptop is out of warranty.  I have read the various forums on here to find a solution, but still nothing.  It seems this is a pretty regular issue with the Inspiron 1525 and other Dell laptops.  Can Dell come out and FINALLY say what the solution is?  Why is it so hard for them to say what the problem is.  It's pretty sad I spent $135 for battery after being told that was the solution.  Can anyone help me?  I've updated the BIOS, I blew into both recepticals, and yes, even tried a new battery.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1433

    0

    Posted December 29th, 2009 05:00

    If you have not yet tried a new Dell AC adapter, that's next.  If it doesn't solve the problem, the mainboard will need to be replaced.

     

  • Downix

    78 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted December 31st, 2009 04:00

    BIOS update, found at ftp://ftp.us.dell.com/bios/1525_A17.EXE   It is an issue with some intel northbridges used in laptops, so is common along several manufacturers, I had an HP with this very issue.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1427

    0

    Posted December 31st, 2009 04:00

    I haven't seen any statistical evidence that Dells are more prone to power failures than others - in fact, the HP you speak highly of is the one that has a much worse reliability record:
    http://www.lockergnome.com/blade/2009/11/17/notebook-reliability-asus-the-best-and-hp-the-worse-what-do-you-think/

     

  • Kev1972

    5 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted December 31st, 2009 04:00

    The mainboard?  I believe my adapter is working fine.  When I plug it in to my laptop it works fine.  You would think Dell would recall the inspiron 1525 and other laptops, being that this is a common issue.  If the mainboard needs to be replaced then I would think that would be quite expensive.  Better off to go buy a new one.  Probably will not be buying a Dell though.  I've had a HP laptop for almost 5 years now and had no issues.

  • richw46

    23 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted March 3rd, 2010 19:00

    The BIOS update won't work unless your battery is at least 10% charge; mine is zero. Can't charge because the BIOS needs to be upgraded and I can't apply the BIOS because the battery is 0% charge.

  • richw46

    23 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2010 08:00

    I purchased 2 of the 1525 laptops at the same time in November 2008; one for a friend. Oddly enough, they have different versions of the AC adapter.  The other one works fine on my laptop and charged the battery so I could apply the new BIOS.  After applying it did a reboot and when I logged in and checked the icon, it still said "plugged in, not charging".  I said 'Oh well, so much for that' and let it sit while I watched TV.  I came back later and it said 100% charged. I let it run on just the battery for a while, then plugged the adapter in again.  "Battery level 97%, charging".  So it seems to be charging again. We'll see how long it lasts.

  • parmsesean

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2010 23:00

    is it still working? I just put that bios in and its still saying the same thing..

  • richw46

    23 Posts

    1427

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2010 07:00

    After we did the BIOS upgrade the charger worked steady for about a couple of weeks. Now it works intermittently.  My son gets mad when the battery goes to zero because he has to shut down if he wants to move anywhere.  Other times the battery will charge for days at a time.

    His friend has an identical laptop; we purchased them together.  I can put my son's battery in the other laptop and it will charge. If I put my son's AC adapter on the other laptop it won't charge at all.  If I put the other laptop battery in my son's with the other charger, it works.  I don't see how it can be the mother board but that's what everyone says. I think it's a combination of things because Dell buys parts from many different suppliers.  I'd replace the AC adapter but others that have done this say it helps for only a few weeks then the problem returns. 

    I won't replace the mother board because it's too costly and too much work.  Because of all these problems I won't replace this 1525 with another Dell.  I'll be looking at HP for my next one and turn this one into a desktop until something else fails.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1427

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2010 10:00

    It sounds more like you have a faulty AC adapter - though it could be the power jack ( which is on a $100 power board, not the mainboard).

    Beware before buying HP-  their hardware is the least reliable out there and their support is bottom of the barrel.

     

  • richw46

    23 Posts

    722

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2010 11:00

    >It sounds more like you have a faulty AC adapter

    If the AC adapter were faulty, how could it provide enough power to run the laptop? It has a stated DC output which seems to be running the laptop just fine even though it's 'plugged in, not charging'.  It does this on the other 1525 too but posts in this forum state that replacing the adapter didn't solve the problem for very long, same as the BIOS upgrade.:emotion-40:

    > though it could be the power jack

    If the power jack was bad, why would the problem follow the adapter when I move it to another 1525 that doesn't experience the problem with its own AC adapter?

    Yes, I thought of these and I'm happy to have another properly functioning 1525 to test with.  I think it's the mother board and I'm not spending the money to replace it.  I own 4 Dells and the Dimension XPS Pro 200n is still chugging along. It stayed plugged in and running from 1997 to about 2004 when I bought the Dimension 4700 which I have to run with the side panel off to keep it from shutting down with an 'overheating' error, also fixed by replacing the motherboard.  The Inspiron 531 so far is running OK.  The 1525 laptop has its power error.  I thing it's time to move on, maybe not with HP but with another supplier.  I'll have to do some research.

    You'd think Dell would research this issue and provide a final fix for the problem.  People in this forum reported they've tried the BIOS upgrade, replaced the mother board and replaced the adapter only to have the problem return within a month or less.  For that kind of money I can buy another laptop.

    Thanks for your suggestions, though.  I appreciate the replies.:emotion-2:

    -Rich