
UNSOLVED
Closed
IMPORTANT ADVISE to all M1730 owner
Hi everyone.
As a big simmer I am since the last 25 years, I had lot of overheating problem with Dell's laptops I bought in the last 7 years. My Inspiron 5150 died because of that, my XPS Gen 2 burned 2 video cards in a year before being replaced with the M1710 (which is running pretty cool) and now I own the M1730. As this one is more powerful than the M1710, it run much hotter.
As I own my M1730 for less than a week, yesterday I did serious testing with the cooling fans while flying FS2004 for hours. The left side of the laptop is getting so hot causing me to feel like burning my finger when touching the metalic parts of the right side connector. Even by placing hockey pucks under the laptop to raise it sufficiently for better ventilation, the bottom keep too hot.
I turned the laptop on the side while flying to observe with a flashlight how the fans are working during a game or a sim running. The left video card's fan was working very badly. The thermo sensor controlled by the BIOS is not controlling the fan efficiently. The fan start for about less than a second, stop, start again 2 second later, stop, restart, etc etc etc. That's not sufficient to evacuate all the heat generated by the game. The middle fan is spinning continously at low speed and keep the bottom cool enough. Same for the CPU's fan. As the M1730 is my 5th Dell's laptop, beleive me if you don't do nothing about that, you are running for big troubles in less than a year. For those with a 1 year warranty, you are about to have big frustration with your nice machine. Fortunately, I always bought 3 years warranties so I never ran out of warranty with overheating problem.
I did some test with I8kfanGUI V3.1 founded here:
http://www.diefer.de/i8kfan/index.html and let me tell you, this little software I was using on my M1710 is perfect for M1730 too. I was awared that the software doesn't control the 3rd fan and I was anxious to know if I would be able to use it or not. So I ran the software with manual fan control at minimum speed and observed how the 3rd fan was reacting. I stopped manually both CPU and left video card fans to see if the middle one was still spinning and it was. I restarted the fan manually at low speed and beleive me, the left part of the laptop was running pretty cool. No more heat. Just running so cool that I can't get any overheating problem in the future. The three cooling fans are evacuating the heat so efficiently on this laptop, but they have to work constantly to do the job. The middle fan is still controlled by the BIOS even if you force the other two to stop manually. So don't worry, run this software and you will keep your laptop in a very good health for years. During my game play, I did check the middle fan very very often, and it never stop spinning until I quit the game.
Be advised you are running toward overheating problem if you don't act now. After all, Dell is giving wrong video drivers for this laptop, and the BIOS is not controlling the fans correctly, so I don't see any problem forcing the fans to run low speed continously to keep it cooler. Dell offer a very good technical service when your latpop is still under warranty, but as soon it expire, you are by your own.... Better prevent now.
Andre.
Responses (17)
Solutions (0)
- PlatelleftLike I mentionned in my post, Dell is not able to supply good video drivers for this laptop and are not really in a hurry to make the 169.09 driver official, so how they are able to approve that kind of software? Also, like I mentionned in my post, this is the 4th laptop I bought from Dell (as the M1710 is a replacement of my Gen 2), I spent more than $20,000 CDN in 7 years for these laptop !!! Beleive me I want to protect them the most I can by using unofficial software which help me keeping them running cool. I know Dell's laptop suffer overheating problem. I have been great success cooling my M1710 with a cooling base and this software. So don't worry, protect your investment and you will be very happy it will not die before the end of your warranty. The best thing you can do is controlling the temperatures within the laptop with this software so you can always know if it goes too hot in the future and you can take action right away. Also, place hockey pucks under the back part to raise it for better ventilation.The BIOS is not controlling the fans of any Dell's laptop correctly.Andre.
Platellaleft
25 Posts
765
0
Posted December 27th, 2007 07:00
169.09 driver?. Yes I do concern myself that it is getting to hot I take your point .Thanks PlatPlatellaleft
25 Posts
765
0
Posted December 27th, 2007 08:00
this program looks great and I do notknow why dell did not incorperate this with the unit.are there standard tempreture setting if so is this manufacture recomendations.PlatellaleftPlatellaleft
25 Posts
765
0
Posted December 27th, 2007 08:00
HI! I do not know how long the fans can run at high speed do you set them for slow or auto.Platellleft- Hi.You don't need to let the fan spinning high speed. Just set them manually to slow speed. Here what you have to pay attention to make sure the fans will start at every bootup.TAB AUTOSTARTCheck enable autostartCheck autostart only on ACCheck enable automatic fan setting (set to slow speed)TAB TEMPERATURE CONTROLSet policies to Normal (its the lowest temperature control)Tab CPU, check enable CPU temperature control, enable first fan and second fanTAB DISPLAY OPTIONCheck enable status histrory diagramTAB STATUS READINGCheck EVERY case on this page and click YES to every warning messageTAB DIRECT FAN CONTROLCheck select fans for forcing high speed first and second fan (do not check enable hardware support sensor as it don't work)TAB ICON SETTINGSCheck transparent backgroundCheck enable fan speed iconCheck transparent backgrondTAB MISCELLEANOUSCheck only minimize to tray when closing main windowTAB ADVANCEDNothing to doThats it.Now everytime you will boot your machine, the fans will start slow speed and you will be able to monitor the temperature by moving your mouse over the icon in the task bar. But just feel how cool your laptop left part casin will remain cool with this software. In all time you can select automatic temperature control to give back full control of the fans by the BIOS. When playing a game, you can set back to manual and click APPLY to return back to manual control. Very important to apply to accept the change.ONCE AGAIN, don't worry as the middle fan is BIOS controlled more efficiently than the left fan.Andre.
Platellaleft
25 Posts
789
0
Posted December 28th, 2007 06:00
is the chip set temp ok 61c 62c sorry to bother you but you are the one who knowsPeterPlatellaleft
25 Posts
765
0
Posted December 28th, 2007 06:00
Hi! this program is great, computer running cooler, thank you very much for sharing what you know with others AndrePeter- HiYour welcome.Usually the temperature going to the hightest point is the CPU's temp which may go as high as 68º C but the chipset and all others temp should range in the 50s not really going higher than 60º C. But it depend which game your are playing. That vary depending how your game require ressources from the system. At least your temp don't go higher than 65º C, you are ok. Did you put something under your laptop to raise the back by about 2 inches ??? Hockey pucks are ideal. While playing your game, control the airflow evacuated from the back to be sure all your three fans are spinning. If all of them are spinning, everything work correctly.Andre.
Platellaleft
25 Posts
565
0
Posted December 29th, 2007 01:00
Hi All OK thanks, had my comp raised already.happy computing

Platellaleft
25 Posts
765
0
Posted December 27th, 2007 02:00