UNSOLVED

UMassRob

updated

24 years ago

U

UMassRob

349 Posts

0

27133

October 17th, 2002 11:00

Memory on 8250

Does anyone know why the Dimension 8250 can only support 1.5 GB of PC1066 RDRAM ... while it can (along with the 8200) handle 2 GB of PC800 RDRAM?

They both use the Intel 850E chipset and have 4 slots for memory.

Is it because PC1066 is harder to get?

 

  • 730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 12:00

       Simply because the bandwidth is greater with PC1066 and you do not need as much memory. Straight from Dell's mouth.

    Dimension 8200 2.53Ghz 533Mhz

    1024MB Samsung PC800 40NS RDRAM
    2) 120GB ( Total: 240GB ) Western Digital Ultra ATA/100 7200RPM Hard Drives w/8MB Cache
    Promise FastTrack 100TX2 Raid 0 Array Card
    128MB Nvidia GeForce Ti4600 Graphic Card
    Turtle Beach/Santa Cruz DSP Sound Card
    Altec Lansing THX Certified ADA995 5.1 Dolby Digital 6 Speaker System
    Dell Ultra Sharp 2000FP 20.1 inch Flat Panel LCD Monitor
    16X DVD-Rom Drive
    48X/24X/48X CD-RW Drive
    Win XP Home
    Microsoft Intellimouse Explorer

     

    Message Edited by SpongeBob_Sq_P_ on 10-17-2002 08:46 AM

  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 13:00

    Dell's mouth is wrong. The amount of memory you need is independent of the memory speed. If the application doesn't fit, then you basically run at the speed the hard drive can swap, which is much slower than even PC100 SDRAM! There are very few people for which 1.5GB would be a problem. Most people probably wouldn't see a speedup with more than 256MB of RAM. If someone really needs RAM, then buy the Precision 530 Workstation which will take 4GB (as well as dual, hyperthreaded Xeon processors!)
  • 730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 18:00

    I'm glad you noticed this is what Dell said and not me. I did call and this was the answer Dell gave me. As far as I'm concerned, who needs 1.5Gb of memory? 
  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 19:00

    Few people indeed. I run some CAD applications and have never used more than about 400MB. I've got 512MB on those systems. If somebody truely does have a program that needs 2GB, then they would be MUCH better off with a 8200 than an 8250, no matter what Dell says!

    (I take it somebody disagrees with me because of the 1-* vote. :-()
  • -Friendlyname-

    2 Intern

    •

    858 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 20:00

    Talmy,

    Some of us have our star givers receivers turned off!!!    :)

    Regards,

    Jane

  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 20:00

    I didn't like the idea of the stars either, but haven't given up yet.
  • UMassRob

    349 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 17th, 2002 23:00

    You probably received the 1 star because you posted a response that had very little to do with my original question.

    I wanted to know why the 8250 only supports 1.5 GB of PC1066 while it can take 2.0 GB of PC800.

    You responded with comments about who needs that much memory ... which was not relevant.  Sorry.

    Thank you anyway for the input.

     

  • CMB

    2 Intern

    •

    181 Posts

    641

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2002 00:00

    Not to be a jerk, but does this really matter??

    Oh and about the 1+ GB of memory. Now you say you dont need that much. But in the future you will think it ist enough. Like HD's back then 500 MB was a lot, now 80 GB isnt enough.

  • UMassRob

    349 Posts

    730

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2002 00:00

    Thank you for the response.

    So ... can one conclude that PC800 uses less power and creates less heat?

    Please advise.

     

  • 730

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2002 00:00

    1)  Dell Dimension 8250's are configured with 250-Watt power supplies.  They do not have enough power to run 2GB of PC1066 RDRAM and provide platform stability.

    2)  Dell Dimension 8250's do not provide good thermal management...  Not enough case fans to dissipate the heat generated from 2GB of PC1066 RDRAM.