UNSOLVED

TCU_Z06

updated

12 years ago

T

TCU_Z06

3 Posts

0

9445

August 16th, 2014 14:00

Quick Question - Long Complaint

Posted this elsewhere but was told to put it here... First the question, I have an Aurora R4 from 2002 tag [Amin Note: Service Tag Edited per TOU policy]. Unfortunately out of warranty. Recently the video card died (which I replaced), then two memory sticks died (which I replaced) and for the final act, the CPR finally capitulated. I am replacing the CPU right now and need to know whether the liquid cooler should be oriented as exhaust for intake. Also, should the Alienhead on the waterblock be facing the top of the case?. This seems to cause the line to twist the least. Now the complaints. No more than 6 months after purchase, the motherboard died and I had it replaced under warranty. In hindsight, I would have been much better off doing it myself. Below is a list of the mistakes made by the tech while installing the motherboard 1. Did not reconnect the memory cooling fan 2. Did not reconnect the fan attached to the weird looking radiator right above the CPU. 3. The wires were in complete disarray. Not tied down, not it the channels designed for that purpose and effectively destroying an cohesive airflow within the case which always seemed to run hot. Now the important stuff 4. The fan for the liquid cooler was set as pull (mounted directly to the case) and as exhaust. Frankly I have never seen this configuration on back mounted radiators. Set as pull and oriented as exhaust it pulling the above average hot air from inside the case across the radiator in the least efficient manner (push > pull). It also seems that the water block is turned the wrong way, facing the front drive bays and causing the lines to twist at extreme angles. 5. There was NO thermal grease, none, nada, no trace and the core on top of the CPU was scorched. 6. A loose wire was lodged in the video card fan, preventing it from turning and, I assume, causing its death. 7. And finally, he left while the system was on a blue screen of death. It never did boot so I went down and bought a copy of Windows 8.1 Pro and installed it myself and the system then functioned but with sporadic reboots. The computer was my daughters and I was not aware that she was receiving numerous BSODs. She just assumed rebooting your computer 10 times a day was normal so I did not find out soon enough to catch the problem and I am kicking myself for not checking the techs work To top it off, I was treated extremely rudely just a few minutes ago when I called tech support only to find out if the liquid cooler should be set to intake or exhaust. I know it is out of warranty, but there has to be an exception when your system was effectively guaranteed to fail in short order by the ineptitude by an employee. I used to be an ardent supporter of dell and alienware but not more. If there is any consolation, this happened before I purchased about 50 systems for a company that I am starting. What do you think? Should entitled to some restitution? Though our of warranty, none of these problems were due to the standard wear and tear from typical use but instead cause by an inept dell sponsored tech who installed the mother board. I spent $2500 on the PC and no another 1,500 getting it back running. In all my years of both building and buying PCs, I have NEVER encountered anything remotely close to this travesty. I am not a complainer, I hate complainers, but this has broken past my generally benevolent nature not to mention crushing my finances. Regardless, before starting a campaign of logging horrendous reviews on every social media sight I know of, including , I figured I would give dell the opportunity to make things right. A refund or material store credit at a minimum. Does anyone agree that I have a valid complaint. If so where should I really post this. I'm not a message board guy, this it just the first one I came across Thanks for any advice, Robby

  • amric1

    52 Posts

    675

    0

    Posted August 16th, 2014 16:00

    The alienhead on the pump should be facing you when you open the panel. AW sets the fan up as exhaust, pulling the air through the radiator. Some members have reported lower temps setting them up as intake/push when changing to aftermarket cooling solutions after the the oem one failed, as some tend to gel up over time. How long have you waited since the warranty work was done?
  • TCU_Z06

    3 Posts

    675

    0

    Posted August 16th, 2014 22:00

    work was done about 18 months ago. I'm surprised it took so long for the components to die. I tried various configs, and finally trashed the radiator fan than was included. Installed two fairly cheap sickle fans in push pull. Definitely set to intake. That exhaust stuff is nonsense. There are not enough fans, wait there are no fans actually pulling in outside air, at least with mine which has no venting. Temp diff was 3 degrees at ambient at 20 at 100% load (higher = exhaust). I think the thing that hacks me off the most was the brush-off I got from tech support when I called in with the simple intake vs exhaust question. I should have just tested it myself but maybe I was just looking for a little pat on the back, I'm sorry kind of thing. He just said send an EMAIL. I needed an answer then not 72 hours later. Mostly I'm just angry at myself for not inspecting the techs work who installed the new mobo. I've built a number of systems, mainly back when I was younger and I just got lazy. Even though the only apparent "support" I got from the Alienware mods were to point out my egregious posting violations, I'm actually kind of glad they deleted the ID #. It's probably the only way to track back to the hack who did the repair work and I don't really want to get anyone fired. I'm recently unemployed myself which made the repair bill that much tougher to cough up. I probably should have just trashed it but my daughter absolutely loves it so I had to hit up Mr. credit card for a loan. Two other things I found as I endeavored to get the thing running was LESS than half the mobo screws were even installed, lol. To top it off, the 8 pin additional mobo plug, which I can now assume is optional as long as you are not really pushing it, was not plugged in. Oh well, as the mods deemed fit to edit out my comments/threats which amount to little more than a Styrofoam bat when dealing with Dellzilla I guess I will go ahead a follow through with them. Exactly when did a contrite, seemingly sincere apology disappear from Corporate America. All I got was a bunch of flak about posting violations. Just a little extra twist of the knife.
  • Tesla1856

    10 Wizard

    •

    18086 Posts

    •

    71947 Points

    675

    0

    Posted August 16th, 2014 23:00

     1. wait there are no fans actually pulling in outside air,

    2. To top it off, the 8 pin additional mobo plug, which I can now assume is optional as long as you are not really pushing it, was not plugged in.

    1. I thought all Aurora's had the PCIe Fan ... pulling in cool air from the front.

    2. That is real poor work. I thought the 8 pinner was voltage for the main processor. I didn't know it would even run without that connected.

    Good you had the skills to clean up this repair and finish it properly ... most people don't.

     

    Dell Rockstar

    Microsoft Windows and Apple iOS Developer (Retired)
    - Like many of you, I can appreciate a good game-engine.
    - I answer questions here, but I'm not a Dell employee.
    - Consider giving posts you like a "thumbs-up"
    - Posting models-numbers and software versions speeds trouble-shooting.
    - Click "Mark as Accepted Answer" on any post that answers your question best.